Microsoft word - anova ejaf msm assessment full report v5.docx
Anova Health Institute, November 2013
McIntyre, J., Jobson, G., Struthers, H. De Swardt, G., Rebe, K. Rapid Assessment of HIV Prevention, Care and Treatment Programming for MSM in South Africa. Assessment Report 2013, Anova Health Institute, Johannesburg. Available at: http://www.anovahealth.co.za
The Anova Health Institute acknowledges the assistance of the fol owing people in the preparation of this report: Candice Harrison-Train and Carmel Marock of Singizi Consulting, Anne Aslett and Mohamed Osman of the Elton John AID Foundation, Tim Lane, Zach Isdahl and Alex Marr of UCSF and all the respondents who so willingly contributed their expertise.
The Elton John AIDS Foundation funded the assessment.
This report is based on the findings of the rapid assessment, reporting of respondent views and the authors' opinions and the views expressed do not necessarily represent those of the Anova Health Institute or the Elton John AIDS Foundation.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acronyms and Abbreviations
Part 1: Review of available information on MSM in South Africa
Key MSM groups
MSM, sex workers and transactional sex
Structural issues impacting MSM
South African MSM Population Size Estimates: Current Status
MSM Population Size Estimation Methods
An example of MSM population size estimates in Mpumalanga
PART 2: MSM In South Africa – A Review Of The Policy Environment
MSM Policy Introduction
South African Government Policy and HIV in MSM
South African Government Policy regarding other Key Populations
National policies in development or under review
International organisations policies and guidelines
PART 3: Current MSM Related HIV Prevention And Treatment Programmes,
Gaps And Opportunities
Current prevention programmes
Research into acceptability of and needs for prevention programme design
Prevention with HIV positive MSM
Prevention and pleasure interventions
Gaps and opportunities for HIV prevention interventions
MSM in relationships
MSM Sex workers and transactional sex
MSM and structural issues
HIV Care and Treatment for MSM
Current Treatment programmes
Support for MSM Targeted programming
Service gaps and program opportunities
Sexual y Transmitted Infections
PART 4: MSM programming in South Africa: Key Stakeholders views
A. Introduction and Methodology
4. A Methodology
4. B: MSM Policies and Guidelines
Non-Governmental Respondents (including Donors and NGOs)
4. C: MSM and HIV Services and Programmes
Summary of MSM Programming and Services
Governmental Service Provision
Non-Governmental Service Provision
National Department of Health
Provincial Departments of Health
Eastern Cape Department of Health
Free State Provincial Department of Health
Gauteng Department of Health
KwaZulu Natal Provincial Department of Health
Limpopo Department of Health
Northern Cape Department of Health
North West Provincial Department of Health
MPUMALANGA PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
Western Cape Department of Health
Non Governmental Sector
The Anova Heath Institute
Diamond Gays and Lesbians Organisation
Durban Lesbian and Gay Community Health Centre
ECGLA (Eastern Cape Gay and Lesbian Association)
Limpopo LGBTI Proudly Out
National LGBTI Health Campaign
OUT LGBT Wel being
Wits Reproductive Health and HIV Institute (Wits RHI)
Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation
South African Gay and Lesbian Al iance Against Defamation (GLAAD) 75 The Networking Hiv/Aids Community Of South Africa (NACOSA)
Summary of Reach of Non-Governmental Services and Programmes
MSM Work supported by Donor, Technical Support and Umbrel a Organisations
South African National AIDS Council (SANAC)
SANAC LGBTI Sector
Right To Care/ GLOBAL FUND PR
US Centres for Disease Control AND PREVENTION (CDC)
4.D: Research on MSM and HIV
Research on MSM HIV Incidence and Prevalence
Government Data on MSM HIV Incidence and Prevalence
Other Sources of MSM HIV Incidence and Prevalence Data
Other Areas of Research on MSM
Anova Health Institute
Gauteng Department of Health
Centres for Disease Control
Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation
Durban Lesbian and Gay Community and Health Centre
4.E: Gaps, Opportunities and Priorities
Non Governmental Perceptions
Data and Research
A Coordinated National Response
Considering Specialised Facilities
Specific MSM Groupings
4.F: Summary of Findings
MSM Policies and Guidelines
MSM and HIV Services and Programmes
Governmental Service Provision
Non-Governmental Service Provision
Research on MSM and HIV
Research on MSM HIV Incidence and Prevalence
Other Areas of Research on MSM
Gaps, Opportunities and Priorities
Non Governmental Perceptions
Data and Research
A Coordinated National Response
Considering Specialised Facilities
Specific MSM Groupings
PART 5: MSM programming in South Africa Priority Actions
Summary Priority Recommendations
Care & Treatment
Prevention messaging and communication
Condoms and lubricant
Civil Society and Structural Interventions
Moving forward with priority actions
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
African Men for Sexual Health and Rights
Adjusted Odds Ratio
Anti Retroviral Therapy
Behavioural Surveil ance Survey
Community Based Organisation
Country Coordinating Mechanism (for the Global Fund)
Centres for Disease Control
Community Health Centre
Community of Practice
Couples-based voluntary counsel ing and testing
Diffusion of Behavioural Interventions
Department of Health
Department of Public Service and Administration
Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation
Eastern Cape Gay and Lesbian Association
Enhancing Children's HIV Outcomes
Enzyme Linked Immunosorbent Assay
Gender Based Violence
Gay and Lesbian Al iance Against Defamation
Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria
HIV Counsel ing and Testing
Human Immunodeficiency Virus
Humanist Institute for Cooperation
Human Sciences Research Council
International Centre for AIDS Care and Treatment Programmes
Intravenous Drug User
Information, Education and Communication
Knowledge, Attitude, Practice
Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex
Most at risk populations
Medical Education Partnerships Initiative
Medical Male Circumcision
Memorandum of Understanding
Men who have Sex with Men
Networking HIV/AIDS Community of South Africa
National Alliance of State and Territorial Directors
National Department of Health
Non Governmental Organisation
National Institute of Health (US)
National Strategic Plan for HIV, STIs and TB (2012-2016)
Orphans and Vulnerable Children
President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief
Primary Health Care
Peri Natal HIV Research Unit
Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission
Reproductive Health Research Unit
Southern African Development Community
South African Government
South African National AIDS Council
South African National Council on Alcoholism
Sexual HIV Prevention Program
Short Message Service
Soweto HIV/AIDS Counsel ors Association
Sexual y Transmitted Infection
Sex Worker Education and Advocacy Task Force
Translating Research into Practice
Unprotected anal intercourse
University of California, San Francisco
United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS
United States Agency for International Development
Wits Reproductive Health and HIV Institute
Young men who have sex with men
Men who have sex with men (MSM) in South Africa are an under-served group in terms of HIV prevention, treatment, and care services. While HIV-related services in South Africa in general have been scaled up rapidly and effectively over the last decade this scale up has not included a specific focus on MSM. This is largely due to the generalised nature of the South African HIV epidemic. However, recent research with MSM in South Africa has revealed that, as in the rest of the world, these men have a high risk of HIV infection and are disproportionately affected by the HIV epidemic.
The purpose of this assessment is to provide a better understanding of responses to HIV for MSM populations, both by the government and non-governmental sectors, and to identify areas of need for enhanced programming.
The rapid assessment has been completed in the context of an increase in interest in MSM programming in South Africa and in the region, partly due to major funders such as the Global Fund and PEPFAR advocating for funding for this, and high level political support in South Africa from both the South African National AIDS Council (SANAC) and the National Department of Health. This assessment happens at a time when some proposed strategies and guidelines are stil being planned but, at this point, MSM-targeted HIV prevention, treatment and care programming appears to remain minimal, and is regularly undertaken by NGO or community groups, and not taken to scale in the country.
This report provides a description of the programmes and services currently made available to MSM, and explores the extent to which research is being conducted in terms of the prevalence and incidence of MSM with HIV. The report also reviews perceptions of key role-players in terms of key gaps, areas of opportunity, and current priorities.
The rapid assessment includes the fol owing core components:
1. Desktop review of published and grey literature on MSM in South Africa; 2. Desktop review of the South African policy environment for MSM; 3. Rapid review of existing and planned programming for HIV prevention,
testing, counsel ing and treatment and care services;
4. Review of perceptions of MSM programming needs, gaps and priorities in
terms of the above.
REVIEW OF AVAILABLE INFORMATION ON MSM IN SOUTH AFRICA
Estimating the number of MSM in South Africa is difficult due to the lack of
generalisable epidemiological research that has included questions on same sex
behaviour. However, based on the data that is available, estimates of the total
population of MSM range from 750 0001 (Imrie et al., 2013) to 1 360 0002 (Dunkle et
al., 2013). The potential for more accurate methods of estimating population sizes of
key populations in South Africa are discussed in more detail below (pg. 21).
One of the critical chal enges related to developing HIV treatment, care and prevention interventions for MSM in South Africa is the diverse nature of the MSM population in the country. Because MSM is a broad behavioural category, it includes men who identify as heterosexual, homosexual, bisexual as wel as biological y male transgender or gender queer individuals. In addition to comprising multiple gender
1 Based on a figure of 3.2% of male participants in the HSRC's 2008 HIV prevalence survey
reporting same sex sexual behaviours.
2 This figure is our own calculation based on Dunkle et al.'s finding that 5.4% of their generalisable sample of South African men reported any lifetime consensual same sex sexual
identities and sexual orientations, MSM in South Africa are also differentiated along racial, age, and socio-economic lines (cf. Tucker, 2009).
Adding further to the complexity of understanding MSM as a key population in South Africa is the fact that MSM social identities, social dynamics, and risky behaviours also differ geographically, both between particular regions, and across the rural/urban divide. Research on MSM in metropolitan areas in South Africa has documented diverse sexual and social identities. Sexual identities are also thoroughly entwined with race in South Africa. For example, several authors document the existence of fairly disparate sexual identities among MSM in Cape Town between various race groups (Swarr, 2004, Tucker, 2009, Visser, 2003). This in turn affects the social and sexual contexts of HIV risk among these men.
HIV prevalence rates among MSM in South Africa range from 10.4% to 34.5% across
different studies (Lane, 2013, Lane et al., 2011, Rispel and Metcalf, 2009, Tucker et al.,
2013, Baral et al., 2011). Research with South African MSM has found that their risk of
HIV infection is driven by multiple personal, interpersonal, and structural factors
(Arnold et al., 2013, Knox et al., 2010, Nel et al., 2013, Tun et al., 2012, Jobson et al.,
2013). In the studies reviewed, HIV risk was most frequently understood as
inconsistent condom use for anal intercourse. However, several studies also used HIV
positive status as an indicator of HIV risk.
At a personal level HIV risk in the South African MSM population has been found to be associated with: sexual identity (Lane, 2013); mental health status (Tucker et al., 2013); endorsing HIV related conspiracy beliefs (Tun et al., 2012); beliefs about trust and condom use in intimate relationships (Knox et al., 2010); and drug and alcohol use (Lane et al., 2008c, Parry et al., 2008). Vu et al. (2011) report high levels of internalised homophobia in their sample of MSM from Tshwane (Pretoria), and note an association between internalised homophobia and HIV related misinformation, which in turn affects individuals' likelihood of engaging in risky behaviours. Importantly, these personal factors are also affected by MSMs' relationships with each other and with the communities they live in.
Several studies have documented the interpersonal and local level community factors that affect HIV risk among MSM. The high levels of discrimination experienced by MSM across the country have been repeatedly documented (Baral et al., 2011, Cloete et al., 2008, Lane et al., 2008a, Rispel et al., 2011, Jobson et al., 2013), and have been linked to HIV risk among MSM. Baral et al. (2011), for example found that human rights violations were common in their sample of MSM in Cape Town, and that being blackmailed was significantly associated with HIV infection (Baral et al., 2011). Discrimination and the fear of discrimination at clinics and health care centres has also been documented in several studies, particularly with regard to seeking
care for sexual y transmitted infections (STIs) (Lane et al., 2008a, Rispel et al., 2011, Jobson et al., 2013). Delaying or neglecting treatment for STIs is an important risk for HIV transmission.
The intimate relationships between MSM also directly affect their risk of HIV infection. In their discussion of contextual factors associated with unprotected anal sex in a sample of MSM from Soweto, Arnold et al. (2013) found that rates of unprotected anal intercourse were significantly higher with partners described as ‘regular', and the authors suggest that a focus on trust, love and the regularity of anal intercourse in HIV prevention interventions for MSM may be a useful complement to other HIV prevention initiatives.
The broader contexts in which MSM live have also received attention as important factors driving HIV risk. These contexts include the socio-economic, and the cultural aspects of MSM's lives. Cultural and religious contexts that include intolerance of homosexuality may contribute to HIV risk directly and indirectly through various causal paths. Indirectly, these contextual factors may contribute to depression and lower self-esteem, which have been linked to increased rates of unprotected anal intercourse (cf. Alvy et al., 2010, Tucker et al., 2013). More directly, social exclusion due to homophobic cultural and social contexts limits the ability of MSM to access care and appropriate HIV prevention materials (such as condoms, water based lubricants, and MSM specific risk reduction information), which in turn increases their HIV infection risk (Arnold et al., 2013, Jobson et al., 2013).
The likelihood of transmission of HIV between MSM is dependent on several factors,
including: the route of acquisition, the infecting viral load, and the presence of
inflammation and activated immune system cel s below mucosal surfaces. In terms
of sexual risk, unprotected anal intercourse, and particularly receptive anal
intercourse carries a very high risk of HIV transmission, approximately 18 times that of
penile-vaginal intercourse (Rebe et al., 2011a).
HIV transmission is also affected by the presence of other STIs. For example, prevalent herpes simplex virus type 2 (HSV-2) has been found to be associated with a threefold increased risk of HIV infection (Freeman et al., 2006); similarly, syphilis (Buchacz et al., 2004) and gonorrhoea and Chlamydia (Bernstein et al., 2010), are also associated with increased risk of HIV infection.
The progression of HIV infection to AIDS is also affected by a range of factors.
Broadly, these can be classified as lifestyle/behavioural and HIV management
related factors, immune system factors and infection and co-infection specific
In terms of lifestyle and behaviour related factors, HIV progression is affected by heavy alcohol consumption, with alcohol having a negative impact on CD4 count in HIV positive individuals not receiving ART (Samet et al., 2007), additional y alcohol and drug use may negatively affect adherence to ART regimes, which also has negative impacts on HIV progression (Hinkin et al., 2004). Adherence to ART is critical in managing HIV progression and there is a range of issues that need to be considered in working with HIV positive MSM with regard to medication adherence. Stoloff et al. (2013), for example, note the high burden of common mental disorders among MSM attending Health4Men's clinic in Cape Town, and point to the importance of understanding the role of mental health in affecting ART adherence. Equal y, medication adherence may be negatively affected by individuals' socio-economic status (Geng et al., 2010, Sahay et al., 2011), and local levels of HIV related stigma (cf. Rao et al., 2007).
Individuals immune response to HIV infection may also vary, and this in turn can affect the rate at which their infection progresses. Equally, the particular strain of HIV with which individuals are infected may also influence the rate at which their disease progresses. Co-infection with other viruses and infectious diseases may also affect HIV progression.
KEY MSM GROUPS
Research in South Africa on HIV among MSM to date has tended to take a rather
undifferentiated view of the MSM population. Where differences are noted these
tend to be based on race, residential location (peri-urban townships vs.
urban/suburban), or substance use. While this research has revealed a range of
important issues that need to be addressed in HIV prevention for MSM, there remains
a need for more granular and nuanced approaches to this population. Based on
both local and international literature, we note the need for an increased focus on:
age group, relationship status, sex work, HIV positive MSM, and substance use in
work with MSM. A more differentiated and targeted approach to HIV prevention is
likely to enable organisations to tailor interventions and messaging to specific
population groups based on their specific needs.
There is very limited research in South Africa that focuses on young (aged <25) MSM
specifical y. However, international evidence suggests that these men may have a
relatively high risk of HIV infection (Val eroy et al., 2000). Beck et al (2012) note that
young MSM (YMSM) face a number of unique vulnerabilities that increase their risk of
HIV infection. Where YMSM are dependent on their families for income, housing, and
support, they are at risk of losing these resources if their sexuality is not accepted by
their family members (Beck et al., 2012). The loss of stable housing and income are
both associated with increased HIV risk (Leaver et al., 2007). Globally, Beck et al
(2012) found that YMSM experienced significantly higher levels of homophobia and
violence than older MSM, and simultaneously reported lower levels of community
engagement, comfort with service providers and connection to the gay community
than older MSM. The combined effect of these factors increases HIV risk for YMSM by
limiting their access to support services and HIV prevention resources (Beck et al.,
It is clear then that YMSM may face challenges related to disclosing their sexual orientation or sexual behaviours in various contexts, including within their families, among friends, and in health care settings. The broadly homophobic nature of South African society means that disclosure, or coming out as gay, is a potential y risky undertaking which may lead to withdrawal of support, and increased stigma, violence, and discrimination (Henderson and Shefer, 2008). This in turn may increase individuals' risk of HIV infection through the mechanisms noted above.
Other studies, primarily in the United States, have identified a range of risk factors for HIV infection among YMSM. These include: having high lifetime numbers of male sex partners (Valleroy et al., 2000); lower levels of education (Balaji et al., 2013); alcohol and drug use prior to sex (Newcomb, 2013, Balaji et al., 2013); experiences of violence or threats of violence (Koblin et al., 2006); intimate relationship characteristics (Mustanski et al., 2011); and having an older partner (Mustanski et al., 2011).
It is likely that some or al of these issues also affect young MSM in South Africa, but research is lacking. One study conducted with YMSM at a South African university found relatively high levels of consistent condom use (70% reported always using condoms), but also noted the relative frequency of experiencing violence and abuse, as wel as alcohol and drug use during sexual intercourse (Brink, 2012).
Data from Ivan Toms Centre for Men's Health shows that there are also differences between younger and older MSM in terms of their sexual identities and race. Among black clients, younger MSM were more likely to self-identify as gay or homosexual, while older MSM tended to identify as bisexual; this difference did not exist among white or coloured clients (Jobson et al., 2011). Differences in sexual identity may be associated with differences in HIV risk, and Lane (2013) for example, found that gay
or transgender identifying participants in their study in Mpumalanga had higher odds of testing positive for HIV than those who identified as straight or bisexual.
HIV-related interventions targeting YMSM specifical y are likely to form an important part of the evolving response to the HIV epidemic in key populations in South Africa. By targeting YMSM as a group in their own right it wil be possible to tailor interventions to address the specific needs and chal enges faced by these individuals, which will have long term effects on their HIV risk across their lifetimes.
Fol owing the logic of age group specific HIV interventions, it is also necessary to
examine the HIV risks among older MSM (older than 45 years) in South Africa. Sankar
et al (2011) note that age can be conceptualised as both the chronological age of
the biological body, and the cultural life course stage. A life course stage is defined
by a society's age-related expectations and its norms around social y constructed
age groups and the transitions between these age groups (Sankar et al., 2011). Both
the biological and social aspects of aging may therefore affect older MSM's HIV
In terms of the socio-cultural aspects of aging, the social and sexual norms and expectations for older MSM may differ substantial y from those of other men in their age group, and these norms and expectations could also affect their HIV risk (Lyons et al., 2010). Murray and Adam (2001) for example found that older gay men experience concerns about living up to the idealised standards of younger gay men, fears about losing their desirability, and feelings of worthlessness. Older gay men also suffered from depression and isolation more frequently than younger gay men (Murray and Adam, 2001). Heath et al. (2012) note that these psychosocial factors may lead older gay men to engage in riskier sexual behaviours as a means of attempting to fulfil their emotional needs.
It is also important to understand that patterns of well-recognised HIV risks may differ between younger and older MSM, and that it is not necessarily appropriate to target older and younger MSM with the same types of interventions (cf. Salomon et al., 2008).
In terms of the biological aspects of the aging process, the increasing rates of erectile dysfunction associated with increased age may also affect HIV risk (Heath et al., 2012). For example, older MSM may be tempted to forgo condom use if they find that using condoms makes it more difficult for them to get or maintain erections. Becoming infected with HIV at an older age may also be associated with more severe consequences in terms of declines in health and decreased survival times (Centers for Disease Control, 2007).
There is, again, a lack of research with older MSM in South Africa, but there are likely to be some paral els between older MSM global y and those in South Africa. Examining what research is available, Lane (2013) found higher rates of HIV infection among older (>25 years) MSM respondents in Mpumalanga. In an online survey of MSM who use drugs in South Africa, Jobson (2012) found that the MSM reporting the highest rates of drug use in unprotected sexual encounters were on average 40 years old, and that these men reported using drugs specifical y to increase their enjoyment of sex and to lose their inhibitions.
The relationships that MSM engage in may have direct effects on their risk
behaviours, as wel as providing an effective context in which to implement HIV
prevention interventions. In terms of HIV risk, Arnold et al. (2013) found that
participants in the Soweto Men's Study who reported sex partners as ‘regular' were
more likely to report unprotected anal intercourse with these partners. This finding is
also important in light of Sul ivan et al.'s (2009) estimation that 68% of HIV
transmissions in their US sample were from main sex partners. This was due to the
higher number of sex acts with main partners, more frequent receptive anal
intercourse and lower levels of condom use with these partners (Sul ivan et al., 2009).
Data on HIV transmission rates between MSM couples in South Africa are lacking, but
based on studies with heterosexual couples in other parts of sub-Saharan Africa
(Dunkle et al., 2008), it is likely that this is an issue worth focusing on.
The relationship context also provides a basis for targeted HIV prevention interventions. One such intervention is couples-based voluntary counsel ing and testing (CVCT). As the name suggests, CVCT involves couples testing for HIV together, receiving pre- and post-test counsel ing, and risk reduction counsel ing appropriate to their couple sero-status (sero-concordant positive or negative, or sero-discordant) together (Stephenson et al., 2012). CVCT has been shown to be effective in reducing sexual risk taking among heterosexual couples in other parts of Africa, and Stephenson et al. (2012) found a high level of acceptance of CVCT among MSM couples in Cape Town.
In addition to the provision of CVCT, there is a need for sensitisation of health care workers more general y in their work with MSM. In particular, there is a need for health care workers to avoid adopting heteronormative attitudes in their work with MSM (Rebe et al., 2013a), and to avoid making assumptions about the sex of individual MSM's sexual partners.
Given the high rates of UAI with regular partners reported by Arnold et al. (2013) it is likely that sensitively implemented interventions focusing on couples could have a positive impact on HIV transmission rates among MSM in South Africa.
MSM, SEX WORKERS AND TRANSACTIONAL SEX
Sex worker populations global y have a high risk of HIV infection due to their multiple
overlapping vulnerabilities (Wariki et al., 2011). These vulnerabilities are in part due to
the living and working conditions of sex workers. The direct HIV risks associated with
sex work include: high numbers of sex partners with different social backgrounds and
sexual histories; exposure to higher than average numbers of STIs; unprotected
sexual intercourse; and injecting drug use by either sex workers or their partners
(Wariki et al., 2011).
Indirect risk factors that increase sex workers vulnerability to HIV infection include social marginalisation and exclusion; the criminalisation of sex work and victimisation by police (Arnott and Crago, 2009). Knowledge of HIV transmission risks associated with male-male sex may also be lacking among sex workers, and research with male sex workers in Kenya found that 35% of respondents did not know that HIV could be transmitted through anal sex, while 21.2% did not know that water based lubricants should be used with condoms for anal sex (Geibel et al., 2008). There is a lack of South African specific data on male sex work, however, Richter et al (2013) report that in their study of male, female, and transgender sex workers in four South African cities male sex workers were 2.9 times (AOR, 95% CI 1.6 – 5.3, p<0.001) more likely than female sex workers to have unprotected sex. Daily and weekly binge drinking were also noted as risk factors among male sex workers in this study, with 59.7% reporting feeling drunk at last sex with either of their previous 2 clients, and overal (across male, female, and transgender sex workers), daily or weekly binge drinking was associated with a 2.1 times (AOR, 95% CI 1.2 – 3.7; p=0.011) higher likelihood of reporting unprotected sex (Richter et al., 2013).
Another risk associated with sex work among MSM is substance use. Hal et (2003) for example documents how male sex workers in his study used drugs as a coping mechanism to help them deal with the demands of their work. Similarly, research global y has also documented high rates of substance use among male sex workers, and has found that substance use is a risk factor for HIV transmission in this population (Baral et al., 2010, Mimiaga et al., 2009, Tun et al., 2008, Wechsberg et al., 2005). Boyce and Isaacs (2012) report that male sex workers from South Africa who participated in their assessment of social contexts, risks and practices among men sel ing sex rated substance use as the largest general threat facing sex workers. In line with this finding, Needle et al. (2008) found that drug use was common among both male and female sex workers in South Africa, and that using drugs was intimately associated with sex workers daily routines and their sexual interactions with clients.
In discussing sex work and transactional sex in South Africa, it is worth distinguishing between sex work as a form of employment, and occasional transactional sex in the context of individuals social lives. This distinction is important because the social context of HIV risk, including the motivations and processes behind negotiating
sexual encounters differs markedly in these interactions. In research conducted with MSM in Cape Town, sexual interactions between men during their normal patterns of socialising were reportedly frequently characterised by a transactional element (Jobson et al., 2013). General y the ‘transaction' would involve individuals buying alcohol for potential sex partners, who were frequently heterosexually identifying (known col oquial y as "after nines")(Jobson et al., 2013). MSM also report being paid for sex, and in unpublished data from Health4Men's Ukwazana Study, 31.5% (95/302) of participants reported receiving some form of payment for sex, while 32.9% (100/304) reported paying someone else for sex, and 19.2% (57/297) reported both paying for sex, and receiving payment for sex. Notably, these sexual encounters were most frequently reported to occur in the context of alcohol use, and several participants noted forgoing condom use either due to being intoxicated or out of fear of losing the opportunity to have sex (Jobson et al., 2013).
MSM DRUG USERS
Substance use may directly affect HIV risk behaviour, and international y,
associations between sexual risk taking and substance use have been repeatedly
documented (cf. Aguinaldo et al., 2009, Benotsch et al., 1999, Carey et al., 2009,
Choi et al., 2005). Aside from incidental use of drugs in contexts where men have sex
with each other, drugs are also used specifical y to enhance sexual interactions.
Drug use may play a range of roles in MSM's sex lives and Myers et al. (2004) outline
six of these, noting that MSM may use drugs in sexual interactions as a means of:
general y enhancing the sexual experience; increasing sexual arousal; facilitating
sexual encounters; increasing the capacity to engage in particular sexual activities;
increasing the length of sexual interactions; and facilitating sex work.
In South Africa research has revealed distinct differences in drug use among MSM by racial group, economic status, and geographical location. Among black MSM alcohol appears to be the most frequently used substance, and Lane et al. (2008c) found an increased risk of unprotected anal intercourse among MSM in their study in Soweto who reported regular drinking. Jobson et al. (2013), in a qualitative study in Cape Town, found that black MSM directly associated risky sexual behaviour with being under the influence of alcohol. Where research has documented the use of other substances among township dwelling MSM in South Africa, marijuana appears to be the main substance used, and rates of using harder drugs such as cocaine, crystal methamphetamine, ecstasy, heroin or mandrax are reportedly low (Lane et al., 2008c). Generally, the use of harder drugs among black MSM seems fairly limited, with the exception of black MSM who work as sex workers (Parry et al., 2008).
Among the white, coloured and Indian MSM population the use of a variety of drugs appears to be more widespread. In a small sample of MSM attending Ivan Toms Centre for Men's Health in Cape Town, Stoloff et al. (2013) found a high prevalence
of drug use disorders (56%). In Health4Men's (2012) online survey of MSM in South Africa 35.5% of white participants, 18.6% of black participants, 31.9% of coloured participants, and 18.9% of Indian participants reported any drug use in the previous 6 months. Data from this survey also show significant differences between HIV positive and HIV negative MSM in terms of their drug use and sexual risk behaviours (Jobson, 2013b). For example, 22.3% of HIV positive MSM reported using crystal methamphetamine to enhance their sexual encounters, compared to only 3.9% of HIV negative MSM; and 42.5% of HIV positive participants reported more than one session of group sex in the previous 6 months, in comparison to 28.7% of HIV negative participants (Jobson, 2013b). These findings are possibly related to reports of the use of crystal methamphetamine in the context of sex parties organised exclusively for HIV positive MSM, an occurrence reported in focus group discussions with drug using MSM in Cape Town (Health4Men, 2012). Parry et al. (2008) similarly noted that MSM in their rapid assessment of drug use and HIV risk reported using drugs in the context of group sex.
More broadly, Mitchel (2013), reporting data from Health4Men's (2012) online survey, found that among MSM who reported daily drug use HIV prevalence was 54%, that 47% reported 7 or more sex partners in the previous 6 months, and that 92% reported inconsistent condom use in the previous 6 months. These findings clearly point to a need for HIV prevention initiatives focusing on substance use among MSM in South Africa.
The HIV prevalence among South Africa's prisoner population was estimated at 45%
in 2006 (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, 2007), and around 97% of
inmates in South Africa are male (Department of Correctional Services, 2011). Being
imprisoned presents a high risk of HIV infection for these men, with sexual activity and
anal sex being a key risk factor for HIV transmission in this context. Other important
risks include the use of contaminated cutting equipment for drawing tattoos, and to
a lesser extent in the South African context, injecting drug use (Goyer, 2003).
Both consensual sex and sexual assault present particular chal enges for HIV prevention in the prison context in South Africa. The Jali Commission of Inquiry (2006) found high rates of sexual violence in South African prisons, and this violence is frequently linked to gang activities within these prisons. Consequently, the establishment of sexual relationships between prisoners is often linked to processes of dominance and subordination, and may form an intimate part of gang ritual and lore (Gear, 2005).
It is important to note that consensual sex also takes place between men in prison (Gear, 2005), and that this may or may not occur between men who self identify as homosexual. The occurrence of consensual sex between men in environments such
as prisons, the military, or mining hostels has been described by Parket et al as the "situational specificity" of erotic desire. (Parker et al., 2000)
There is a clear need, given the high HIV prevalence among prisoners, and the frequent sexual interactions between them, to focus attention on interventions promoting the use of condoms and water based lubricants for anal sex in this context. There is also a clear need for interventions addressing sexual violence and rape in South Africa's prisons.
STRUCTURAL ISSUES IMPACTING MSM
Structural factors affecting HIV risk are the social, economic, political and
environmental issues that directly and indirectly affect individuals risks of acquiring
HIV through multiple causal pathways (Rao-Gupta et al., 2008). A central tenet of
the call for combination HIV prevention interventions is the recognition that the
ability of individuals to implement risk reducing behaviours is strongly affected by the
contexts in which they live (Coates et al., 2008). As Coates et al. (2008 p. 36) note,
"HIV prevention is neither simple nor simplistic", and in order to sustain the changes in
behaviour required to reduce HIV transmission, the multiple, multi-level drivers of HIV
risk need to be addressed.
For MSM in South Africa particularly important structural issues affecting HIV risk include: high levels of stigma and discrimination from multiple sources (Jobson et al., 2013, Lane et al., 2008a, Rispel et al., 2011, Cloete et al., 2008, Vu et al., 2011); cultural and religious beliefs about the unacceptability of homosexuality (Jobson et al., 2013); lack of access to appropriate HIV prevention, treatment and care (Rispel et al., 2011, Lane et al., 2008a); and poverty and a lack of economic opportunities, including lack of access to the social grant system (Jobson et al., 2013). In contrast, Arnold et al. (2013) note increases in HIV risk associated with higher income levels among MSM in Soweto, which may point to the dual role of poverty and local level income inequality as interacting factors affecting HIV risk. Indeed, Scheibe et al. (2013) note the importance of considering both poverty and increasing levels of inequity as drivers of HIV risk among MSM in Cape Town. The potent mix of social exclusion, direct experiences of homoprejudice, lack of access to power and resources and lack of access to income earning opportunities combine to increase MSM's HIV risk through multiple causal pathways.
Examples of these include: negative effects on individuals mental health statuses, which in turn have been linked to increased HIV risk (cf. Salomon et al., 2009); high levels of homophobia in individuals' local communities may lead MSM to hide their same-sex sexual practices, reducing the likelihood of their accessing appropriate HIV prevention materials (such as water based lubricants) (Jobson et al., 2013); and homophobic social contexts create the potential for human rights abuses and
blackmail, which were linked to less frequent HIV testing and denial of health care in Baral et al.'s (2009) study.
Another structural factor of central importance to HIV risk among MSM is the policy context of the countries in which they live. As Scheibe (2013) notes, while the broad policy context in South Africa is supportive of MSM rights, the ability to enjoy the freedoms enshrined in the Constitution is stil linked to individuals' power and resources. Further, the degree to which the constitutional enshrinement of individuals' rights is reflected in the policies and programmes implemented by government departments at national, provincial and local level varies. The MSM-related policy context in South Africa is discussed in more detail below.
SOUTH AFRICAN MSM POPULATION SIZE ESTIMATES: CURRENT
South Africa does not have accurate populations size estimates for the MSM
population, although some plans are in place for a more detailed assessment. Some
national level data exists from The Human Sciences Research Council's (HSRC) 2008
National HIV Prevalence, Incidence, Behaviour and Communication Survey (Shisana
et al., 2009). Results from the 2012 survey have not yet been ful y released: no MSM-
related data has been presented in the initial conference presentations from this
study (Shisana, 2013).
In the HSRC 2008 survey 3.2% of men self reported same sex behaviour, which would be equivalent to approximately 750,000 men nationally. Dunkle et al. (2013) reported on a population based survey of men from randomly selected households in the Eastern Cape and KwaZulu-Natal provinces, in which 5.4% of men reported at least one lifetime occurrence of consensual sexual contact with a man. If this proportion were extrapolated national y, it would suggest in the region of 1.2 mil ion MSM. In this study, there were no significant differences in the prevalence of consensual male–male sexual behaviour by race, age, education, or recent employment. Almost al the MSM in this study (98.9%) had had sex with a woman.
Population size estimates are important to target both HIV prevention and treatment services, and plans are in progress to extend a UCSF-led approach to population size estimates, which has been used in other African countries, and in other key populations in South Africa, to MSM in 2014. This approach is described below, with an example from a recently completed exercise undertaken by UCSF and Anova in Mpumalanga.
MSM POPULATION SIZE ESTIMATION METHODS
In the absence of a gold standard methodology to estimate the size of a given
population, current estimates are imprecise and prone to potential biases. Using
multiple estimation methods, however, improves the validity of the estimate and is
useful for local, provincial, and national health program planning purposes. Current
estimation projects in South Africa, conducted by University of California, San
Francisco (UCSF) utilize three approaches to produce the most rigorous estimates of
key populations, in this case, men who have sex with men (MSM). The use of multiple
methods strengthens confidence in estimates, provides upper and lower plausibility
bounds, and reduces the likelihood that biases of any single method wil substantially
alter results. The fol owing describes the three methods currently employed:
Method 1: Modified Delphi. This method produces an estimate of the number of
MSM in the targeted communities through the synthesis of local and international
expert opinion. A synthesis of data from an extensive review of the published and
grey literature is conducted, searching for relevant data from South Africa and
similar regions. Additional y, members of the target community are also asked their
best estimate of the number of MSM "In and around" the study sites. This approach
has also been cal ed the "Wisdom of the Crowds Method". Such an approach
produces a measure of the perception of community members and providers of the
population size of MSM.
Method 2: Unique Object Multiplier. Procedures for unique object multipliers entail
two basic steps:
1. Distribution of a fixed number of memorable, unique objects (e.g., a glass
bead bracelet with a distinct pattern) to members of the study population in the geographic area of the study.
2. Re-sampling this area of study and asking whether study participants had
received the unique object.
Using these two data sources, the multiplier method provides a population size estimate by the formula:
Where N is the estimated MSM population size, n is the total number of unique objects distributed in the study location, and p is the proportion of MSM reporting in the fol ow-up survey that they received the unique object.
To strengthen accuracy and recal , there should not be a long lag-time between the disbursement of the unique object and the re-sampling of the community. Additional y, outreach workers who hand out the object should be memorable (e.g. wearing a red hat) to decrease recal bias.
Method 3: Unique Event Multiplier. Similar to the Unique Object method, rather than
"tagging" MSM with an object, a memorable event is held (e.g., mobilization fair,
house party) that records the number of unique individual MSM in attendance. Prior
experience with other MSM populations in Ghana, Kenya, and Mozambique have
shown that timing these events with the launch of a survey helps publicize the survey
aims and goals throughout the community, facilitating timely achievement of
recruitment goals. The event is fol owed by a fol ow-up survey, which asks if the
respondent attended the event. The number of MSM counted attending the event
and the proportion reporting attending in the fol ow-up survey provide the
parameters for the formula in Method 2 above.
AN EXAMPLE OF MSM POPULATION SIZE ESTIMATES IN MPUMALANGA
A col aborative team from UCSF and the Anova Health Institute, under the
leadership of Dr Tim Lane, has recently completed data col ection on the
Mpumalanga Men's Study in the Gert Sibande and Ehlanzeni districts of
Mpumalanga province (Lane, 2013).
To determine the number of men who have sex with men (MSM) living in Gert Sibande District and Ehlanzeni District, Mpumalanga, South Africa in 2012/2013, this group applied several, practical population size estimation methods during the Mpumalanga Men's Study (MpMS) and synthesized findings to determine plausible estimates. The range of estimates determined by the various methods yielded the fol owing estimates for MSM in Gert Sibande: 1,810 (1.2%) from literature review, 1,363 (0.9%) by unique object multiplier, 696 (0.5%) by unique event multiplier and 624 (0.4%) by wisdom of the crowds (WOTC). Using the same methods as in Gert Sibande, population size estimates of MSM in Ehlanzeni included 2,049 (1.2%) from literature review, 3,833 (2.2%) by unique object multiplier, 324 (0.2%) by unique event multiplier and 2,491 (1.5%) by wisdom of the crowds (WOTC). The point estimates adopted via a consensus review as being most plausible were 1,363 (0.9%) for Gert Sibande and 2,049 (1.2%) for Ehlanzeni. This process emphasizes that there is no gold standard for estimation population sizes among key populations at risk for HIV and thus no one method can conclude the size estimate of MSM in these two municipalities in Mpumalanga. The estimates that the researchers found, though stil not perfect, are useful as a basis for the HIV programmes serving these populations.
MSM IN SOUTH AFRICA – A REVIEW OF THE POLICY ENVIRONMENT
MSM POLICY INTRODUCTION
The policy environment in which MSM-related HIV prevention, treatment and care
interventions operate is central y important in determining the range of possibilities
for such interventions, as wel as determining, to some extent, the level of
involvement possible from government services and employees. In South Africa the
broad policy environment affecting HIV interventions for MSM and other key
populations is determined by both government and donor policies.
While there has been a supportive policy environment for MSM-related interventions since the drafting and promulgation of the South African Constitution in 1996, in reality, it is only in the last 5 years that MSM have been focused on as an important part of the response to HIV in the country. Indeed, as Rispel and Metcalf (2009) note with regard to the previous National Strategic Plan (NSP) on HIV and AIDS and Sexual y Transmitted Infections (2007 – 2011), "…health services remain largely unresponsive, and no dedicated funding has been al ocated by government to meet the targets outlined in the NSP." In this context, the bulk of HIV interventions targeting MSM and other key populations have been implemented by NGOs with donor funding. The policies of major donors (notably PEPFAR and the Global Fund) have thus also played an important role in shaping the policy environment in which interventions are implemented.
SOUTH AFRICAN GOVERNMENT POLICY AND HIV IN MSM
At the broadest level, the South African Constitution outlaws discrimination against
anyone on the basis of his or her sexual orientation, and South Africa remains the
only country in Africa that explicitly prohibits such discrimination. In terms of health
care and social policy, however, explicit mention of MSM and other key populations
The South African National AIDS Council (SANAC) is responsible for drafting the NSP and for monitoring its implementation as part of its mandate in overseeing the country's response to HIV. The NSP provides the basis for both strategic and operational plans in the individual provinces. As noted above, while both the previous (2007 – 2011) and current (2012 – 2016) NSPs include MSM and key populations, there remains a lack of operational guidelines and specific policy measures at both national and provincial level to ensure that targets outlined in the plans are implemented.
The current NSP is structured around four strategic objectives: 1) address the social and structural drivers of HIV, STIs, and TB; 2) prevent new HIV, STI, and TB infections; 3) sustain health and wel ness; 4) ensure protection of human rights and improve access to justice. These four objectives include sub-objectives, and while MSM are implicitly included across the main objectives, only 2 sub-objectives make explicit mention of this population. Sub-objective 2.5. notes the need to work on strategies around implementing Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) for MSM; and sub-objective 3.1. outlines the necessity of making concerted efforts to reach MSM with appropriate screening, diagnosis, and treatment.
While the NSP provides the basis for provincial departments' planning processes, only two provinces explicitly include MSM in their current strategic plans. In KwaZulu-Natal (KzN), MSM are included as a key population in their table of combination interventions aimed at preventing HIV and STI transmissions (Office of the Premier: Province of KwaZulu-Natal, 2011). This table includes a range of intervention types, including: condoms, PEP, HCT, TB screening, MMS, Behavioural Change Campaigns, STI treatment, PrEP, PMTCT, and "addressing contextual"; and notes the applicability of each of these for each key population.
The Western Cape also explicitly includes MSM in their Provincial Strategic Plan on HIV/AIDS, STIs and TB (Western Cape Department of Health, 2012). This plan includes MSM with other key populations as requiring services, noting the responsible sector as "civil society"; MSM are also included in a sub-objective focusing on reducing HIV and TB related stigma and discrimination, where MSM-training for health workers is noted as a priority activity (Western Cape Department of Health, 2012). The use of PrEP in MSM is also noted as an area requiring further work to develop strategies for implementation and to understand the feasibility of its implementation (Western Cape Department of Health, 2012).
MSM do not appear to be mentioned in the policies or strategic plans of other provincial health departments, or other government departments more general y. Guidelines for HCT, ART and other aspects of HIV and STI management do not mention MSM. However, the consensus committee of the Southern African HIV Clinicians Society has developed guidelines for the safe use of PrEP among MSM (Bekker et al., 2012).
SOUTH AFRICAN GOVERNMENT POLICY REGARDING OTHER KEY POPULATIONS
Apart from MSM, other key populations with increased risk of HIV infection in South
Africa include: transgender populations, sex workers, injecting drug users, prison
populations and specific migrant groups (Scheibe et al., 2011). These populations
are also included in the NSP as requiring a specific focus in HIV prevention,
treatment, and care programming (SANAC, 2012). However, the policy environment
for these different groups differs somewhat from that of MSM.
In the case of sex workers and injecting drug users, a key challenge in the policy environment is the fact that sex work and the possession and use of drugs remain illegal in South Africa. The illegality of these activities negatively affects the ability of individuals to access relevant health services, and jeopardises the implementation of targeted HIV prevention programmes for these groups.
In terms of cross-border migrants, while legislation exists to ensure their access to HIV related services, in practice access to these services may be difficult and may be particularly difficult in cases where individuals have outstanding documentation or whose legal status is not yet confirmed (Scheibe et al., 2011).
The right of transgender people to change their gender is legislated in South Africa (Scheibe et al., 2011). The Alteration of Sex Description and Sex Status Act No. 49 of 2003 al ows for individuals to legal y change their gender and provides for those who are in various stages of transition. It is not limited to those who have undergone reassignment surgery. However, transgender populations stil face high levels of stigma and discrimination in health services, the Act is poorly implemented by the Dept. of Home Affairs and transgender people are denied identity documents or experience excessive delays and there remains a lack of HIV related services focusing specifical y on transgender populations. There is no formal national Transgender Health Policy or Curriculum, although there are guidance documents on transgender care issued by a local NGO, GenderDynamix (Mul er, 2013).
The policies of major international donors to HIV-related programmes have played
an important role in raising awareness of the need to address MSM and other key
populations in HIV prevention, treatment and care in South Africa, as wel as in
supporting the initiation of projects focusing on these populations. The two largest
donors funding HIV-related work in South Africa are PEPFAR and The Global Fund to
Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria (Parsons et al., 2011).
In 2011 PEPFAR published guidelines for combination HIV prevention for MSM (PEPFAR, 2011). This technical guidance on HIV prevention for MSM emphasises the need to address the complex drivers of HIV risk among MSM, and defines the core elements of such a prevention package as:
1) Community based outreach 2) Distribution of condoms and lubricants 3) HCT 4) Linkage to care 5) Target information, education and communication (IEC) 6) STI prevention, screening and treatment.
As one of the major donors supporting MSM related HIV programming in South Africa, PEPFAR's approach to this programming forms the basis of much of the current work underway in this area.
The Global Fund's approach to working with MSM, transgender people, and sex workers, is outlined in their 2009 document titled "The Global Fund Strategy in Relation to Sexual Orientation and Gender Identities" (The Global Fund, 2009). This strategy outlines 19 actions to be taken to support programming that is inclusive of MSM, transgender people and sex workers. These actions include internal procedural changes (such as modifying guidelines for proposals), changes to monitoring and evaluation processes, working to increase budget al ocations to programmes focusing on MSM, transgender populations and sex workers, and supporting trainings and briefings around these issues for Global Fund Partners (The Global Fund, 2009).
The increased focus on MSM and key populations by these two donors has had a direct impact on the number of interventions working in this area in South Africa, and in doing so it is likely that they have also contributed towards creating a more supportive policy environment for such interventions.
NATIONAL POLICIES IN DEVELOPMENT OR UNDER REVIEW
Several new policies are at a late stage of development or review by the National
Department of Health, which wil address relevant issues for MSM. Three of these are
at the stage of stakeholder review, and should be finalised and published in the
The National Department of Health has developed "Operational Guidelines for HIV, STIs and TB Programmes for Key Populations in South Africa" which is at a final draft stage (National Department of Health, 2012). This extensive operational guideline results from a consultative process, initial y documented in Sheibe, Brown et al.
(2011) and from input from an extensive network of local and international contributors and reviewers. The guidelines focus on men who have sex with men (MSM), sex workers, people who inject drugs (PWID) and other drug users, transgender people, migrants and mobile populations and detained people and are intended to assist health planners to develop and implement programmes that wil lead to an achievement of the targets set for Key Populations in the NSP.
The National Department of Health's draft "HIV Prevention Strategy for the Health Sector" is a practical tool to assist healthcare managers, particularly at a district level to plan and implement prevention interventions in a manner tailored to the needs of al people in their area of work (National Department of Health, 2013). It includes recommendations for MSM services and interventions, which are aligned with the Key Populations policy.
The "Quality Assurance Standards for Peer Education and Outreach Programmes for High Risk Vulnerable Populations in South Africa (Draft)" lays out quality assurance (QA) standards for peer education and outreach programmes for men who have sex with men (MSM), sex workers (SWs), and people who inject drugs (PWID) in South Africa (ICF International, 2012). The QA standards are intended to provide guidance to organisations implementing peer education and outreach programmes for MSM, and other key populations in South Africa. The quality of peer education and outreach programmes targeting MSM and other key populations in South Africa is critical to implementing effective intervention agreed quality assurance standards for peer education and outreach programmes are needed to ensure successful delivery of high-quality programmes. The standards and guidelines were developed by a team lead by the Programme for Appropriate Technologies in Health (PATH), Joint Commission International (JCI), and CDC; and were field tested by a range of South African NGOs working with key populations.
INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATIONS POLICIES AND GUIDELINES
A final aspect of the environment in which MSM and key population interventions
operate is the guidelines and policies of the various United Nations organisations,
including the World Health Organisation and UNAIDS. These organisations have
published a range of resources focusing on HIV prevention, treatment and care for
MSM and other key populations. These include both broad outlines of necessary
changes in support of HIV prevention, treatment and care, such as the "UNAIDS
Action Framework: Universal Access for Men who have Sex with Men and
Transgender People" (UNAIDS, 2009), guidelines for monitoring and evaluation
(UNAIDS, 2013) and specific guidelines focusing on the prevention and treatment of
HIV and STIs among MSM and transgender people (World Health Organisation,
2011). These WHO-published guidelines are intended to enhance the ability of
countries to provide comprehensive HIV responses to MSM and transgender (TG)
populations, and comprise a thorough set of technical recommendations for STI and HIV treatment among MSM and TG populations. The document provides six "good practice recommendations," focused on the fol owing: (1) prevention of sexual transmission; (2) HIV testing and counselling; (3) IEC; (4) HIV prevention focused on substance use; (5) MSM and TG people living with HIV; and (6) prevention and treatment of STIs. It is geared toward national public health officials, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), and health workers.
The WHO has also published guidelines focusing on STI and HIV treatment for sex workers (World Health Organisation, 2012). Final y, South Africa is a signatory to a 2011 United Nations General Assembly Resolution on "Intensifying Our Efforts to Eliminate HIV and AIDS", which recognises the need to target services at populations at higher risk of infection (United Nations, 2011).
There is clearly a broadly supportive policy environment for the implementation of
MSM and key population focused HIV interventions in South Africa. Although there
remains a lack of provincial and local government level policy and guidelines for this
work, the inclusion of MSM and key populations in the NSP provides a clear basis for
this work. There is also a strong recognition of the need for a focus on these
populations among the major HIV/AIDS donor organisations, the World Health
Organisation and various UN agencies.
CURRENT MSM RELATED HIV PREVENTION AND TREATMENT
PROGRAMMES, GAPS AND OPPORTUNITIES
CURRENT PREVENTION PROGRAMMES
Several organisations across South Africa are currently running MSM-related HIV
prevention programmes. The main organisations running these programmes are: the
Anova Health Institute's Health4Men programme, ICAP's MOSAIC project, the
Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation, OUT-LGBT Wel being, and Triangle Project. Given the
general lack of MSM-specific HIV programmes in South Africa, the interventions that
have been implemented to date have been fairly broadly focused on HIV risk
behaviours, and the provision of MSM-relevant information and resources.
As such, current HIV prevention programmes for MSM in South Africa include:
o HIV counsel ing and testing, o STI testing and treatment, o condom and water based lubricant distribution, o provision of information, education, and communication (IEC) resources, o prevention messaging, and o community outreach.
There is limited access to medical HIV prevention such as Post-Exposure Prophylaxis (PEP). Several organisations have also implemented health care worker sensitisation training as a means of making health care more widely accessible to MSM in South Africa.
These various prevention strategies, and the extent to which they have been implemented in South Africa to date are discussed below.
RESEARCH INTO ACCEPTABILITY OF AND NEEDS FOR PREVENTION PROGRAMME
Prevention messaging forms an important component of HIV prevention programmes worldwide. However, in South Africa, HIV prevention programmes have neglected men who have sex with men (MSM) and there is a lack of research focusing on the prevention information needs of MSM in the country. Anova's Health4Men programme has conducted research focused on understanding the HIV prevention messaging preferences MSM.
Participants in this research identified a clear need for messaging targeting MSM, but when asked to rank various HIV prevention posters, they tended to prefer those that were not identifiable as focusing on MSM. This contradictory preference was directly related by participants to the homophobic social and cultural contexts in which they live. The primary concern identified was the possibility of a violent backlash against MSM if explicitly homosexual messaging was placed in their communities. Other important concerns included: that linking HIV to MSM in messaging would reinforce stereotypical ideas about MSM as being transmitters of HIV; that messaging would reinforce stereotypes of MSM as being only interested in sex; and that messaging would promote ideas about MSM as having more money than other community members.
These concerns have important implications for the design and implementation of HIV prevention messaging for MSM in this context, and raise the possibility of using HIV prevention messaging creatively to address issues around homoprejudice, discrimination and stigma as a means of indirectly increasing MSM's health seeking behaviours.
PREVENTION WITH HIV POSITIVE MSM
HIV prevention interventions that specifically focus on HIV positive MSM play an
important role in decreasing HIV transmission rates. The most widely publicised of
these types of interventions currently is the use of ART in HIV serodiscordant couples.
However, current ART guidelines in South Africa preclude the use of this method prior
to individuals CD4 cell counts dropping below 350/mm3. While current HIV
prevention messaging is relevant to the needs of both HIV positive and negative
MSM, there is a lack of information available that deals specifical y with HIV positive
MSM's needs. For example, there is no widely available prevention information
discussing the pros and cons of various sero-adaptive behaviours. The need for such
information was highlighted in the results of Health4Men's annual online survey
(2012), which revealed that MSM in South Africa are adapting their sexual
behaviours based on their HIV status, but that fairly high percentages of these men
lack accurate information about the relative risks of these various behavioural
adaptations (Jobson, 2013a).
PREVENTION AND PLEASURE INTERVENTIONS
The role of sexual pleasure in HIV prevention interventions is often acknowledged,
but simultaneously, specific components focusing on sexual pleasure are very rarely
included in these interventions. In part, this reticence may be attributed to social
and cultural taboos around the discussion of sexual intimacy (Boyce et al., 2007,
Lambert and Wood, 2005). Equal y, the donors funding HIV prevention programming
may be fearful of creating perceptions that they are promoting sexual promiscuity in the guise of HIV prevention. As such, much of the prevention work that has been implemented in South Africa still centres on the Abstain, Be faithful, use Condoms (ABC) model, despite the limited evidence for its effectiveness.
Interventions focusing on sexual pleasure have been shown to be effective in changing risk behaviours in Southern Africa. For example, Philpott et al. (2006) report that an intervention in Mozambique successful y reduced married men's extramarital partnerships through creating open dialogues about sexual pleasure between marital partners.
There are very few examples of pleasure based prevention interventions for MSM, but Hazra (2006), based on work with MSM in India, argues that approaches to HIV prevention for MSM that emphasise sensuality and mutual pleasure may play an important role in reducing HIV risk in contexts where sexual encounters between men are marked by sexual aggression, and where social ideals about dominance and submission affect men's expectations in terms of their sexual experiences. For example, in some contexts penetrative partners may be expected to behave aggressively or to dominate their partners, which may increase the risk of damage to their partners' anuses and hence increase the risk of HIV infection (Hazra, 2006). This type of dynamic has been noted in some research with MSM in South Africa, with receptive partners emphasising the need to be submissive during sex, and even expressing the desire for, or expectation of, pain as part of anal intercourse. As this participant in a Health4Men focus group discussion states:
"It's supposed to be painful, there's nothing helping the penis to get in, so it's supposed to be painful".
In contexts where sex between men is stigmatised, a focus on pleasure in HIV prevention can also play an important role in affirming the validity of individuals' same-sex desires and in so doing help them to deal with the negative effects of discrimination and internalised stigma.
GAPS AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR HIV PREVENTION INTERVENTIONS
There are several gaps in current HIV prevention programmes for MSM in South
Africa. As noted above, the prevention programmes currently in place are focused
on: HIV counselling and testing, STI testing and treatment, condom and water based
lubricant distribution, provision of information, education, and communication (IEC)
resources, prevention messaging, and community outreach. These approaches are
in close alignment with PEPFAR's technical guidance on combination HIV prevention
for MSM (PEPFAR, 2011) and the DOH prevention guidelines (National Department of
Health, 2012). However, these approaches remain firmly within the broad scope of
the generic interventions used in tackling the HIV epidemic as a whole, and thus
may not reach MSM with more specific HIV risks resulting from their particular life circumstances, social contexts, or sexual behaviours. Gaps in HIV prevention programming therefore exist in targeting these particularly high-risk individuals and behaviours, and in doing so it may be possible to act synergistically to decrease HIV transmission within the MSM population as a whole.
There are no HIV prevention programmes that focus specifical y on young MSM
(YMSM) in South Africa. This is an important gap because YMSM experience a range
of chal enges that are unique to their life stage.
HIV prevention interventions for YMSM could focus on:
o Supporting them in dealing with accepting their sexuality as a normal part
of the range of human sexual desires.
o Providing sex-positive sexuality education about male-male sexual
practices and risk reduction.
o Sensitising health care and social workers to the particular needs and
chal enges facing YMSM
o Harm reduction approaches focusing on alcohol and drug use in the
context of sexual interactions
The particular HIV risks facing older MSM in South Africa have not been addressed in
HIV prevention interventions to date.
This gap in HIV prevention programming could focus on several areas, including:
o Sex-positive messaging around aging and sexuality
o IEC materials or harm reduction focusing on drug use, sexual risk, and
the use of erectile dysfunction medication
o Encouraging more frequent HIV testing, STI screening and linkage to
MSM IN RELATIONSHIPS
The relationship context provides an effective basis for HIV prevention interventions,
but there are no such interventions currently being implemented in South Africa. As
noted in the literature review, the couples context may be particularly risky for HIV
transmission among MSM in South Africa.
There is a range of potential interventions that could target MSM in relationships, including:
o Couples based voluntary counsel ing and testing
o Couples specific IEC materials focusing on discussing sexual risk and
sexuality within relationships
o Access to information about sero-discordancy, sero-adaptive
behaviours, and ART as prevention in sero-discordant couples.
MSM SEX WORKERS AND TRANSACTIONAL SEX
While there are HIV prevention interventions in existence that focus on MSM sex
workers, these are limited to the major metropolitan areas and focus specifical y on
individuals whose primary occupation is sex work. There are gaps for interventions
focusing on intermittent sex work, and transactional sex in the contexts of MSM's
everyday lives. There is a particular need for a focus on HIV prevention with straight
identifying MSM ("after nines").
Possible interventions could include:
o IEC materials, condoms and water based lubricant distribution in the
venues in which transactional sex and sex work occurs.
o Increased MSM sex worker focused HCT and STI screening
o Health care worker sensitisation training or development of manuals
focusing on the particular needs of MSM sex workers.
o Prevention interventions focusing on transactional sex and alcohol use
o Interventions aimed at improving self-esteem and self-efficacy among
MSM who ‘pay' for sex in the contexts of alcohol use.
MSM DRUG USERS
In spite of drug use being well documented among MSM in South Africa there
remain very few programmes that target this aspect of HIV risk. There are a range of
possible interventions that could be developed to target drug-using MSM in the
o A specific focus on drug use in the context of sex parties, group sex,
and sex on site venues
o Non-judgemental IEC materials focusing on risk reduction when using
o Information about the risks of combining different substances (such as
poppers and erectile dysfunction drugs)
o The development of MSM-specific drug use risk reduction counselling
training for health workers and people working with drug users.
MSM AND STRUCTURAL ISSUES
The range of structural issues affecting HIV transmission among MSM in South Africa
have not been addressed by any HIV prevention programmes to date, outside of
research evaluations. There is a need for these issues to be addressed in order to
work towards creating more supportive environments and local contexts for MSM.
HIV prevention programmes focusing on structural issues could therefore include:
o Anti-homophobia messaging and interventions at health care services,
police stations and other government departments
o Work with religious leaders to address homophobic beliefs in their
communities and congregations
o Work with cultural authorities and traditional leaders around historical
precedents of cultural acceptance of same sex sexualities
o Work with educational institutions towards reducing homophobic
discrimination and violence.
HIV CARE AND TREATMENT FOR MSM
CURRENT TREATMENT PROGRAMMES
Until 2009, no medical services specifical y targeting MSM for sexual health and HIV
care were available in South Africa. This situation existed despite inclusion of MSM-
targeted health services in the country's previous National Strategic Plan for Health
Care. Gay men and other MSM received care at regular state-sector HIV clinics,
which were not capacitated to provide appropriate, MSM targeted-services. Health
provider stigma acted as a barrier to health access by MSM as clinics were not
sensitized or competent to address their health requirements (Lane et al., 2008b,
Muraguri et al., 2012, Rebe et al., 2010, Rebe et al., 2013b, Rebe et al., 2012, Rebe
et al., 2011b,).
In 2009, the Anova Health Institute launched the first MSM-targeted HIV and Sexual Health and Wel ness service in Cape Town. This service (Health4Men) was initial y
developed and run in partnership with the Western Cape Department of Health and was supported and funded by PEPFAR/USAID. The programme was extended to Soweto in 2010. The design of this program has resulted in the creation of two Centres of Excel ence (COEs), which facilitate the development and testing of MSM health guidelines. Operational research also occurs at the COEs and is aimed at improving the package of care for local MSM, for example, knowledge gained via implementation of MSM services at the COEs has been used to develop training and mentoring programs, aimed at institutionalizing and mainstreaming appropriate MSM healthcare in existing state-sector STI and HIV/ART clinics. In addition to the COEs, MSM healthcare-trained and competent clinics within this model now exist in five provinces.
During the past three years, other strategic partners have contributed significantly to the development and institutionalization of MSM health services into state healthcare programs. These partners include: The Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation, ICAP, OUT-LGBT Wel being, FPD, Right to Care, NACOSA and others. The Anova Health Institute, via its Health4men clinics, remains the largest provider and supporter of state-sector, primary level, MSM health services with care provided to more than 10 000 MSM to date. Health4men operates or supports clinics in Johannesburg, Soweto, Cape Town, Khayelitsha, Nelspruit, Ermelo and Tzaneen.
The scope of practice at Health4men sites includes:
o HIV: Screening, wel ness, treatment and support and prevention o STI: Screening, treatment, prevention and surveil ance o Mental Health: Life skil s, adherence support, couples counselling and
linkage to care with psychology, psychiatric and harm reduction services
o Harm reduction and other services for MSM who use drugs (AidsFonds
funded) or are involved in commercial or transactional sex work or who are displaced refugees
Programme activities both on and off-site include:
o Training and mentoring of health care workers o Provision of a variety of condoms and sexual lubricants o Community support and education projects o Health communication projects (IEC and other materials) o mHealth support via the H4M.mobi and Health4Men websites o Peer educator and community Ambassador projects o Technical support to state-sector clinics providing care for MSM o Biomedical and psychosocial operations and implementation science
SUPPORT FOR MSM TARGETED PROGRAMMING
The past two years have seen an expansion in support for MSM targeted
programming in South Africa, in particular from PEPFAR, accompanied by high level
government support. The Anova Health Institute's Health4Men programme is
PEPFAR/USAID funded and works in five provinces to develop MSM competent state
sector facilities and to provide treatment and prevention information. In addition, a
Global Fund sub award is currently in negotiation between Anova and Right to Care
to extend MSM competency training to the remaining four provinces. The
PEPFAR/CDC funded ICAP Mosaic programme works in five provinces to support HIV
prevention in partnership with local groups and to sensitise health workers. There is
little support for treatment-targeted support in the private health sector.
A number of civil society organisations are active in HIV prevention and human rights advocacy. Donor support for prevention initiatives, in general, is considerably less than that available for treatment initiatives.
SERVICE GAPS AND PROGRAM OPPORTUNITIES
There is currently a concern with the translation of evidence-based knowledge
about MSM health care provision into operationalized programs in Africa. This
includes both a failure to scale up existing treatment and prevention interventions
(e.g. hepatitis B and C screening / vaccination) and to implement new technologies
such as PrEP and early ART treatment for prevention (TasP). While HIV treatment is
similar in MSM and MSW, there are some specific treatment issues that are not wel
addressed by mainstream clinics.
Additional y, sexual y transmitted infections in MSM patients are often poorly or inadequately managed. Structural contributors to inadequate management include in-country guidance for the empiric treatment of STIs, which do not address the needs of MSM, and nurses and doctors who have not received competency training to address these needs. (South African Department of Health, 2003)
Current treatment gaps and opportunities wil therefore be considered under the fol owing headings:
a) HIV and ART b) Sexual y transmitted infections
HIV AND ART
Opportunity: Implement a program of early ART initiation for MSM and monitor
adherence, retention and health outcomes.
Early treatment with antiretrovirals has been shown to decrease HIV transmission among discordant heterosexual couples (Cohen et al., 2011). Similar evidence is lacking for MSM but ecological evidence supports similar risk reductions when using early ART in MSM (Das et al., 2010, Cowan et al., 2012). Individuals who are HIV positive are likely to benefit from earlier treatment and have improved health outcomes. The WHO has recently revised its ART recommendations to initiate individuals on ART if their CD4 count is below 500 copies/mm3. South Africa currently recommends later treatment, however, treating earlier with ART would provide both individual and community level benefits (Baggaley et al., 2010). Early treatment might also improve retention in care since a large percentage of loss to fol ow up of MSM occurs between HIV screening and initiation of ART – the "wel ness group" who are currently receiving little health programing aside from 6 monthly CD4 count estimations.
Opportunity: Implement point of care ART monitoring and measure effect on
adherence, retention in care, quality of life, health preferences and health
Attracting MSM into sexual health services may be difficult due to fear of health provider stigma. (De Swardt and Rebe, 2010a) Similarly, retention in care may also be challenging. The effect of point of care monitoring of patients pre- and on-ART using point of care CD4 and viral load monitoring technology has not been investigated in local MSM and could provide potential benefits.
Opportunity: Develop alternative ART col ection depots at non-medical, shop front-
style sites close to where MSM live or congregate.
Since MSM are often suspicious of the health care sector, alternative models of ART provision and col ection might improve adherence and health outcomes. Health4men promotes a program of sexual wel ness; HIV positive MSM who are stable and have no current health chal enges do not necessarily need to be attended to in a hospital or clinic. Alternative "shop front"-style drop-in ART collection depots (such as the Magnet Model in San Francisco) are not currently available. Such services could benefit both individuals accessing treatment and the state-healthcare system, which could be decongested of wel patients who attend simply to pick up medications. Similar alternative distribution strategies are already
being implemented for wider ART delivery in some areas of South Africa. This approach may provide opportunities to extend HIV prevention messaging, and HCT, in addition to and ART delivery for MSM in acceptable community centres. This programme would need to include measures of impact on adherence, retention in care, quality of life, health preferences and health outcomes.
Opportunity: Develop appropriate adherence support strategies for MSM, utilising
web based and social media technologies.
Antiretroviral treatment adherence is a chal enge in al settings, and may particularly be so given the many other issues, including stigma and high levels of drug use, that exist in the MSM community. Overburdened state sector antiretroviral services have little resources to promote adherence or address the individual needs of MSM. The use of web based or mobile phone based adherence support services have been shown to be successful in other settings and can al ow for confidential and individualised support. There is a need to develop, or possible col aborate with and adapt existing examples of these for South African MSM.
Opportunity: Broaden the menu of ART agents available to construct suppressive HIV
regimens that are individual y tailored to MSM patient needs and concerns.
The South African Department of Health mandates the use of specified first and second line ART regimens (i.e. tenofovir, emtricitabine and efavirenz in first line and zidovudine, lamivudine and lopinavir/ritonavir in second line). These medications may not be entirely suitable for MSM and it is problematic that alternative, more individualized ART medications are not proposed. An example includes the use of lopinavir/ritonavir in second line treatment. This agent commonly causes flatulence and diarrhoea, which are troubling for all individuals but may also result in sexual dysfunction for MSM engaging in receptive anal sex. Widespread use of psychoactive ARVs such as efavirenz may also negatively impact on the health of MSM who have a higher rate of mental health diseases than their heterosexual peers and who use recreational drugs which might result in drug-drug interactions. As a research question, there would be value in investigating the effects of alternative ART agents such as ritonavir-boosted atazanavir and integrase inhibitors on MSM health outcomes and quality of life.
Opportunity: Implement and monitor a PrEP pilot project for MSM attending MSM
Evidence for the use of antiretrovirals as prevention for HIV negative MSM was provided by the Global iPrEx study with further evidence expected from iPrEx OLE (open label extension) and other demonstration pilot projects. (Grant et al., 2010) Local guidelines for the safe use of PrEP in MSM have been developed and published. (Southern African HIV Clinicians Society, 2012) Despite this, PrEP is not available in state-sector facilities.
The NSP provides for introductory work to implement and deliver PrEP and other novel prevention technologies. At present little is known about the wil ingness of South African men to use PrEP, or what the most effective delivery systems would be. The availability of MSM targeted services, in specialised sites, research sites and in primary health care, provides an opportunity to move into a pilot programme of PrEP delivery.
Opportunity: Develop and implement training and materials to up-skil emergency
room staff and private practitioners in the provision of PEP for key populations.
Post exposure prophylaxis (PEP) is advocated for the prevention of HIV transmission to negative individuals fol owing potential exposure. (SA HIV Clinicians Society, 2008, WHO, 2007) PEP has traditional y been used in South Africa fol owing needle-stick injuries and after sexual assault but not fol owing risky consensual sex. Many health care workers in the state health sector are unaware of this additional indication. Several NGO's, in particular Health4Men and OUT LGBT Wel being, have promoted community awareness of PEP through IEC materials, community outreach, web and media campaigns. Despite this, there is little uptake of PEP and few facilities are capacitated to provide PEP. Embarking on a course of PEP is often difficult for MSM for the fol owing reasons:
• It is often required outside of expert-HIV clinic operating hours and thus needs
to be accessed via busy emergency units
• Emergency room staff are often untrained in counselling MSM for HIV
screening, which is required before starting the drugs
• MSM fear health provider stigma and loss of confidentiality regarding their
sexual orientation and HIV status
There is a need to develop, or adapt, and implement training materials and information resources to make PEP more widely offered and available.
Opportunity: Pilot and monitor the provision of PEP "starter packs" to MSM who are
HIV negative and are in regular care at MSM competent clinics.
A complementary approach to PEP provision is to provide MSM who have recently tested HIV negative with PEP "starter packs", which they could start in the event of a
high-risk exposure to HIV. With appropriate guidance this would enable MSM to rapidly initiate PEP after a risk incident prior to consulting a medical practitioner. Such a programme would need careful implementation and monitoring, but could be beneficial in reducing HIV infection rates by removing some of the barriers to accessing PEP for MSM.
SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED INFECTIONS
Opportunity: Improve health access to HIV services by MSM by leveraging STI-
targeted health communication messages, mHealth and venue based campaigns.
Monitor the effect on HCT screening and retention in care.
Sexual y transmitted infections (STIs) are common among MSM and are increasing even in countries where HIV rates are stable or decreasing; this speaks of on-going high risk sexual behaviours in this population group.(Cowan et al., 2012) STIs act as an entry point into care as MSM may be avoiding health care services due to fear of HIV-status-based stigma.
Opportunity: Strengthen partnerships with the National Institute of Communicable
Diseases and the country's GERMS Surveil ance program to col ect and process STI
specimens col ected from MSM at collaborating clinics.
A major chal enge in South Africa is that the current Department of Health guidelines for the empiric treatment of STIs do not cater for the needs of MSM. Specifical y, a high percentage (and often the majority) of gonorrhoea and chlamydial infections in MSM are asymptomatic. They would thus not be detected or treated using current in-country heteronormative STI guidance. (Lewis et al., 2013). A second major chal enge is that poly-drug resistant gonococcus (and specifically cefixime and ceftriaxone resistant strains) is more common among MSM. Two isolates of cefixime resistant cases have been detected in Johannesburg and another via the Health4men clinic in Cape Town. (Lewis et al., 2013).
Current in-country guidelines preclude isolation of the offending STI organism and antibiotic sensitivity estimation. As clinical STI specimens are not col ected in the state sector, no such specimens are processed by the National Health Laboratory Service and antibiotic surveil ance is not occurring. This is extremely problematic and needs to be urgently addressed as systematic under-treatment of MSM may be occurring which could drive further gonoccocal resistance. This opportunity would provide an evidence base for improving the applicability of current STI guidelines to MSM and would inform the Department of Health of the need to update or change these guidelines.
Opportunity: To broaden STI screening of healthy MSM without STI symptoms to
detect and treat asymptomatic disease (ASTIs).
This would have multiple possible benefits including; maintaining genital mucosal health which may positivity affect HIV incidence, providing an access point and a retention mechanism for healthy MSM who would not otherwise attend services for HIV risk reduction, lowering the morbidity associated with STIs and allowing for the development of cost-effective screening algorithms.
Opportunity: Point of care screening for STIs
The technology has recently become available to screen MSM for symptomatic and asymptomatic STIs using point of care technology (GeneXpert CT/NG and HPV, Cepheid) and syphilis (Syphilis Rapid, Alere Medical). STI screening could be routinized for MSM, raising awareness of this health issue, improving attendance at health facilities, improving general HIV prevention and health knowledge and engagement and of course providing an opportunity to treat infections and prevent them from becoming symptomatic. Al of this could be done in a single clinic visit, thus ensuring correct diagnosis and treatment occurs without loss to fol ow up. An evaluation of the effectiveness of such an approach is needed.
Opportunity: Explore the feasibility of implementing an anal pre-cancer screening
program for MSM.
Anal HPV infection is associated with an increased risk of anal cancer (similar to the elevated risk of cervical cancer in HPV infected women). (Jong et al., 2011) Currently there are no anal Pap smear services in the state sector. Also, Gardasil HPV vaccination is not available for MSM in South Africa outside of the private sector. By monitoring service utilization rates, HPV detection rates and rates of intra-epithelial anal neoplasms (AIN), a facilitated referral pathway could be developed to refer clients with AIN to curative services at tertiary state-hospital Ano-rectal surgery departments.
The provision of Gardasil vaccination to young MSM and to older MSM who have not had clinical genital warts would also play an important role in decreasing the incidence of HPV and hence of AIN.
Opportunity: Expand viral hepatitis screening for al MSM attending HIV and STI
services and vaccinate hepatitis A and B susceptible individuals.
Community knowledge of the risks of hepatitis remain low and this project would provide an opportunity to educate gay and other MSM about this risk and allow them to mitigate it. Viral hepatitis is common among MSM because hepatitis A and B can be sexual y spread during same-sex activities. Hepatitis A vaccination is not included in South Africa's paediatric vaccination schedule. Hepatitis B vaccination is currently included but there have been no catch up campaigns for sexual y active MSM who have not previously been vaccinated and remain susceptible. Hepatitis B vaccine is included in the country's essential drug list and thus should be available at primary health care centres but this is often not the case. Our experience during the past four years is that primary care pharmacies often do not order or stock this vaccine, limiting availability.
Opportunity: Screen al MSM attending sentinel MSM sites for hepatitis C in order to
investigate factors associated with positivity.
Hepatitis C is common in populations of people who use drugs, especially where the route of drug use is intravenous. Hepatitis C is also transmitted sexual y between MSM. Currently no routine screening for hepatitis C in high risk MSM is available. Screening al MSM attending sentinel sites, such as the Health4Men clinics, for hepatitis C would al ow for the development of a cost effective, local y evidence-based screening algorithm that could be utilized by the Department of Health.
MSM PROGRAMMING IN SOUTH AFRICA: KEY STAKEHOLDERS VIEWS
A. INTRODUCTION AND METHODOLOGY
Singizi Consulting was commissioned to work with the Anova Health Institute to
undertake a rapid review of existing and planned programming for HIV prevention,
testing, counsel ing and treatment and care services; and a review of perceptions of
MSM programming needs, gaps and priorities in terms of this.
Data were col ected through telephonic interviews with respondents from the National and Provincial Departments of Health, bodies such as SANAC, NGOs, PEPFAR partners, international agencies and selected private medical practitioners. A list for this assessment was developed from contact lists, meeting participants and major agencies of 60 identified respondents from 49 institutions, and interviews were completed for al available participants against this list between the 2nd and 23rd of September, 2013. A total of 40 respondents were interviewed from 35 institutions. Respondents included representatives from SANAC and the national Department of Health, eight of the nine provincial health departments and a wide range of non-governmental and donor organisations. Two respondents declined to participate, whilst the others were not available for interview during the period, or another representative of the organisation had already responded.
While efforts were made to ensure broad representation, the rapid assessment methodology may not have al owed for ful participation by al relevant groups. Respondents were informed that the data col ection was in order to provide information on priority funding areas for an unidentified funder, to avoid any bias in this regard. Conversely, this may have limited the information that participants were wil ing to share.
The purpose of the assessment is to provide a better understanding of responses to HIV for MSM populations, both by the government and non-governmental sectors, and to identify areas of need for enhanced programming.
The rapid assessment has been completed in the context of an increase in interest in MSM programming in South Africa and in the region, partly due to major funders such as the Global Fund and PEPFAR advocating for funding for this. This assessment happens at a time when some of these processes are stil being planned for but, at this point, MSM HIV prevention, treatment and care programming appears to remain minimal, and is regularly undertaken by NGO or community groups, and not taken to scale in the country.
This report provides a description of the programmes and services currently made available to MSM, and also explores the extent to which research is being conducted in terms of the prevalence and incidence of MSM with HIV. The report also reviews perceptions of key role-players in terms of key gaps, areas of opportunity, and current priorities.
The report is structured as fol ows:
provides an introduction and the methodology employed for this component of the rapid assessment;
considers the extent to which governmental and non-governmental organisations have developed any specific policies or guidelines for MSM, outside of the National Skil s Plan (NSP) and the Operational Guidelines for Key Populations currently being finalised;
describes and documents the key programmes and services available for MSM, both at the level of government and at the level of the non-governmental sectors;
reports on research studies being conducted on MSM and the nature of these, in accordance with the information provided by respondents;
reviews perceptions of current gaps, opportunities and priorities in MSM programming and service provision; and
provides an overarching summary of the findings emerging from this assessment.
4. A METHODOLOGY
A set of instruments was developed for the purposes of the telephonic interviews
which probed, as relevant, the fol owing areas:
• MSM-related policies and guidelines: this probed the extent to which policy
and guidelines exist (both those developed by the South African Government, as wel as organisation-level policies and guidelines), the extent to which respondents were aware of these, and perceptions of the comprehensiveness and relevance of these;
• Nature of MSM Programming and Services: this involved the col ection of
interview data on current programming and current service provision in terms of MSM. This includes data collection on the types of programmes and services currently in existence, as well as planned for the future, the reach in terms of these programmes and services (including their location geographical y), and the different types of providers involved in areas of provision.
• Partnerships in MSM provision: respondents were also asked to indicate the
extent to which they collaborated with partners in the implementation of programmes and delivery of services, and the nature of these partnerships;
• Research in MSM: respondents were asked to indicate whether or not their
organisations were directly involved in the development of any research on MSM and HIV, and the nature and status of this research. This included a consideration of any research pertaining to incidence and prevalence of HIV in MSM populations;
• Gaps, Opportunities and Priorities: final y, respondents were invited to share
their views on the most significant gaps and opportunities in MSM programming and service provision, and to consider the most important priorities for programming and provision if funding were available for these purposes.
Singizi also requested interviewees to make available any grey literature on MSM that they would feel comfortable contributing to the desktop review component of this study. However, most respondents reported not possessing any literature of this nature. The few documents that were made available have been provided to the desktop reviewer.
In line with the requirements that the potential donor organisation for this assessment remain anonymous, respondents were asked to participate in the assessment on this basis. While the vast majority of respondents agreed to participate accordingly, a smal number chose not to participate in the assessment without further detail on the potential donor. Where this was the case, the team has used online and publical y available resources, as wel as references made to specific programmes by other interviewees, to augment some of the gaps in this regard.
4. B: MSM POLICIES AND GUIDELINES
This section reviews the extent to which respondents indicated knowledge of MSM-
related policies and guidelines, or were in possession of guidelines that may have
been developed at the level of the organisation.
Respondents from the National Department of Health (NDoH) referenced the
Department of Health's draft Operational Guidelines for HIV, STIs and TB Programmes
for Key Populations (November 2012) as the key government resource document for
MSM (as wel as other "key populations", including sex workers and intravenous drug
users or IDUs) in South Africa. Both respondents from the NDoH indicated that the
Operational Guidelines have emerged from the National Strategic Plan (NSP) on
HIV, STIs and TB, 2012-2016 and that the Guidelines are an attempt to "standardise"
the NSP for key populations. The respondents indicated further that a national
Prevention Strategy is also in the process of being developed, and that this wil link to
the Operational Guidelines.
While stil in draft form, the NDoH indicated that there had been "wide consultation" on the Operational Guidelines, and that the document is currently being circulated for further input prior to finalisation.
Most Provincial Department of Health respondents were al aware that the national Operational Guidelines were being drafted, and none reported to have any other provincial guidelines or policies in place with regards to MSM in particular. A respondent from Gauteng commented that the province would "rely on national to finalise the guidelines, and then we wil adapt them to suit our own programmes". A respondent from the North West Provincial Department of Health welcomed the finalisation of the Operational Guidelines, and indicated that the government had not made sufficient progress to date in mainstreaming key populations. The respondent indicated that it was the "commitment of government to attend to those issues – key populations – we are trying to focus on those things and orientate our professionals on how to deal with their clients. If a client has an STI, we mustn't exclude them or make assumptions. These are human rights issues".
Eastern Cape and KwaZulu Natal DoH respondents did not appear to be aware of the Operational Guidelines, and both indicated that the NSP guided their policy on provision to MSM. One respondent indicated: "we don't have specific policies. If they (MSM) come to us for treatment, they get the treatment". The respondent from KwaZulu Natal indicated that while the NSP guides implementation, specific policies for MSM were required, and would be welcomed by the Department. The respondent indicated further that Provincial Departments of Health should be "influencing" national government policy, but that – due to issues of stigma associated with MSM in the province – there was "no organised movement in this
regard" and, as such, "no concomitant response to encourage such a policy to be put in place".
NON-GOVERNMENTAL RESPONDENTS (INCLUDING DONORS AND NGOS)
Non-governmental respondents were general y very positive about the
development of the Operational Guidelines, and several respondents reported that
the guidelines were both comprehensive and relevant. Comments included:
"They are good and very comprehensive. In the last couple of years there has been an increasing focus on MSM, with the acknowledgement that it is not just a ‘gay' issue, but that the increased prevalence of HIV amongst MSM affects the whole population"
"The National Guidelines on key populations…they're good, very comprehensive"
"The Guidelines are good. A national strategy does need to happen. There is a need to harmonise legislatively what is happening on a grass roots level"
However, respondents expressed some concerns about the extent to which the Operational Guidelines would be implemented in the spirit intended. As one respondent commented: "I am worried, though, that people are going to be doing the ‘right thing' in implementing the guidelines, but not real y internalising what it means to provide services to key populations. They'l just follow the guidelines and not think about how their behaviour or attitude needs to change". The respondent indicated that the need for identifying how issues of stigma could impact on implementation is an area that needs further exploration.
Another respondent indicated concern about the extent to which the Operational Guidelines would filter down to the level of the health district and health facilities in terms of implementation. The respondent commented: "like so many things in this country, it is not the policy, it is the implementation of the policy where there may be a gap". Linked to this, a respondent indicated that international studies on MSM had suggested that MSM "travel for miles to be treated in ‘safe' facilities" and that it was possibly unrealistic to anticipate that all facilities could become ‘safe' spaces for MSM. It was the view of this respondent that successful implementation of the Operational Guidelines would ultimately be reliant on leadership at the level of individual health facilities, and that this would likely vary.
Respondents were also asked to indicate if they were aware of any other non-governmental guideline documents available for MSM and HIV.
A CDC respondent indicated that for the past few years, the CDC has been involved in developing guidelines and sensitivity training for health care workers. In addition, the CDC has been also working with a number of other organisations to
develop standards for peer educators for key populations. Peer education is seen as a critical part of key populations programmes, and, as reported by the CDC, there has been a very broad range of quality of these educators, and so it is viewed as important to standardise these services. A respondent from PATH indicated that their major work in relation to MSM thus far has been in developing these quality assurance standards for peer educators for key populations. This has involved working with local MSM groups, and has resulted in the development of a Quality Assurance Standards Compendium, which is being finalised, and wil be available by December 2013. The respondent indicated that the need for the standards was identified, as there are a lot of different organisations doing peer education, but they were al doing it differently, so organisations have worked together to try and standardise the approach. The work was USAID funded, and peer educators wil be trained in the standards.
The Anova Health institute, in turn, has played a pivotal role in adapting Department of Health guidelines related to HIV management into protocols and guidelines specific to MSM sexual health, including the promotion and use of combination prevention modalities. In addition, Anova has contributed to international and World Health Organisation MSM guidelines. An Anova staff member also co-chaired the Southern Africa HIV Clinicians Society PrEP guidelines, described below.
The Southern Africa HIV Clinicians Society has compiled Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) guidelines for MSM. These are published in the Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine, June 2012, Issue 44, Vol. 13, No. 2, and are available on the Society's Website (www.sahivsoc.org). A SANAC respondent indicated that it was anticipated that PrEP would become a key focus in the new round of Global Fund funding for MSM.
4. C: MSM AND HIV SERVICES AND PROGRAMMES
SUMMARY OF MSM PROGRAMMING AND SERVICES
This section provides a summary of the provision of MSM programming and services.
The sections that fol ow (Sections 6 to 9) provide further detail on programming and
services provided by government respondents, non-governmental respondents,
private practitioners, as wel as respondents from donor agencies, international
agencies and umbrel a organisations.
GOVERNMENTAL SERVICE PROVISION
The South African Government's (SAG) approach to MSM service provision supports
integrated service delivery to al , including MSM and other identified key
populations. As such, emphasis is placed on ensuring that healthcare workers and
facilities at the coalface of primary health care are equipped to provide MSM with
appropriate services. This is to largely be achieved through sensitisation training, as
wel as concomitant clinical training and mentoring to support MSM and other "key
While interviews with several government respondents emphasised the need for increased sensitisation and related training for healthcare workers, the data emerging in this assessment suggests that there is substantial activity in this regard, both in terms of current training, as wel as planned training pertaining to increasing healthcare workers' competence for MSM. The figure below represents the current coverage of this training and mentoring (as reported by respondents in this assessment), which is presently being rol ed out by organisations such as the Anova Health Institute and ICAP. Between the two institutions, training is planned in all nine provinces. Anova has been undertaking such institutionalising of MSM competence in Gauteng, Limpopo, Mpumalanga, North West and Western Cape, while ICAP has been working in Eastern Cape, Free State, KwaZulu Natal, Limpopo and Northern Cape provinces.
In addition, A Right to Care respondent confirmed that the Global Fund to Fight Aids, Tuberculosis and Malaria (GTAFM) in South Africa is supporting further MSM competent health services (through sensitisation, training and clinical mentoring) in the Free State, Eastern Cape, Northern Cape and KwaZulu Natal to facilitate national coverage. This wil involve 59 existing health facilities in these provinces becoming both MSM and WSW competent. This grant has been awarded to Anova, allowing for a national comprehensive and coordinated response to HIV among MSM.
NON-GOVERNMENTAL SERVICE PROVISION
Service provision has tended to be concentrated in Johannesburg and Pretoria,
Cape Town and Durban, with isolated scatterings of provision in other areas,
primarily through the work of Anova and the ICAP Mosaic initiative. Further, the
geographic summary indicates that the largest portion of programming is in
combination prevention and HCT, with only seven centres countrywide providing
holistic services for MSM, including treatment (six of these are Health4Men initiatives
and the remainder is the OUT clinic in Pretoria).
The table below provides further information on the programmes and services for MSM summarised above. The data is represented by province, and specific areas of provision are outlined in more detail per organisation.
A further mapping exercise is in progress, led by CDC south Africa, which aims to identify MSM programming down to a district level.
Table 1: NON-GOVERNMENTAL Service Provision by Province
OUT (Mosaic/ ICAP)
Other members of
Durban Lesbian & Gay Community
Durban Lesbian & Gay Community
OUT (Mosaic/ ICAP)
Other members of
Pietermaritzburg ICAP Mosaic CoP
Zululand District SHIPP
Other members of
Other members of
other members of
The fol owing sections of the report document and describe programming and services available for MSM in terms of those organisations interviewed for this assessment. The first section outlines government's provision of services and programmes, as wel as information pertaining to government's awareness of other interventions taking place within their spheres of governance.
Fol owing sections, in turn, document and describe programmes and services on the part of non-governmental organisations, in terms of the information provided by respondents.
It is noted here that most respondents were not able to provide information on reach of services in the course of the interviews. However, where this was made available in or after the interview process, the data are included here.
This section of the report deals with government services and programmes for
MSM, including programmes and services funded directly by the SAG, as wel
as programmes run by partners in the relevant areas. In many cases, further
detail on the programmes and services provided by partners is discussed in
more detail in the next section.
This section reviews data from the National Department of Health and eight of the nine Provincial Departments of Health. The Mpumalanga respondent was not available for an interview in the fieldwork timeframe.
NATIONAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
In the course of the interviews, National Department of Health respondents
expressed the view that service provision for MSM needs to be viewed in the
context of the South African Government's (SAG) position of the provision of
integrated services for al . As one respondent commented, "with the
Department, it becomes difficult to talk about specific groups. We encourage
everybody who comes in to be treated as an individual. If a person walks in
as a man, they are treated as a man, and not an MSM…the service we
provide, we provide for everybody. We don't segregate".
The respondent indicated that while non-governmental options for MSM service provision existed in a scattered fashion across the country, the Department was not in a position to establish separate services for key populations, as these are considered "costly and not real y practical". Instead, the SAG's thrust is to ensure that the service needs of different populations can be adequately addressed within existing departmental health facilities. As one NDoH respondent commented: "We are trying to make it for MSM whereby they can access health care from any health care clinic. We are doing that training on those staff that work in the clinics, so that they can deal with them (MSM)". Another NDoH respondent indicated that the training was focused on appropriate clinical intervention for different populations: If they (clinical staff) are dealing with a man who identifies as an MSM, for example, for HIV prevention, we need to consider lubrication, and STI we need to consider anal STI as opposed to hetero transmission. But it doesn't make it any difference who you are - if you're MSM or someone else".
One NDoH respondent indicated that there were a smal group of professional nurses who had been trained to deal with MSM cases in
particular, but that there was a need for greater levels of training, as wel as training across facilities. It was indicated that the trained professional nurses were currently operating from just a few sites, but that there were plans for this to be expanded with the finalisation of the Operational Guidelines.
NDoH respondents indicated that several international donor agencies in South Africa were supporting both capacity building – including sensitisation and clinical training for DoH staff - as wel as direct services provision for MSM and other key populations. These include PEPFAR, USAID, CDC, the Global Fund (GF) and, inter alia, the International Organisation for Migration.
PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENTS OF HEALTH
EASTERN CAPE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The respondent from the Eastern Cape Provincial Government indicated that
apart from the provision of integrated services, the Department had "no
plans to rol out other MSM services in the Department". The respondent
commented, however, that the Operational Guidelines might prompt
changes in this regard when they are completed.
In terms of partnerships, the respondent indicated that ICAP and Mosaic (ICAP's community of service programme described in more detail in Section 7) worked "hand in hand" with the Department to provide services for MSM, and that ICAP was also focusing on training Departmental healthcare workers on "how to deal with MSM when they present at the clinic".
Final y, the respondent indicated that there were other smal organisations within the Province that dealt with MSM and health issues, but he was not aware of the detail of their contributions.
FREE STATE PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The respondent from the Free State Provincial Department of Health
indicated that HIV services for MSM were integrated into general services
available. The respondent also indicated that the Department was awaiting
lubricant supplies from the National Department of Health.
The respondent indicated an NGO cal ed the National LGBTI Health Campaign was the key organisation dealing with MSM issues in the Province, and that their work primarily focused on peer education programmes for LGBTI populations, awareness raising at the level of the community, condom
distribution, pamphlet distribution, and related. It was indicated that the NGO used to be funded directly by the National Department of Health, but that this funding ceased two years ago, whereupon the organisation approached the Provincial Department of Health. The respondent indicated that "we are trying to get them funds, but this has not happened yet", although the organisation reportedly still operates in the Province and works with its Community Health Education Programme (more detail is provided on the National Health Campaign in section 7).
The respondent indicated that ICAP was also working within the province, but the respondent indicated that "they are not working with us" and did not have additional information on their activities. The respondent from ICAP, however, indicated that they were providing sensitisation training for government facility staff in the province (presently in and around Bloemfontein).
GAUTENG DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
Respondents from the Gauteng Department of Health indicated that MSM
are treated routinely at government health facilities that deal with STIs, HIV
and TB, in alignment with the integrated approach to service provision. The
Anova Health Institute's Health4men programme operates col aborative
services at three clinic sites in Johannesburg and Soweto. One respondent
indicated that the Province is proceeding with the rol out of sensitisation
training pertaining to MSM, through the Anova Health Institute, and that the
first three health districts include Ekurhuleni, Tshwane and the West Rand.
Data on the numbers trained to date were not available from the
Department, but the respondent indicated that the intervention aims to "train
everybody, from the security guy at the gate, to the clinician on dealing with
issues that limit MSM access to our services". The training wil reportedly
primarily focus on clinics, but it was indicated that it would ultimately cover
"the entire spectrum of healthcare services, from primary health care, to
CHCs, to your district hospital".
Another Gauteng respondent indicated that the non-governmental organisation, OUT, has a clinic in the province (located in Hatfield, Pretoria), and that MSM are also referred to the OUT clinic for treatment, if this is within reasonable reach for the client. It was indicated that the Gauteng Department of Health also directly funds OUT for a peer education programme for MSM. It was reported that in the current financial year, a total of 8000 individuals were reached through this peer education programme in the province.
The Gauteng Department of Health also reports that it directly funds the Soweto HIV/AIDS Counsel ors Association (SOHACA) for its peer education programme, which provides general support and counselling for people affected and infected by HIV and AIDS, including children, women, and the gay, lesbian and transgender community. It was indicated that the Department - as part of its imperative to minimise stigma - funds the Association.
The respondents did not discuss support provided by ICAP in the Province, but this is outlined further below.
KWAZULU NATAL PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The KwaZulu Natal Department of Health (Zululand district) indicated that
they were not aware of any NGOs or partners in the district addressing the
issue of MSM. The respondent indicated, however, that the Department was
very eager to consider how to better support MSM in terms of prevention,
treatment and care, but that the Department has no sense of the need in this
regard. As the respondent commented:
"We want to provide [services for MSM] but we don't have clients who say they are MSM. We'd like to find out from them what protection we can provide for them, what capacity building we can provide for them, how we can help them…information or anything that wil help them. But we don't know about them: who they are or what they want. If they are there, like the sex workers, then they could have a forum where we could support them".
The respondent indicated that one of the factors that potential y fed into the perceived invisibility of MSM in the province related to the fact that large areas of KZN are rural, and that "traditional" norms and values militate against open discussion of issues pertaining to MSM, which is considered by many to be "taboo".
The respondent acknowledged that KwaZulu Natal had not done anything active to challenge MSM to come forward and to encourage them to express their needs from a health perspective and that it was "necessary to implement interventions to help them come out", but that the Department was unclear about how people would respond to such potential interventions, given the extent of conservative views, especial y in rural areas.
The respondent indicated that one possible area of initial intervention – although this had not been decided on – would be to train nurses from
community outreach teams on MSM, including sensitisation on MSM, as well as MSM service provision.
Section 7 provides information from non-governmental respondents on programmes and services that are taking place in the province, including ICAP (sensitisation training for DoH staff), ICAP's Mosaic programme, and related.
LIMPOPO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The province has signed an agreement with the Anova Health Institute to extend MSM competent services in the province, most notably in the Mopani and Vhembe districts. Anova and the department have jointly launched a MSM-focused Regional Leadership Site to drive this process, in Tzaneen. This was fol owed by the first MSM symposium in Limpopo in October. The respondent from the Limpopo Department of Health also indicated that ICAP undertakes sensitisation training in the Capricorn District, as wel as prevention education programmes accompanying the distribution of lubricants and condoms.
NORTHERN CAPE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The respondent from the Northern Cape indicated that apart from integrated
services available to al clients, the Province currently has a partnership with
ICAP, that has developed a programme to train staff to deal with MSM cases
and to promote access for MSM. It was indicated that ICAP is currently
providing the training in the Francis Baart District (around Kimberly), but has
not expanded from this base to date, although the province hopes to have
the training conducted across the province, which includes approximately
210 health facilities. The initial focus, however, wil reportedly be on high
transmission areas, although the respondent indicated that data in this regard
was not available. The respondent specified that the training focused not
only on MSM, but included al the groups specified in the "key populations".
The respondent indicated that there was little additional NGO activity in the Province regarding MSM, and indicated that "… a lot of NGOs or developmental partners don't want to come to the Northern Cape because of the distances. If you have to travel to one district to another the distance is vast. It's not easy to get in your car and travel. To get to Springbok you travel a day".
The respondent indicated that condom distribution was sometimes a chal enge in the province, as there was only one truck responsible for distributing condoms to facilities in the province. This reportedly resulted in condom shortages on occasion. It was indicated that an NGO, the Society for Family Health was one of the entities in the province that distributed condoms in far-reaching areas and that, in the Siyanda District, TB and HIV Care Association focused on condom access and male sexual health, although this was not specifically targeted at MSM.
Final y, the respondent indicated that the Department aimed to distribute lubrication, but was awaiting the go-ahead from national government to order supplies. The respondent indicated that he understood that a "company has donated lubrication to national and we are awaiting them on that".
NORTH WEST PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The respondent from the North West Department of Health was not aware of
any MSM activities within the Province already underway but noted that an
MOU for the extension of MSM competency training has recently been signed
Other NGO respondents interviewed in this process did not report that they work in the province, although there are some smal local NGO's in parts of the province.
MPUMALANGA PROVINCIAL DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The respondent from the Mpumalanga Department of Health was not
available for interview during the assessment time frame. However, the
Department is actively partnering in the establishment of MSM-competency
training in the province, with an Anova Regional Leadership Site official y
opened in Nelspruit by senior Department officials in mid-2013 and another
clinic due to open on World AIDS Day 2013 in Ermelo. The Department is also
aware and supportive of Project Boithato's work in the province.
WESTERN CAPE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
Similar to the Gauteng Department of Health, the respondent from the
Western Cape Department indicated that services are provided to MSM
along with the general population, and that no specific government
interventions were in place at scale in this regard in the Province. The respondent indicated that testing was available at al facilities, and that condoms were also made available at al facilities. However, it was indicated that counsel ing and treatment was not available at district level hospitals and some clinics. The respondent indicated that in terms of MSM in particular, the Department had made a decision to make lubrication available at al health facilities, and that this was underway. He acknowledged that the Province was aware of the imperative to address key populations, including MSM, but that issues pertaining to key populations had yet to be ful y addressed.
The respondent indicated that the City of Cape Town had opened three male clinics to provide men with access to preventative and curative services, and that MSM clientele reportedly access these. The clinics provide HIV testing and counsel ing, condom distribution, treatment of STIs, TB screening and other health services. The three clinics are located in Khayelitsha, Gugulethu and Bel vil e. The Anova Health institute supports the Khayalitsha and Bel vil e clinics.
The respondent indicated that there are also non-governmental organisations in the province that provide specific support to MSM. The respondent referred to the Anova-funded Health4Men clinic in Woodstock, which is run in partnership with the Department. The respondent indicated that Anova's MSM focus was considered a considerable asset in the Province, and that, as a result of the limited geographical spread and limited scope of MSM services, the City was in discussions with the Anova Health Institute to address this.
NON GOVERNMENTAL SECTOR
This section provides further detail on organisations already mentioned by government respondents, as well as additional detail on other organisations not mentioned.
THE ANOVA HEATH INSTITUTE
Anova has focused on MSM sexual health since 2008, through its Health4Men
project which aims to provide access to "competent, prejudice-free sexual
health care for men who have sex with men and the promotion of a sex-
positive attitude among health care workers" (www.health4men.co.za). In this
regard Anova established Africa's first two MSM sexual health Centres of
Excel ence (in the Western Cape and Gauteng), each supported by a
network of MSM competent sites.
This process has al owed Anova to pioneer MSM-competent services within the public sector by developing and refining MSM-focused protocols and guidelines, in partnership with the Department of Health. In addition, direct service provision to MSM has al owed for the development of the largest database on MSM sexual health on the continent, which is a vital asset for Anova's ongoing biomedical and psychosocial research processes.
Anova has developed expertise in combination prevention methodologies, including prevention for positive MSM , PrEP, PEP and TasP, STI management, MSM-related mental health and working with particularly vulnerable MSM. The latter includes a harm-reduction programme for IDU MSM (with a needle exchange programme), MSM sex workers and displaced people, and transgender clients.
Anova has received funding from PEPFAR/USAID to extend MSM competence within the public health sector in five provinces through a tested model of sensitisation, training, mentoring and ongoing technical assistance to health workers.
This is currently being undertaken in the fol owing geographical areas:
CoJ, West Rand, Ekurhuleni,
Ehlanzeni, Gert Sibande,
Dr K Kaunda, Bojanala, Dr
Metro, Eden, Winelands
Total competent sites
Total competent clinicians
Total competent staff
As previously noted, during October 2013 Anova received an additonal grant from the Global Fund for AIDS, TB and Malaria (GFATM), through Right to Care, to extend this intervention into the remaining provinces (KwaZulu-Natal, Eastern Cape, Northern Cape and Free State) al owing for an integrated national response.
Anova has developed expertise in various forms of public engagement and messaging targeting diverse MSM groupings, including developing innovative media products ranging from print media to public bil boards, and utilises mHealth. The latter includes the H4M mobi site (h4m.mobi), using cel ular phone technology, where MSM can access information as wel as post anonymous questions to Anova's medical team. Anova's outreach programme, referred to in published articles as Ukwazana, was developed in partnership with the University of Cambridge and addresses MSM sexual health and barriers to MSM accessing health care. The outreach model includes an emphasis on partnering with shebeen / tavern owners to disseminate topical MSM-specific information plus branded condoms and lubricant sachets. Anova's black condoms are in demand by various bodies, including SAPS and parliament.
Anova conducts both national and provincial MSM-related symposia aiming to disseminate its model of excel ence in MSM sexual healthcare and has developed extensive training materials.
ICAP, which has been operating since 2004, is situated at Columbia University,
and aims to improve the health of families and communities through health
system strengthening and has, to date, worked in 21 countries across the
ICAP has been operating in South Africa since its inception year, initial y with a focus on HIV prevention, care and support for the general population, using primarily a clinical approach. Since 2008, with the receipt of CDC funding, the Most at Risk Populations (MARPs) programme has been implemented, with a focus on prevention. ICAP's general population work is on-going, with foci on PMTCT and paediatric HIV, TB and HIV, the Medical Education Partnerships Initiative (MEPI) programme for nurses and the provision of technical assistance to government, among other areas.
According to the respondent from ICAP, the MARPs programme is essential y around prevention, and one component is a national capacity building programme in which they work with the NDoH and Provincial Departments around building capacity to work with mainly sex workers, IDUs and MSM. In order to implement the capacity building programme, ICAP contracts local partners (such as OUT in Gauteng and the DTHF in the Western Cape, amongst others) to conduct the sensitisation training with facility staff. In addition, ICAP conducts clinical training to improve clinical competence for managing cases for sex workers, MSM and IDUs, which are supported by a mentoring programme in a few health facilities. In terms of the sensitisation training referred to above, ICAP indicates that they worked with several partners to develop "an integrated sensitisation manual" and wil be commencing with train-the-trainer processes using this manual this October, to be fol owed by pilot training in 2014.
In addition to the national capacity building programme, the ICAP respondent explained that its MSM programme is, principal y, a combination prevention programme. ICAP reports that it completed a needs assessment around MSM programming in March 2012, and identified NGOs who were already working with, or who had the potential to work with, MSM in the geographical areas they had identified. The needs assessment established that there was a high level of duplication, and very little coordination across NGOs and that, in turn, many NGOs were competing for limited resources available for MSM work.
Consequently, ICAP developed a framework around a combination prevention programme using a "community of practice" approach, whereby
it brought identified NGOs together, and then al ocated responsibility for various aspects of the programme. This programme is now known as the Mosaic Men's Health Initiative.
The respondent indicated that one example of Mosaic is that in Durban, the Durban Gay and Lesbian Centre provides peer counsel ing, SANCA does treatment for MSM who are also substance abusers, Lovelife works with young MSM people and Lifeline provides psychosocial support for MSM. The respondent indicated that "this approach works wel . It strengthens linkages between organisations, and enables us to provide a broad range of services. There is definitely a wil ingness to col aborate amongst the NGOs". However, he added that the approach involved "a lot of effort to bring people together".
The table below indicates the provinces and areas that ICAP currently operates in, as well as where it plans to extend to in 2014:
Locations to which the
programmes wil be extended
Lejwelaputswa District (around Welkom)
Empangeni Areas surrounding Pietermaritzburg
Additional Districts around Kimberly
The ICAP respondent noted that the organisation had tried to deliberately focus on the inclusion of both urban and rural areas, and that in 2014 they would also attempt to work in some "deep" rural areas, albeit that they had little experience in this regard. The respondent indicated that working across these different locales had revealed the extent to which local contextual issues impact on prevention. For example, it was reported that cultural and religious issues in Durban heavily impact on MSM access to support, whereas in a locale such as Kimberly, the risk issues are much more strongly linked to MSM who are abusing substances. This learning is seen to support the "community of practice" approach, such that programmes and interventions are shaped within a specific context, and with the cooperation and coordination of players operating within those contexts. As the respondent
commented, "because the interventions are led by the community, they are much more contextualized, and much more sustainable".
ICAP supplies Mosaic-branded condoms (male and "female" – the latter of which are being rebranded as "external" condoms for use in anal sex) and lubricants to many of its partner organisations, but these are currently in short supply as a result of budgetary constraints.
The respondent did not supply data on reach in terms of the Mosaic programme, but some of the Mosaic organisations were interviewed in the course of this process, and reach data is reported where this was available.
DIAMOND GAYS AND LESBIANS ORGANISATION
The Diamond Gay and Lesbian Organisation is one of the partners working
with ICAP in the "community of practice" approach discussed above. The
organisation deals with LGBTI populations, and reportedly focuses specifical y
on MSM sex workers in terms of HIV.
The organisation reported that its routine work involves door-to-door awareness raising, telephone counsel ing, and the organisation also participate in radio talk shows in which individuals are able to call in and ask questions about MSM. Its five-year plan is to increasingly offer workshops on MSM and HIV, facilitate film festivals that screen educational films on MSM issues, and to focus on additional awareness-raising activities. In addition to these activities, the organisation distributes condoms and lubricant to MSM (which are reportedly supplied by ICAP), but it is presently out of stock of condoms. The respondent indicated that MSM "don't want the government Choice condoms", and that their clients preferred the Mosaic condoms, which are both coloured and flavoured and, reportedly, larger than the Choice condoms.
The organisation reportedly has no office, and is currently running its operations from the house of the director/head.
In terms of its work with ICAP, Diamond is working with Lifeline in the Northern Cape, around Kimberly, to train health care workers on counsel ing and testing MSM. The respondent indicated that in some of their training, some healthcare workers started out "not understanding at al what MSM is about", and that is was challenging to change mind sets. It was reported that Diamond and Lifeline intend to work with the Department of Health (through ICAP) over the next eight years, providing training, monthly workshops, road shows and radio shows.
DURBAN LESBIAN AND GAY COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTRE
The Durban Centre is a drop-in centre that aims to provide "safe and secure
spaces for lesbians, transgender, gay, bisexual and intersex communities in
Durban and KwaZulu Natal".
The Centre provides services to LGBTI through counselling and support groups, HIV education and support, legal advice, and other social and health activities. The Centre provides HCT for MSM and other populations, as wel as TB and STI screening services, and refers clients to suitable facilities, as relevant for treatment, as required.
The Centre also provides a mobile outreach service and they mobile clinic is taken to correctional services, tertiary institutions, taxi ranks and shopping centres. The respondent reported that reach tends to be greater when the mobile clinic is used for outreach. It was reported that there might be seven individuals a week who seek HIV services at the Centre, but up to 50 people are reached in one week in an outreach exercise (using 2 to 3 outreach offers).
The Centre has now partnered with ICAP, and intends to "establish their grounding better first, and then to grow the programme and extend its reach". The Centre has, through ICAP, also started sensitisation training for health care workers, and views itself as becoming a "service providing space, as well as a training space".
The organisation also disseminates DoH Choice condoms, Mosaic condoms (from ICAP) and lubricant from separate funding. The respondent was not able to provide an indication of reach.
Lifeline Durban is a forty-four year old institution with the core business of
promoting emotional wel being. The organisation offers 24 hour a day
counselling, 7 days a week (telephonic and face-to-face) and HIV testing
and awareness. There is also a Training Department, which advances peer-to-
Lifeline has a "High Risk Project" which focuses on key populations, including sex workers, IDUs and MSM. The respondent indicated that the overal approach is to "establish relationships. Starting with the counselling and emotional wellbeing focus, which then gets us to the testing phase. We assist with referrals to clinic and then work on plans with each client and then refer to social workers to continue".
The peer-to-peer training programme, in turn, provides skil s development in emotional wellness and, in this way, offers clients from high-risk groups an opportunity to learn and develop skil s. They could then potential y become part of the outreach team who work with the peer-to-peer model. They then provide HIV support groups for key populations. The respondent indicated that "65% of peer educators were high risk them selves".
Lifeline Durban is one of ICAP's Mosaic partners, and also partners with MATCH (a research organisation) and SWEAT.
The respondent was not able to provide information on reach in terms of the high-risk project.
ECGLA (EASTERN CAPE GAY AND LESBIAN ASSOCIATION)
ECGLA is a smal organisation that includes a Director, four outreach workers,
a counsel or, six volunteers and support staff. The organisation assists LGBTI
individuals in terms of HIV testing, TB screening, and diabetes testing, and wil
include testing for syphilis and Hepatitis B in the near future. The organisation
indicated that they would be expanding their offerings to the heterosexual
community, as "we don't always hear from the gay community, as the EC is
stil very closed about any of these issues".
The respondent reported that their staff from the organisation travel to people's homes for testing, as they do not have the funding for a centre. The outreach workers visit nightclubs and university campuses in order to create awareness.
The organisation received condoms for distribution from the DoH, and also distributes condoms from ICAP. ICAP also supplies lubricant, although both the ICAP condoms and lubricant are apparently not presently available. The respondent reported that the organisation also actively promotes the use of female condoms for anal sex, as research from Canada has indicated that these are considered comfortable for anal sex and also have a lower possibility of producing an allergic reaction. The organisation prefers to promote the DoH female condoms for these purposes, as the ICAP female condoms reportedly have a sponge with spermicide at the bottom, which makes them less appealing to MSM.
Project Boithato is a col aborative project of the University of California, San
Francisco (UCSF) and the Anova Health Institute. The project is an adaption of
the MPowerment Project in a rural South African setting. The MPowerment
Project is a US HIV prevention programme for young gay and bisexual men
that focuses on:
• "Personal and community empowerment • Diffusion of new behaviours through social networks; • Peer influence • Putting HIV prevention within the context of other compel ing issues for
young gay/bisexual men (e.g. social issues)
• Community building • Using gay-positive approaches" (http://caps.ucsf.edu/mpowerment/)
Project Boithato provided HIV interventions that focus on MSM. Currently, the project focuses on the Gert Sibande district, including almost all of the encompassed sub districts, excluding Depaleseng Sub-district. There is a project space in Ermelo, which is an informative safe and relaxing space for MSM. The Boithato project promotes safer sex unity among MSM and a community that is free from discrimination and stigma which both contribute to MSM being at risk for HIV. Project Boithato uses multi-level approaches addressing individual factors such as misperceptions about safe and unsafe sexual behaviour, interpersonal factors such as being unable to negotiate sexual situations, social/community level factors such as social stigma towards MSM, and environmental factors such as health services unfriendly to MSM. The project works in line with the NSP to provide an MSM targeted intervention. Additional y, it works in close cooperation with the Mpumalanga Department of Health. The project aims to use peer influence to recruit MSM into the project, believing that it is easier and more influential to glean information from your friends, as opposed to strangers. There is a Core Group made up of MSM volunteers. These members are the decision makers and plan social activities, including "Bar Zaps" (condom and lube education and distribution in bars). The Core Group members also recruit through informal outreach by spreading information through word of mouth and inviting friends to the project space. "Mgroup" are guided group discussions with between 8 to 12 men focusing on skil s building in areas such as negotiating condom use, safer sex techniques, and how to encourage one another to test for HIV. Additional y, Mgroups have condom and lube demonstrations in a fun environment. Project Boithato's goal is to reduce unprotected anal sex, increase HIV testing at least every 6 months and for HIV positive MSM to get on ART at the right time and to take their medications regularly.
LIMPOPO LGBTI PROUDLY OUT
Limpopo's Proudly Out is a LGBTI-focused organisation that focuses on
awareness and education about LGBTI, and also HIV safety and awareness
for LGBTI. The organisation also takes a counsel or to its events and
campaigns to provide counselling and testing services.
In terms of MSM specifically, the respondent indicated that they run workshops and provide education talks for MSM and try to "…draw them out and to teach them how their behaviour puts them at risk". The organisation offers a peer mentoring programme, and aims to get MSM to become involved and own their own processes. This programme has been extended to universities and col eges, but is not yet available in schools.
Since November 2012, the organisation has provided face-to-face
counselling to 600 MSM in Polokwane, and has reached 3500 individuals
through workshops and dialogues, or open discussions. The respondent
indicated that the organisation tries to fol ow up the men that it reached by
visiting drinking spots or telephoning them to "check how they are doing"
and encourage healthy choices and active participation. However, the
respondent noted that cultural "norms" impact heavily on MSM participation
in the province, most notably in more rural areas, such as Venda. As the
respondent commented: "In Venda it is extremely difficult because of the
place and culture. This is big stigma. They don't want to hear about it [MSM].
They think we are promoting it. It doesn't exist here. You wil bring it. If they
had a safe place to go then maybe they wouldn't drink and carry on with the
In addition to the awareness raising, peer mentoring and education programmes, Proudly Out also distributes condoms and lubricants. It was reported that the lubricants are now starting to be supplied by the Department of Health, and that up until recently, ICAP supplied both condoms and lubricants, which are presently not available. The Anova Health Institute is reportedly supplying condoms and lubricants in Venda and Mopane, but the respondent indicated that "we always need more…though if we could, we'd ask for the loose ones rather than the bigger packs. They're easier to put in your pocket when you are out jol ing [partying]".
The testing kits reportedly come from the DoH and ICAP.
Proudly Out is also involved in training staff in the clinics to not treat MSM judgementally. The respondent indicated, however, that a core concern was that even if services become more MSM friendly, very few MSM come to the clinics when they have engaged in unsafe sex. The respondent reported that 6 out of 10 MSM they speak to are HIV positive, and yet they do not want to
be "caught out", as it results in losing their jobs, or being thrown out their homes.
Final y, the respondent indicated that local municipalities in Limpopo were beginning to come on board in terms of MSM. The respondent indicated that there was now a gender forum in place, which at least "opens the doors for discussion".
NATIONAL LGBTI HEALTH CAMPAIGN
The National LGBTI Health Campaign is located in Bloemfontein and focuses
on LGBTI populations, including MSM. The organisation mainly focuses on
outreach activities for LGBTI for advocacy and awareness raising purposes
(including face to face counsel ing, community workshops and dialogues),
and also facilitates support groups for LGBTI. The organisation also
participates in radio programmes pertaining to LGBTI, and engages
organisations such as the media and local churches.
In terms of HIV services, the Campaign provides HCT services, as wel as testing support groups, and has staff placed at clinics in the area to support this. The testing kits are provided by the DoH. The Campaign also distributes condoms and lubrication (supplied by ICAP), and provides education on the use of lubricant as part of the distribution process. The respondent indicated that there is a need for more lubricant than they are currently supplied with. The Campaign also assists to trace HIV clients to support monitoring their progress and promoting adherence.
The respondent indicated that in terms of their current activities, the targets – which are usual y always reached – include 800 people receiving HCT per month, 1000 people reached through door to door activities per month, 800 people reached through community dialogues per month and 160 people attending support groups per month.
OUT LGBT WELLBEING
The Gauteng-based OUT has a clinic in Pretoria, which has been in existence
for twenty years, and provides health services to the lesbian, gay, bisexual
and transgender communities. Their services include HIV counsel ing and
testing, treatment, STI screening and general lifestyle advice and support. The
respondent indicated that OUT presently has approximately 1000 clients on
their clinic books.
OUT reports that it received its testing kits from the DoH, but is responsible for the procurement of its own condoms and lubrication. The respondent indicated that the clinic preferred to purchase coloured condoms, as they are "more attractive to use". The facility reports that it distributes more than 100 000 condoms and lubricants (packaged together) every year. These are distributed at the clinic, and also at shebeens and outreach spots in and around Pretoria.
Also in terms of prevention, OUT has a peer education programme, and also operates two websites, hosts an electronic newsletter, and runs an SMS service for their client targets. Relevant articles, news and education materials are also placed in the gay press. Psychosocial services are available on line, as wel as on a face-to-face basis.
OUT is involved in advocacy work for LGBTI, which currently focuses on HIV and hate crime work. OUT represents LGBTI issues within the SANAC High Plenary, Programme Implementation Committee, the Women's Sector and the Research and Monitoring Task Team.
OUT indicates that it has played an active role in proposing a national programme to reach the MSM related targets in the current National Strategic Plan and to ensure inclusion of targets in the NSP for 2012 and beyond.
OUT is also a member of the African Men for Sexual Health and Rights (AMSHeR) and plays an active role to promote the interest of MSM on the continent.
In addition to the above, OUT works with ICAP in terms of its capacity building programme, and trains Department of Health workers in facilities on how to deal with key populations. At present, OUT is providing training in five provinces, including the Eastern Cape, Northern Cape, Free State, KwaZulu Natal and Limpopo.
The OUT respondent indicated that they are currently planning more focused programming in government clinics in Pretoria in terms of training, mentoring and outreach. The respondent indicated that through this strategy, they aimed to increase reach, as the OUT clinic only addressed "a small percentage of the target group". It was noted, however, that extending reach to LGBTI populations was a chal enge, as "a large percentage of them do not have very good health seeking behaviours. Activities are made very difficult by their own lack of health seeking behaviour".
The Triangle Project, which is based in the Western Cape, is an NGO that
focuses on supporting LGBTI populations through education, advocacy and
community awareness. In addition to its broader advocacy and awareness-
raising work, the Triangle Project also provides specific health-related services
to LGBTI populations.
Triangle has its own clinic in Mowbray for LGBTI, which operates at night specifical y for MSM. The clinic provides rapid HIV testing, along with pre and post test counsel ing, which Triangle considers a priority. If a client tests positive in the rapid test, bloods are sent to a laboratory for a confirmatory ELISA test. The clinic also sends out bloods for CD4 counts, viral loads and STI testing. While general medical consultations are available, if a client requires ART, they are referred to relevant community health clinics for treatment. The respondent indicated that approximately 300 clients receive HIV counsel ing per month at the facility.
The clinic also offers one-on-one psychosocial counselling, and safe sex training.
The Triangle Project reports that it purchases its own testing kits for rapid testing, and these are obtained from a pharmaceutical company. The respondent indicated that obtaining rapid testing kits from the DoH or another source would be "hugely beneficial" to the organisation, as the kits are costly. The Project does receive lubricants and condoms from the DoH, as wel as NACOSA.
The project did not provide reach data.
WITS REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH AND HIV INSTITUTE (WITS RHI)
The Wits RHI is a research institute of the University of the Witwatersrand and is
part of the Faculty of Health Sciences. Established in 1994 as the Reproductive
Health Research Unit (RHRU), the Institute was formed on 1 October 2010
through a merger with Enhancing Children's HIV Outcomes (ECHO).
The WRHI conducts research and provides programmatic support, training, policy development and health system strengthening.
The Wits RHI reported that they do not have any formal programming for MSM. It was indicated that at one point, the organisation was working with MSM sex workers in Hil brow, but that funding for the initiative was halted. The respondent indicated that the Wits RHI was intending to revisit MSM work, with a specific focus on research into HIV prevalence and STI prevalence, and
factors such as resistance to antiretrovirals. It was indicated that there was a possibility that this would be linked to the Institute's broader sex worker programme and work with migrating truckers, but this has not been decided.
DESMOND TUTU HIV FOUNDATION
The Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation (DTHF) developed from the HIV Research
Unit at New Somerset Hospital in the early 1990's, which has since been
registered as a Section 21 non profit organisation, supported by Emeritus
Archbishop Desmond Tutu and Mrs Leah Tutu. The Foundation's activities
include HIV prevention, treatment, and training as wel as tuberculosis
screening and management among some of the most vulnerable
communities of the Western Cape. The work is underpinned by academic
research undertaken by the Desmond Tutu HIV Centre (DTHC). The Centre,
based at the University of Cape Town's Institute of Infectious Disease and
Molecular Medicine, operates symbiotical y with the Foundation's local field
sites in the Nyanga area of Cape Town and Masiphumelele, Noordhoek.
The Foundation has a Men's Health Division, which explores the incidence of HIV among marginalised groups such as men who have sex with men (MSM). The Division aims to support MSM, and to change pervasive negative perceptions of MSM through research and community engagement.
The DTHF indicated that while its core mandate is research, the nature of the research processes is both proactive and action-oriented. As such, MSM research participants receive screening, treatment, as wel as referrals for comprehensive medical care. It was indicated that to date, 525 MSM have participated in two action-oriented research studies in this regard.
In addition to these research studies, the DTHF manages a community engagement programme in which they support 6 different groups of MSM in townships, which aim to promote proactive health seeking behaviour, as wel as providing appropriate referrals and related support.
The DTHF indicates that it works in close partnership with the Health4Men clinics in the Western Cape, and refers study participants to Health4Men for services. The DTHF also works in col aboration with OUT and the Triangle Project.
SOUTH AFRICAN GAY AND LESBIAN ALLIANCE AGAINST DEFAMATION
The SA Gay & Lesbian Al iance Against Defamation (SA GLAAD) is an equal
civil rights advocacy group that documents and responds to homophobia
and heterosexism in the South African popular media and society. The
respondent indicated that responses to defamation range from letter writing
campaigns, to direct action activism and protests. The goal of SA GLAAD is
the elimination of anti gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgendered and intersex bias
in reporting, television and film. In general, GLAAD does not directly interface
with the health system and does not have health-related programming.
The GLAAD respondent from the Free State branch interviewed for these purposes indicated that GLAAD FS has adopted a hands-on approach to the rights of the individual, and continuously assists members of the LGBTI community to access services provided by the S.A. Human Rights Commission, the Equality Courts, and similar institutions. GLAAD also provides support during these processes and, if possible, facilitates alternative dispute resolution processes.
While GLAAD focuses on supporting LGBTI populations in general, the respondent indicated that the MSM community in the Free State (specifical y in Bloemfontein) is "enormous" and that it is a significant challenge that high levels of stigma exist, such that MSM is practiced "in total secrecy".
SA GLAAD FS has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with the S. A. Human Rights Commission, which provides assistance and legal recourse for the violation of LGBTI Human Rights. No formal agreements exist between SA GLAAD FS and any healthcare service providers.
THE NETWORKING HIV/AIDS COMMUNITY OF SOUTH AFRICA
NACOSA is a civil society network of organisations working in the HIV, AIDS, TB
and related social development fields. It has over 1200 members comprised
on CBOs and not-for-profit organisations, and aims to "turn the tide on
HIV/AIDS and TB through grant management, capacity building, and
networking and promoting dialogue" (Global Fund Round 9 Phase I : Men
having Sex with Men/Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersexed
(MSM/LGBTI), Tertiary Institution Programme Description, 2013)
According to NACOSA's 2013 submission to the Global Find, NACOSA's MSM programme was initiated in 2008 with sensitivity training in the Western Cape,
which was taken up by NASTAD (National Al iance of State and Territorial Directors) and the CDC, South Africa.
In December 2009 NACOSA was selected as a civil society Principal Recipient of GF Round 9 funding, which al owed the organisation to channel GF monies to local organisations in the HIV/AIDS sector. A large proportion of NACOSA‘s grant focused on most-at-risk populations (MARPS). NACOSA directs funds to projects aimed at abused and raped women, sex workers, and men who have sex with men (MSM).
The NACOSA respondent indicated that the MSM activities covered in Phase I (and implemented by Anova's Health4Men project and the Triangle Project) included HCT, peer educator outreach (with the distribution of condoms and lubricants) and IEC materials development and dissemination. It also further covered aspects of prevention through risk reduction workshops and support groups. Access to care was addressed through sensitisation trainings of health care professionals. The 2013 GF submission indicates that these activities wil continue, while NACOSA wil focus on a university campus-based programme for Phase I of the current Global Fund country programme, which wil be starting in October 2013.
In terms of the campus-based programme, the respondent indicated that the core objectives are:
• To conduct Rapid KAP Surveys at 12 identified universities – Extension
Period before phase I of the Global Fund grant starts - June to September 2013
• To establish and strengthen MSM/LGBTI friendly health services on
campuses – Phase I , from October 2013
• To create a Supportive Environment for MSM/LGBTI students and staff
to access health care
• To co-ordinate, manage, monitor and evaluate the programme to
ensure successful implementation
In the course of Phase I, an electronic sex health survey was completed that focused on students in general, but also LGBTI, including MSM. In Phase I , 13 higher education institutions (with the possibility of the remaining ten universities being addressed later in the programme) will each receive a coordinator, who wil be based at the HIV Unit on campus. The respondent indicated that their role will be to focus on key populations, including MSM, and that key activities wil include HCT, referral for ART (through the campus health facilities), psychosocial support, risk-reduction counsel ing and putting support groups in place. In addition, the programme wil focus on initiating campus dialogues with and between students and staff, and ensuring that MSM are "not overlooked" in general HIV drives on campus. The programme
wil also include sensitisation training for health staff and academic staff on campus.
The respondent indicated that there was a need to consider appropriately branded student condoms and lubrication packs for MSM students, as wel as the printing of IEC materials. It was indicated that there was a lack of funding for these specific activities.
SUMMARY OF REACH OF NON-GOVERNMENTAL SERVICES AND
The table below provides a summary of the reach data reported by
organisations that were able to do so in the course of the interviews. As a
result of this data being incomplete, it does not provide a comprehensive
sense of reach for MSM programmes and services,
Sensitivity and clinical GP
mentoring to DoH
(Simon Nkoli, Zola
treatment services for CHC and Chiawelo Excel ence MSM
Toms, Belvil e and
reached close to 10 000 known MSM with health care, of whom currently 1882 are HIV positive and in care, and 1226 are receiving antiretroviral therapy.
Institute & UCSF
FS - Bloemfontein,
facility staff to deal
LP - Polokwane, KzN
– Durban and Pietermaritzburg
Mosaic: combination NC – Kimberly
FS - Bloemfontein,
LP - Polokwane, KzN
with local partners,
lubricant distribution, peer education, psychosocial support.
Diamond Gays Awareness raising
such as radio), peer education, counselling for MSM, with a specific focus on MSM sex workers Works with ICAP and
Lifeline to train DoH
staff on counsel ing and testing for MSM
Durban Lesbian HCT and STI and TB
and 50 per week when doing outreach
Lifeline Durban Counsel ing high risk
KzN - Durban and
(excluding once-off visits) This increased from 3500 the previous year
LP – Polokwane
across the province 600 MSM in
(incl. Mopani and
Staff training at clinics
Civil rights advocacy
for LGBTI, but not
health sector or
access to health specifical y
FS - Bloemfontein
and education on
dialogues 800 pm Support groups 160 pm
Gauteng - Pretoria
HCT STI Treatment
Training of healthcare EC
populations in five
Triangle Project Rapid testing for MSM WC - Mowbray
Pre and post test
Sending bloods to labs for CD4, viral load and STI General medical
HCT Peer outreach IEC materials Distribution of condoms and lubricant (Implemented by H4M and Triangle)
programme: HCT Counsel ing Staff sensitization
Smal funding to local MP – Gert Sibande
In addition to the NGO respondents above, the Singizi team also interviewed two
private practitioners in order to understand service provision at the level of the
The private practitioners indicated that their provision of services in a perceived safe space for MSM had largely grown and developed on the basis of word of mouth, and that their clients – who can afford medical cover – prefer to receive medical care from doctors who have a pre-established reputation for being MSM-friendly.
Both practitioners indicated, however, that unlike self-proclaimed LGBTI and MSM organisations, private practitioners tend not to advertise their services as "MSM" for fear of alienating potential y homophobic clientele. One respondent indicated that even advertising a practice as a practice that also provides HIV services tends to alienate other clients and stigmatise the practice. The respondent indicated that he knew of a practitioner who advertised her HIV services, and landed up having to close the practice down – both because HIV clients did not want their status known and because other clients did not want to be associated with a HIV service.
One respondent indicated that it was his perception that there seemed to be a diminished number of private practitioners providing safe spaces for MSM service provision. He indicated that "back in the eighties and nineties, there were a lot more [private practitioners]…when everything was more underground. There were several GPs you would know about that would provide a sympathetic ear". At the same time, however, medical aids "targeted" practitioners providing HIV services, and had exclusionary policies in place, such that those who tended to seek medical help for HIV needed to cover this privately. The respondent indicated that currently, it seemed to him that "the numbers of sympathetic ears have diminished – unless I am not in touch with new blood coming in. I have a sense that the average age of GPs has remained the same, and there has been a lot of emigration. I know fewer GPs now providing MSM services".
One respondent indicated that there was a need for the strengthening of a community of practitioners who could better support MSM clients and each other as practitioners. The respondent indicated that "lots of practitioners are solo practitioners, who end up doing a lot of STI and HIV work, and they burn out". A community of practitioners, however, could potential y reduce the burden on individual GPs, and could also potential y serve as an opportunity to extend outreach. The respondent suggested that, for example, linkages would be created between areas of practice such as Sandton and Alexandra, such that access was less limited to wealthy areas. The respondent suggested that the advent of National Health Insurance could support such interventions, as the state would "end up covering the costs of those who are unemployed".
MSM WORK SUPPORTED BY DONOR, TECHNICAL SUPPORT AND UMBRELLA
This section reviews respondents' contributions from donor, technical support and umbrel a organisations, such as SANAC.
SOUTH AFRICAN NATIONAL AIDS COUNCIL (SANAC)
One of the SANAC respondents indicated that the Country Co-ordinating
Mechanism for South Africa had submitted a request for HIV renewal funding from
the Global Fund in May 2013, and this has been approved. The request indicates
that the key foci for GF funding include the fol owing:
Strengthen and expand treatment, care and support that includes the
provision of antiretroviral therapy; a convenient chronic diseases drug delivery
system for patients stabilised on ART, adherence support, monitoring of
outcomes, pharmaco-vigilance, drug resistance monitoring, as wel as
targeted support to Orphans and Vulnerable Children (OVC);
Deliver a package of combination prevention services tailored for neglected
designated key populations, which represent a large proportion of the new
cases in concentrated target areas. Key populations include: Victims of
Gender Based Violence (GBV); Sex workers (SWs); Men who have sex with
men (MSM) and Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender/Transsexual and
Intersexed (LGBTI) persons; Prisoners, Low socioeconomic populations (incl.
farmers and other hard to reach populations), Uncircumcised Men and Youth
(Young Women and Men);
Create an enabling environment to support community systems strengthening
and the implementation of effective programme management and
monitoring (CCM Request for HIV Renewal to the Global Fund, 31 May 2013).
As evidenced, the renewal again includes a focus on MSM, and the respondent indicated that what was significant in this regard is that previous GF funding for MSM had been in the region of approximately $500 000. The respondent indicated that this has now been increased to approximately $11 mil ion (although al ocations have not yet been finalised). The respondent indicated that this represented a "dramatic increase" in funding going to the sector.
The respondent indicated that a core component of the MSM work wil take place through the NACOSA university programme (described above). In addition, there wil be work supporting combination prevention, as wel a work supporting social mobilisation.
The respondent indicated that the chal enges pertaining to the MSM sector and programmatic planning are threefold. On the one hand, the respondent indicated that there is a lack of coordination in the sector. It was reported that SANAC held meetings with GF-funded and PEPFAR-funded partners working with MSM in order to "compare what each are doing, so that we don't have duplication…so we are talking about it and about what makes a good health organisation". The respondent indicated, however, that there was no comprehensive list of MSM service and programme providers, and that a mapping was required in order to develop a better sense of provision in the sector. The respondent indicated that SANAC was working on a mapping process, but that nothing substantial in this regard had been developed to date. Another SANAC respondent indicated that from his perspective, much of the work around MSM was focused in Gauteng (primarily in and around Johannesburg) and in the Western Cape (around Cape Town), and that MSM work in other areas tended to be piecemeal and smal scale, and that there was a significant need for national coordination of MSM efforts.
The respondent indicated that the second chal enge in terms of planning for MSM programming pertained to the view that many MSM organisations providing services (especial y those at a local and community level) were not structural y very strong. As the respondent commented: "the organisations within the [MSM] sector are not necessarily as strong as other organisations [non MSM organisations]. There are some [MSM organisations] that are a lot stronger than others. So, if they received funding…wel , they need to be strong to meet funders' requirements. Whether it is funding from National Government or from external funders". A respondent commented further "some organisations think they are strong, but it is not supported by processes and systems. You need bi-directional accountability. You can say one thing, but you need to deliver. You need to show the outcomes they bring. And for that you need strong organisations and you need organisations to work optimal y as wel ".
The third chal enge related to programmatic planning pertains to a lack of understanding of the size and the concomitant needs of the MSM sector, not least as a result of reluctance by many MSM to identify themselves as such. The respondent commented that "when we put in the GF proposal, we could say that we wil reach a certain amount of people. But we can't get a clear picture of how many need the services. Funders want to know what the gap is. Because we don't have numbers, we don't have the services mapped clearly enough. But it's not exactly clear where there are gaps, and what the extent of the gaps are". The respondent added, "the GF doesn't want to put in more funding unless we can show where the gaps are. We've done some of the work now, but it hasn't been enough. There is a need to establish the size of the need. And how we can respond to that gap".
The respondent indicated that the lack of clear data on MSM also fed into debates about the extent to which the sector needs support. The respondent commented that in "all the talk about key populations, one message that we are getting from organisations like the HSRC, for example, is that it's the general population at risk, and they say we shouldn't focus on key populations. So there is a bit of debate going on here". The respondent also indicated that the lack of data also fed into "battles over resources".
SANAC LGBTI SECTOR
The SANAC LGBTI Sector consists of service providers who have done most of the
groundwork in research, advocacy, training, treatment, support and care for the
LGBTI community. The sector is a coordinating mechanism, linking organisational
initiatives to the work of SANAC, rather than an implementing body.
These service providers are OUT in Pretoria, ICAP-South Africa, Durban Gay and Lesbian Centre, Pietermaritzburg Gay and Lesbian Network, NACOSA, Triangle Project, Anova Health Institute, Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation Cape Town, Gender Dynamix and Intersex South Africa.
The sector has developed an activity plan, available in summary on the SANAC website:
1. Review plans of Government Departments, other identified sectors and
Provincial Government for inclusion and start to build relationships.
2. Audit of current MSM/LGBTI service delivery by Sector members. Costing
thereof, funding sources current and on medium and long term.
3. Development of communication strategy. It wil include external liaison as wel
as consistent internal messaging (for example PEP for sexual prevention). Build relationship with communication with the aim of on-going integration. Dissemination of various fact sheets on lesbian/transgender/intersex vulnerabilities, and patriarchal masculinities.
4. On-going advocacy for the procurement of water based lubrication, PEP and
PrEP, female condoms (also for anal sex). For inclusion in next Government budget and based on partners' gap analysis.
5. Integration of various trainings within the Regional Training Centres. These are
the key population manual, Nurse Initiated Management of Antiretroviral therapy (NIMART) and Post Exposure Prophylaxis (PEP). On-going advocacy within NDOH to achieve this for both health care workers and community
6. Advocate with NDOH for the rol out of the Service Guidelines to Key
Populations. Advocate and institute with NDOH High Transmission Unit for a permanent Key Population Reference Group
7. Develop M&E strategy and plan. To include monitoring within the mainstream
sector from a ward level and up. Also to develop Sector M& E framework to collate client stats on quarterly basis which wil include services used, hate incidents, and experiences with mainstream health
8. Integrate with research Technical Task Team. Priorities are prevalence for
9. Develop comprehensive resource lists and link with current directories such as
10. Explore possibility of "health passport"" which clients can use between
different service providers
RIGHT TO CARE/ GLOBAL FUND PR
Right to Care is the Principal Recipient for the GF, responsible for MSM (selected
under Round 10). This means that RTC has responsibility for al ocating grants in a
number of areas. Thus far, requests for proposals have been made and, at the point
of the interview process, a review of the proposals was about to be undertaken.
This area of work includes that of building staff capacity in government health facilities so as to provide "MSM competent and LGBTI effective HIV-related services – Programme Area 2" (Right to Care Sub-Recipient Selection Process Document, August 2013). The capacity building component wil be covered in the Eastern Cape, Free State, KwaZulu Natal and the Northern Cape. As mentioned earlier in this document, this work has been awarded to Anova.
The second component of work is the "community engagement and peer education for MSM/LGBTI people to facilitate referrals to appropriate health services and conduct community-based adherence and retention in care activities – Programme Area 3". This is also to be based in the above four provinces. No award has been made fol owing the first applications, and this wil be reopened in the future
The core activities wil focus on
• Establish one MSM and LGBTI Centre of Excel ence and strengthen the
capacity of Primary Health Care facilities to provide comprehensive HIV treatment and preventions services for MSM and LGBTI in four provinces.
o Establishment of one Centre of Excel ence site in four previously un-
o Establishment of fifty-nine MSM/LGBTI-competent PHC facilities o Train and mentor Department of Health staff to be able to deliver
MSM/LGBTI competent PHC services
o Deployment of Peer Educators for community mobilisation and public
education activities aimed at both HIV and STI prevention, and linking MSM and LGBTI to care
o MSM and LGBTI-specific information, communication and education
(IEC) materials developed/printed/distributed
o Social networking technologies optimized for improved health
outcomes and service utilization.
• Conduct ethnographic mapping and repeated KAP studies to inform the
need for and content of HIV prevention and treatment services provided to MSM and LGBTI
o Conduct ethnographic mapping o Conduct repeated KAP studies
Over and above this role, Right to Care has a programme in which they work in prisons. They work with 11 facilities/management areas and provide programmes to support HIV counsel ing and testing and TB screening. They also provide condoms and lubricants for prisons nationally.
US CENTRES FOR DISEASE CONTROL AND PREVENTION (CDC)
The CDC is funding several programmes in South Africa, focused on prevention
(behavioural, structural and biomedical). ICAP is their main implementing partner,
and they use a community of practice model described in the previous section.
The CDC has funded the HSRC to develop a package of services for key populations, and this package has now been handed over to ICAP for implementation.
One of the CDC respondents indicated that there had been significant changes in terms of the introduction of MSM services and programming in the last few years. As the respondent commented, "there has been an enormous change in the last three years. When I first arrived here at the beginning of 2010, I was surprised by the lack of work in this area. We brought in someone to do an assessment, and they found that there was very little work being done with HIV positive MSM, and certainly no co-ordination. This has changed through the work done by organizations like Anova's Health4Men project, the work in Cape Town and the LGBTI lobby in SANAC. The real focus now is on co-ordination of the various activities".
FHI360 indicated that they are a public health organisation that operates in sixty
countries worldwide. Their focus pertains to public health, education and research
and development in terms of gender issues. The respondent indicated that they do
not have any service provision programmes in South Africa, but provide technical
support on issues pertaining to gender to the NDOH and SANAC.
HIVOS is a humanist development organisation with four core programmes:
• Sexual development and rights programmes for LGBTI – regional SADC
• Civic voice building programme – multi agency grant initiative - National • Gender programme – Gender Based Violence, HIV - National • Refugee rights programme – National.
HIVOS does not do programming as such, but provides technical capacity building services, grant making, capacity development and network building with many partners based in South Africa and Southern Africa.
SHIPP is a flagship USAID funded project with three core functions:
• Create an enabling environment in which Government is able to deliver
programmes at national, provincial and local levels.
• Develop capacity to deliver combination treatment and prevention
programmes to key populations
• Work with civil society, CBOs and NGOs to scale up combination prevention
SHIPP does not directly provide services, but rather focuses on technical assistance and capacity building.
At a national level, SHIPP works with key departments to support them to develop a coherent response to the national strategy. They report that they provide technical assistance and guidance to the NDoH, Department of Basic Education, Department of Higher Education and Training, Department of Public Service and Administration, Department of Social Development, SANAC and the Office of the Deputy President.
In relation to MSM, SHIPP has been involved in the development of a sexuality education programme for Grades 6 to 10, which wil be rol ed out in schools. They are working with DPSA in terms of the new Civil Service Act, and there are elements around homophobia in the guidelines that SHIPP is reportedly developing.
In relation to key populations, SHIPP focuses on MSM, sex workers, youth and migrant men. SHIPP works in Gauteng, KwaZulu Natal and Mpumalanga, principally at a district level with the District AIDS Councils and Local AIDS Councils. The respondent indicated that in this regard SHIPP works with the District AIDS Councils to consider the operationalization of the Operational Guidelines on Key Populations.
Also at a district level, SHIPP provide smal grants to CBOs to undertake specific community based activities around combination prevention. It was reported that one of the key threads of their work with MSM is working with CBOs to develop programmes around MSM. In Gert Sibande, they are working with an organization to support condom distribution, and this is also going to be rol ed out in the Zululand District.
AMSHER is a regional organisation with a secretariat based in South Africa, but the
respondent reported that the majority of their work takes place outside of the
country. AMSHER broadly supports LGBTI rights through the capacity building of
country-based civil society organisations to engage in advocacy and to provide
services. AMSHER does not engage with the state directly, but works through its
member organisations to advocate for LGBTI rights.
At the regional level, AMSHER engages at the level of the AU and African Commission, and also convenes regional conversations with national institutions in a facilitated manner to discuss national interventions and best practices, including issues pertaining to LGBTI and HIV.
AMSHER has three core programmes, including MSM and health, policy and law and movement building.
The organisation OUT, described above in this document, is a key AMSHER member organisation in South Africa. The respondent referred Singizi to OUT for further information.
The UNAIDS respondent indicated that the organisation does not fund programmes,
but reviews programmatic areas and identifies where the gaps are in this regard.
Their focus is on issues of human rights, advocacy and capacity building.
The respondent indicated that a substantial portion of the recent work has been with IDUs and that UNAIDS has recently released global technical guidelines in this regard.
In terms of MSM, UNAIDS reports that it has been providing technical support to the Department of Health regarding the implementation of the Operational Guidelines for Key Populations. They are also working with the NDoH to set up a Technical Forum for Key Populations, which wil bring together al the major players in this area and co-ordinate activities in relation to key populations. The respondent indicated that they hoped to have the Forum operational by the end of 2013.
The respondent suggested that the Forum would help to avoid overlaps in programming and identify gaps where there is a need to mobilise resources and determine the priorities for programming.
The respondent indicated that while there was a lot of work being conducted on key populations, much of this was concentrated in urban areas in Gauteng, the Western Cape and, to some extent, KwaZulu Natal. The respondent suggested that this needed to be reviewed and opportunities for expansion considered.
4.D: RESEARCH ON MSM AND HIV
RESEARCH ON MSM HIV INCIDENCE AND PREVALENCE
GOVERNMENT DATA ON MSM HIV INCIDENCE AND PREVALENCE
The National Department of Health indicated that government data on HIV
incidence and prevalence among MSM was a chal enge, as the government has
not disaggregated its data down to the level of key populations. The respondent
indicated that the daily registers used in facilities do not take headcounts of
identified key population groups and, as such, no base data is available in this
regard. The respondent commented that as a result, South Africa has not been able
to report to UNGASS in terms of the Declaration of Commitment on HIV/AIDS,
adopted in 2001 by all UN member states.
The respondent indicated that "we have bits and pieces of information here and there. We're working with one consultant who's trying to col ate some of what we already know and using this information he is trying to pul together on what's happening with MSM in South Africa. The minute we have that database, we are able to share with people with where support is needed. But right now, we don't real y have a good picture in South Africa".
The respondent also indicated that they were attempting to establish a Key Populations Forum, and that part of the Forum's role would be to review gaps in research studies on MSM.
All eight of the Provincial Departments of Health respondents interviewed indicated that they did not have any data on MSM incidence and prevalence, and that the only data in place pertained to prevalence amongst antenatal women. A respondent from the Gauteng Department indicated, however, that there was a perception that the "figures are growing". A respondent from the Western Cape Department indicated that one of the issues pertained to obtaining data from clients who did not want to openly identify as MSM for fear of stigma. As the respondent commented, "they don't say they belong to this group of MSM. They just say ‘hi, I have an STI'".
The Northern Cape respondent indicated that they were working with ICAP to assist with the col ection of data on MSM, but that they were "just at the start of this". The respondent indicated that "we have the chal enge of not having clear guidance about how to start. We don't have a database. We need to start reporting on those indicators".
OTHER SOURCES OF MSM HIV INCIDENCE AND PREVALENCE DATA
The three most frequently cited sources of data on MSM HIV incidence and
prevalence in this assessment were:
1. The JEMS study (2009), which was a col aborative study between the
University of the Witwatersrand, the Human Sciences Research Council (HSRC) and the Medical Research Council. The component of the study that focused on prevalence was focused on Johannesburg and Durban, although other components of the study also collected data from Cape Town, Pretoria and Pietermaritzburg.
2. The Soweto Men's Study Survey conducted by UCSF and the PHRU on MSM in
Soweto (also 2009)
3. The DTHF and Johns Hopkins HIV-risk behaviour and prevalence assessment of
MSM from townships in and around Cape Town
A fol ow up study to the JEMS study, the "Marang Men's Project" is an HIV prevalence and behavioural survey among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Cape Town, Durban and Johannesburg, currently being conducted by the Human Sciences Research Council. The Mpumalanga Men's Study, conducted by UCSF and Anova, has presented initial prevalence data in a conference presentation. Additional national surveil ance work in the MSM community is planned for 2014, led by UCSF.
This component of the rapid assessment does not review the findings of these studies, which are being addressed elsewhere.
Apart from these key studies, most organisations interviewed for these purposes were not aware of, or contributing to, further studies on incidence and prevalence (although some other studies are in progress). A SANAC respondent indicated that the key chal enge was that there was no data available at a national level, and that the studies undertaken to date had focused on urban centres and identified "hot spots". As such, he indicated that a "clear picture" of MSM HIV prevalence in the country as a whole was not yet available.
OUT indicated that it was doing some additional work on MSM HIV prevalence in Pretoria. However, the research report is not available yet.
The DTHF indicated that the organisation has completed two MSM HIV prevalence studies in Cape Town, and that one of these was currently being prepared for publication.
Final y, the Anova Health Institute's Health4Men programme has completed an unpublished online survey of self-reported MSM prevalence in South Africa. The findings of the survey, conducted across al nine provinces, suggest that HIV
prevalence amongst MSM varies considerably across provinces, and that prevalence rates – in terms of this study – are highest in the Western Cape and KwaZulu Natal.
OTHER AREAS OF RESEARCH ON MSM
This section provides additional information from respondents on other research
studies being conducted on MSM.
ANOVA HEALTH INSTITUTE
The Anova Health Institute has a diverse MSM focused research agenda, including
work on STI's, clinical outcomes of HIV treatment, mental health issues, intimate
partner violence and prevention technologies. In addition to col aborating with
other South African researchers, Anova works in col aboration with a range of
international institutions, including UCSF, Emory University, UCLA and the University of
Cambridge on these projects.
GAUTENG DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
The Gauteng Department of Health indicated that it was intending to implement a
Behavioural Surveil ance Survey (BSS) that would assess the services being offered by
the Department, and the extent to which these were meeting the needs of MSM, as
wel as assessing the extent to which there was take-up of services. The respondent
indicated that the study was "put on hold", but that it was hoped that there would
be provision for it in the next financial year. It was reported that the Department has
completed a similar BSS for sex workers.
CENTRES FOR DISEASE CONTROL
The CDC indicated that it funds a smal component of what is cal ed "Project
Boithato" (described above). According to the respondent, the research
components of this study, led by the University of California, San Francisco, has
involved the completion of an evidenced-based evaluation .
The project's Website indicates that the Mpowerment Project is part of the Center for Disease Control and Prevention's (CDC) Diffusion of Effective Behavioural Interventions (DEBI) project, and is being replicated by CBOs across the US.
The programme is reportedly currently conducting the Translating Research into Practice (TRIP) study to review how CBOs implement Mpowerment, and Project Boithato is linked to this.
The CDC has also worked with the HSRC and the Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation on NIH funded research into combination therapy, known as the MP3 Study, implemented in Cape Town and Port Elizabeth.
The respondent indicated that in the past, the CDC also worked on a project doing viral sub-typing for HIV positive MSM in Cape Town.
DESMOND TUTU HIV FOUNDATION
The DTHF indicate that the organisation focuses on biomedical prevention trials,
clinical studies and specific molecular studies.
One of these studies in which the DTHF participated was the global iPrEx study, which was a phase I I clinical trial to determine whether tenofovir could safely and effectively prevent HIV acquisition through sex in MSM. The study began in 2007 at four study sites in Peru and Ecuador, fol owing three years of extensive community and stakeholders consultations. In 2008 the study expanded to seven additional sites in Brazil, South Africa, Thailand and the United States. The DTHF was also worked with the International Rectal Microbicide Advocates to help increase awareness of microbicides, and to advocate for more clinical trials. The organization was founded in 2005 to help overcome barriers facing rectal microbicide use amongst MSM.
The ECGLA respondent indicated that they are running a joint project with ICAP,
which involves gathering sex survey data from MSM from Nelson Mandela Bay
townships. The respondent indicated that it was struggling to meet the sample
quotas, however, as "gay men don't want to come forward. It is very closeted".
The respondent indicated that he visits the townships every week and that "people are starting to recognise me and trust me more. Trust is the main problem".
The respondent indicated that once the study was completed, the results would be made available.
The respondent from Lifeline indicated that they are currently conducted a research
project with the Medical Research Council that involved the monitoring of all "high
risk" groups. The project involves tracking return clients and monitoring their progress.
The study is stil in progress.
DURBAN LESBIAN AND GAY COMMUNITY AND HEALTH CENTRE
The Health Centre indicated that they had completed a mini online survey on which
brands of condoms and lubricants were preferred (Choice, Mosaic or Love). The
mini survey found that Love was the most popular brand, preferred because of they
are viewed as "cool" and the "lube smel s better". Mosaic condoms were reportedly
also popular, as some are pink, and are sometimes reportedly referred to as "gay
condoms". The respondent indicated further that the Choice condoms are less
preferred, in part because of the perception that if they are freely and widely
available, they are of a lesser quality. It was also indicated that there is a "class"
issue with regards to Choice condoms, as they are seen to be "for the poor".
Respondents from the fol owing organisations and government departments
participated in the survey:
Health Departments: National Department of Health, Departments of Health: Eastern Cape, Free State, Gauteng, KwaZulu Natal, Limpopo, North West, Western Cape. City of Cape Town.
NGO's, donors and partner organisations: AMSHER, Anova Health Institute, CDC, Diamond Gays & Lesbian Organisation, Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation, Durban Lesbian and Gay Community and Health Centre, ECGLA (The Eastern Cape Gay and Lesbian Association), FHI360, Lifeline, ICAP, HIVOS, Limpopo LGBTi Proudly Out, NACOSA, National LGBTI Health Campaign, OUT LGBTI Wel being, PATH, Right to Care, SANAC, SHIPP, South African Gay & Lesbian Al iance Against Defamation, Free State (SA GLAAD FS), Triangle Project, UNAIDS, WRHI
Invited to participate but not available for interview: Aurum Institute, Free State Rainbow Seeds (LGBTI), Gender Dynamix, Pietermaritzburg Gay and Lesbian Network, SWEAT, TB/HIV Care Association, USAID, UNICEF
We acknowledge the participation of the fol owing respondents, and thank them for sharing their time and views:
Francis Akpan, Ben Brown, Thato Chidarakire, Glenn de Swardt, Pravisha Dhanapalan, Ashraf Grimwood, David Hessey, John Imrie, Karen Jennings, Benjamin Janse Van Rensburg, Dave Johnson, Thapedi Thomas Kganyago, Steve Letsike, Jacques Livingston, Nyameka Mafani, Thandazile Magubane, Pitso Maketha, Iris Mashamba, Eva Marumo, James McIntyre, John Mkandawire, Mabuti Mkangeli, Nonhlanhla Mkhize, Singilizwe Moko, Sindile Molefe, Lee Mondry, Masego Mothladi, Joel Nana, Dawie Nel, Kevin Osborne, Helen Poss, Ian Ralph, Alasdair Reid, Helen Savva, Pheel o Shai, Amit Shrivastav, Nevilene Slingers, Helen Struthers, Carlos Toledo, Kobus van den Heever
4.E: GAPS, OPPORTUNITIES AND PRIORITIES
This section explores respondents' perceptions of the gaps, opportunities and priorities in terms of MSM programming and service provision.
Government respondents from the National DoH, as wel as the Provincial
Departments shared the view that the key gap in terms of the provision of services
for MSM (and other defined key populations) pertained to adequate levels of staff
sensitisation, and concomitant development of clinical knowledge and skil s, to deal
with MSM effectively at government facilities. Operating from the premise of an
integrated approach for al , respondents emphasised the need for the training of
staff at the level of implementation. As one respondent commented, "I think it's [the
gap] training. The implementers don't understand. We need to work together as
government. It's [MSM] something that facilities are not aware of, or people are not
real y open about". Another respondent reinforced this view and commented:
"when we talking about the gap, I think we need to interact and engage. They
[MSM] complain about public clinics not been friendly, and attitudes are wrong.
Why not work on these gaps, make sure they friendly and accessible by al ?".
In considering how such gaps could be addressed, government respondents all shared the view that whilst specialised services provided by non-governmental organisations were able to address some of the needs of MSM, these were viewed as "expensive" and "not sustainable", and that this approach could not be replicated in al areas.
Comments from different respondents in terms of the above were as fol ows:
• "Specialised services (clinics) are expensive. It's better to go the general
clinic, and have staff that are able to cater for al key populations"
• "I believe that we don't need a specialised clinic. I believe let's use what we
have, and make it right so that everybody can access it"
• "We can't have specialised clinics everywhere. Those that can afford to go
and travel and go to specialised, they can go. But not everyone can"
• "Setting up specific services is not the way forward. It's not sustainable and
not cost effective".
A limited number of specialised services can provide training, research and development needs for MSM programming.
Government respondents indicated that a further gap pertained to a sufficient number or scope of initiatives to address stigma. As one respondent commented: "The obstacle is the issue of stigma. In the absence of policy, stigma makes these groups very vulnerable. The attitude of the health workers, some of these groups do not access the services because they fear the issue of stigmatisation. They would rather stay away". Another respondent reiterated this view, and commented: "The issue is attitudes. It's traditional and cultural. It's a cultural shock. We have differing beliefs. There needs to be a process to engage society. It's a process and a commitment to dealing with that. We need to be patient and ensure we are committed as government. We need commitment from leadership and we need to create massive social mobilisation".
One respondent suggested that an opportunity in this regard pertained to more awareness programmes at the level of the community.
Several government respondents indicated that if additional funding was to be made available for service provision in MSM, prevention would be the best area of focus and, in particular, combination prevention. One respondent indicated that there was a glut of funding for treatment, but prevention required more focus. As one respondent commented, "a lot of funders are focusing on the treatment, but we need to do more on prevention. We need to look at this more. You can never ignore this. Through prevention, we wil ultimately reduce the budget for treatment". Another respondent indicated that "there is always less money on prevention. Now more money is spent on ARVs. We need to focus on prevention – that's where the gap is".
Another respondent commented that specific gaps in terms of prevention included the provision of condoms and lubricants that were attractive to MSM. Another respondent indicated that while government had paid attention to the provision of condoms, the need to distribute lubricants for MSM at a national level was a priority.
Another respondent reported further that there was a need to improve "prevention messaging, and adjusting this messaging to fit the MSM population in terms of lingo and community norms". Another respondent supported this view, and reported that a key opportunity would be "communication and prevention messaging for MSM".
One respondent indicated that there was an emerging need to review the opportunities in terms of PrEP and ART as prevention, but that it was "early days" for government to consider these measures, although external agencies could potentially consider this as an opportunity. A National DoH respondent indicated that there was "a lot of talk about PrEP", but that this was not presently a government policy, and would likely not receive attention from the government in the short and medium term.
NON GOVERNMENTAL PERCEPTIONS
This section reviews the perceptions in terms of gaps, opportunities and priorities of
the non-governmental organisations interviewed for these purposes, including
donors and umbrel a organisations. The data has been analysed thematically
according to the emerging responses.
DATA AND RESEARCH
One of the key areas identified as a gap by respondents (and this is referred to
elsewhere in this report) pertains to comprehensive and national information on
MSM. Respondents report that data on MSM, including data on HIV prevalence and
incidence, is sketchy and piecemeal, and has not, to date, been able to provide a
comprehensive picture of MSM in South Africa.
Respondents indicate that a comprehensive body of data is urgently required, both to inform policy, as wel as programming. Responses included:
• "We need to get a clearer sense of what happens here. How deep and how
wide. And on that basis we then need to identify gaps and then review how to fil them" –
• "One of the key things is to get a decent survey up and running. Until we
have a better idea of how many MSM there are, where they are and how receptive they are to the various sorts of programming, we risk wasting a lot of money. For example, much of MSM programming is aimed at black men in townships. There are a significant number of middle class MSM who are not being reached. They are largely ignorant, may not be ‘out', but are relatively easy to reach
• "There is data that exists, but it is not sufficient. We need this data in the form
of operational research to inform policy"
• "The major gap is the lack of evidence, of data, around MSM. There have
been some smaller studies done but no national work"
In addition to data to inform policy and programming, respondents also indicated that there was a need for this data as a baseline against which to monitor prevalence, incidence and provision. As a respondent from FHI360 commented, "there is currently no MSM denominator and then we need to decide how many people we need to reach to make a sizeable impact and then we need to monitor this".
A COORDINATED NATIONAL RESPONSE
The second theme emerging in terms of perceptions of gaps, opportunities and
priorities pertains to perceptions of the need to strengthen a coordinated, national
response to MSM and HIV.
Responses suggest that the two core issues pertaining to a coordinated national response relate to (i) reducing duplication and increasing cooperation and (i ) extending service provision and support services across the country, and beyond the current concentrations in selected urban areas.
A respondent indicated that there was a strong need for partnership, but that the
current situation was such that "partnerships are stil a difficulty that we need to sort
out to avoid overlaps. There are lots of us doing this work, but we not speaking to
each other to maximize the reach".
Another respondent commented, "We need a decent national strategy, and a national presence around MSM, where al of the activities of the various providers can be co-ordinated. We also need a website which talks about al the information and services which are out there. People need to be able to access accurate information, including in the rural areas".
Both respondents from SANAC echoed this view:
"It [MSM programming] needs direction and co-ordination to pul everybody together and to say what is needed. And I think SANAC is the structure that is meant to do that, bring al of that together. There needs to be a delicate working together when you're working with government and civil society. When government do it on their own, it's a one-way relationship and that doesn't work".
"There needs to be coherent partnership. That's a huge gap. Even the smal organisations that exist. There isn't a coherent partnership".
One respondent indicated that one of the chal enges relating to coordination pertained to a lack of funding in the sector, and the concomitant competition for resources. Two respondents suggested that one of the chal enges was that larger organisations tended to receive the lion's share of funding for MSM, and that community programming, which was viewed as critical to succeed in terms of national reach, receives very little of the funding pool in this regard. As one respondent commented, "One needs to increase the funding to community structures and to community practice. This is critical".
While SANAC views this coordination as its responsibility, a respondent from UNAIDS indicated that they were also starting to work with the Provincial AIDS Councils to look at "sustainable ways of taking forward programming around key populations".
CONSIDERING SPECIALISED FACILITIES
As evidenced in the previous section, government respondents support a view that
widespread specialised MSM clinics in the public sector are not a feasible option,
although data from this assessment strongly suggests that the support provided in
the form of specialised MSM centres by external organisations is significantly valued.
Several non-governmental respondents agreed with the view that standalone public sector MSM facilities would not be feasible, but one respondent suggested that increasing the numbers of male wel ness clinics could be viable. The respondent suggested that, for example, several organisations are currently running Medical Male Circumcision (MMC) clinics, and that, in time, the need for these services would be reduced, potential y creating the space for a focus on male wel ness clinics instead. The respondent suggested further that these could also target other key populations, such as sex workers.
As with the Department of Health responses to gaps and priorities, several
respondents indicated that a significant area of priority was reducing stigma, both
at the level of communities at large, as wel as in terms of health care providers.
In terms of health care providers, one respondent indicated that "we need to ensure that service providers are informed about everything and understand, for example, that condoms go with lube. There is a real need for the sensitization of service providers".
A respondent from one of the organisations, which is presently rol ing out sensitisation training for the DoH in selected provinces, indicated that "the majority of participants are receptive to the training, but it's difficult to assess. We have seen real shifts when we do the mentoring, but we have only been able to rol this out to three facilities per province".
Another respondent made a distinction between "sensitisation" to MSM and issues pertaining to stigma and attitudes. The respondent questioned the extent to which stigma and attitudes could be easily changed in a "health system that is under stress". The respondent indicated that changing attitudes was "more complicated" and would take dedication, coordination and time.
Other respondents spoke to the need to reduce stigma at a community level, and the need to support interventions that can assist MSM to disclose their sexuality as MSM, and to seek appropriate treatment, care and support. A respondent indicated that "MSM are a hard to reach population. There are issues around disclosure and the shame of admitting having sex with another man". This respondent gave the example of the "amazing success" with a Project Boithato (described previously)
event in Piet Retief on 8 September 2013, where about 500 community members attended a function in support of men who had come out.
Another respondent indicated that there was a need for national awareness raising campaigns, and another indicated that there was a need to "literally drop information out from planes to get it out there".
The penultimate gap and opportunity emerging from the interviews pertained to
prevention. As with government respondents, several non-government respondents
indicated that prevention (including combination prevention) was a gap in many
areas and that there was a critical need for prevention initiatives to be expanded.
Specifical y, several respondents suggested the need for packages of condoms and lubricants that were branded for MSM. This issue has already been addressed in other sections of this report, but respondents reiterated that MSM tend not to like the Choice condoms and a respondent suggested the need for a "major campaign and widespread distribution of male and female condoms and lube". Another respondent indicated that "without lubricants, condoms wil not be utilised, or the use thereof wil be rendered ineffective. I am of the view that lubricants must be made as readily available as condoms". The successful distribution of branded condoms and lubricant targeting MSM, such as Helath4Men and MOSAIC have instituted, supports these views.
A respondent suggested that there was a need for increased emphasis on considering behaviour change as a component of combination prevention. The respondent indicated, for example, that issues of alcohol and substance abuse appear to be a significant problem amongst MSM, and that paying greater attention to psychosocial issues such as substance abuse is an area that requires greater prioritisation.
Final y, some respondents spoke to opportunities in terms of PrEP. The CDC indicated that while it was not a national programme, there was a strong need for looking at the role of treatment as prevention. Several respondents indicated that PrEP was an area of potential increased focus for MSM, and highlighted an urgent need for pilot projects to better understand how to deliver PrEP.
SPECIFIC MSM GROUPINGS
Some respondents made specific reference to sub-groups of MSM that require attention.
For example, a respondent suggested that there was a need to consider older MSM populations, and why there appeared to be increasing risk amongst this sub-group. It was suggested that there needed to be a consideration on what had changed that had resulted in increased risk amongst older men, and what needed to be put in place to address this.
Further, a private practitioner suggested that whilst much MSM programming focused on younger men, it was his perception that young men of school-going age were not adequately addressed, and that the focus was rather on young men in late adolescence and early adulthood.
The respondent suggested that young men of school going age were an important target in terms of prevention, as schools general y did not prioritise the provision of support for MSM, at a time when young men were likely to experiment sexual y without sufficient knowledge of prevention strategies and with concomitant risks to their health.
There remains a need for specific transgender programming, which acknowledges that the needs of this group may differ from those of MSM.
Final y, male sex workers – as a sub-group of MSM – required further prioritisation.
4.F: SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
This section provides a discussion on the key findings emerging in the course of this assessment, including perceptions of MSM policies and guidelines, a review of overal MSM programming and service provision, and a consideration of data emerging with regards to gaps, opportunities and priorities.
MSM POLICIES AND GUIDELINES
Overal , this assessment has found that respondents are optimistic that the
Operational Guidelines on Key Populations wil provide the basis for improved
programming and an appropriate level of focus on MSM and other key populations
as a priority. The Operational Guidelines are viewed as both relevant and
Some concerns were raised in the course of this assessment about the chal enges that are likely to be faced in the implementation of the guidelines, including the pace of implementation, and the extent to which they wil filter down to the district, sub district and facility levels. Further, there is some concern about the extent to which issues of stigma wil impact on implementation.
Respondents were also asked to indicate if they were aware of any other non-governmental guideline documents available for MSM and HIV. Those identified include guidelines for sensitisation training, as wel as guidelines for healthcare workers. In addition, quality assurance standards for per educators for key populations (i.e. the Quality Assurance Standards Compendium") have been developed, and wil reportedly be available by the end of 2013.
Final y, the Southern Africa HIV Clinicians Society had compiled Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) guidelines for MSM. These are published in the Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine, June 2012, Issue 44, Vol. 13, No. 2, and are available on the Society's Website (www.sahivsoc.org). A SANAC respondent indicated that it was anticipated that PrEP would become a key focus in the new round of GF funding for MSM.
MSM AND HIV SERVICES AND PROGRAMMES
GOVERNMENTAL SERVICE PROVISION
The South African Government's (SAG) approach to MSM service provision supports
integrated service delivery to al , including MSM and other identified key
populations. As such, emphasis is placed on ensuring that healthcare workers and
facilities at the coalface of primary health care are equipped to provide MSM with
appropriate services. This is to be achieved through sensitisation training, as wel as
concomitant clinical training and mentoring to support MSM and other "key
While interviews with several government respondents emphasised the need for increased sensitisation and related training for healthcare workers, the data emerging in this assessment suggests that there is substantial activity in this regard, both in terms of current training, as wel as planned training pertaining to increasing healthcare workers' competence for MSM. Current coverage of this training and mentoring (as reported by respondents in this assessment) is presently being rol ed out by organisations such as ICAP and the Anova Health Institute. Between the two institutions, training is planned in al nine provinces. For ICAP, these include the Eastern Cape, Free State, KwaZulu Natal, Limpopo and Northern Cape. For Anova, these include Western Cape, Limpopo, Mpumalanga, Gauteng, North West, Free State, Eastern Cape, Northern Cape and KwaZulu Natal to facilitate an integrated national coverage addressing HIV among MSM.
NON-GOVERNMENTAL SERVICE PROVISION
The findings of this assessment suggest that service provision tends to be
concentrated in Johannesburg, Pretoria, Cape Town and Durban, with isolated
scatterings of provision in other areas, primarily through Anova's work in other
provinces and the ICAP Mosaic initiative. Further, the findings indicate that the
largest portion of programming is in combination prevention and HCT, with only
seven centres countrywide providing holistic services for MSM, including treatment
(six of these are Health4Men initiatives and the remaining site is the OUT clinic in
The findings indicate that the largest current implementing organisations in terms of non-governmental services for MSM are the Anova Health Institute (through the Health4Men initiative), as wel as the ICAP Mosaic initiative, which employs a "community of practice" approach to combination prevention. This involves bringing identified NGOs in a particular area together, and then al ocating responsibility for various aspects of the programme to these organisations, in accordance with their areas of expertise.
While several smal er provincial y based MSM programmes and services are available (some of which operate under the auspices of Mosaic), the findings suggest that many of these smal er NGOs are under-funded and, as suggested by one respondent, tend not to be sufficiently organisational y robust and coordinated.
Within the above context, however, the assessment notes the impending finalisation of additional funding from the Global Fund for MSM programmes and services that, in addition to further support in terms of DoH sensitisation and clinical training, wil include a focus on prevention services for key populations, including the university programme that wil be supported by NACOSA. Of significance in terms of the GF funding is the finding that that previous GF funding for MSM had been in the region of approximately $500 000. It was indicated that this has now been increased to approximately $11 mil ion (although allocations have not yet been finalised).
A final component of provision for services for MSM pertains to the private sector. Private sector respondents indicated that services for MSM are available at select private practices for those who have access to medical aid or other personal funding for private health care. The respondents suggest, however, that this provision is piecemeal and based on "word of mouth" and that the sector would benefit from greater levels of coordination and/or communities of practice around MSM. Further, there is a perception that current private provision for MSM is possibly on the wane as a result of high levels of practitioner emigration, and changes in the accessibility of ARVs in public facilities.
RESEARCH ON MSM AND HIV
RESEARCH ON MSM HIV INCIDENCE AND PREVALENCE
The findings of this assessment indicate that data on MSM in terms of HIV prevalence
and incidence is piecemeal and limited, and that no comprehensive national
picture in this regard exists at present.
Government respondents proposed that public facilities do not col ect data that allows disaggregation by key populations, although it is understood that there are discussions underway to review this.
Outside of government data, the key studies on incidence and prevalence cited are the JEMS study, the Soweto Men's Study and the DTHF and Johns Hopkins behavioural and prevalence assessment based on Cape Town data
Additional research results from Tshwane and Mpumalanga wil be available in the coming months and the HSRC national data , and MSM study, wil add to the available evidence. Further surveil ance work wil be undertaken in 2014.
OTHER AREAS OF RESEARCH ON MSM
A smal number of respondents indicated that they were involved in the completion
of additional studies in MSM. These included the MPowerment study (Project
Boithato), a collaboration between UCSF and Anova. The CDC also worked on a
project doing viral sub-typing for HIV positive MSM in Cape Town.
The Anova Health Institute has a diverse MSM focused research agenda, including work on STI's, clinical outcomes of HIV treatment, mental health issues, and intimate partner violence and prevention technologies. In addition to col aborating with other South African researchers, Anova works in collaboration with a range of international institutions, including UCSF, Emory University, UCLA and University of Cambridge on these projects.
The Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation is working with the HSRC and Johns Hopkins on NIH and CDC funded research into combination therapy, known as the MP3 Study, implemented in Cape Town and Port Elizabeth. DTHF is also working on rectal microbicide research.
Further, the ECGLA are running a joint project with ICAP, which involves gathering sex survey data from MSM from Nelson Mandela Bay, and Lifeline Durban are currently conducted a research project with the Medical Research Council that involved the monitoring of al "high risk" groups. The project involves tracking return clients and monitoring their progress. The Durban Lesbian and Gay Community Health Centre also reportedly completed an online survey on condom preference.
GAPS, OPPORTUNITIES AND PRIORITIES
Government respondents from the National DoH, as wel as the Provincial
Departments shared the view that the key gap in terms of the provision of services
for MSM (and other defined key populations) pertained to adequate levels of staff
sensitisation, and concomitant development of clinical knowledge and skil s, to deal
with MSM effectively at government facilities.
Government respondents indicated that a further gap pertained to a sufficient number or scale of initiatives to address stigma. One respondent suggested that an opportunity in this regard pertained to more awareness programmes at the level of the community.
Several government respondents indicated that if additional funding was to be made available for service provision in MSM, prevention would be the best area of focus and, in particular, combination prevention. Specific gaps in terms of prevention included the provision of condoms and lubricants that were attractive to MSM; the inclusion of lubricant in condom packages for MSM; the improvement of prevention messaging to MSM and PrEP (although noting that this was not a government priority, this represented an opportunity for external agencies).
NON GOVERNMENTAL PERCEPTIONS
Key gaps, opportunities and priorities for non-governmental respondents included:
DATA AND RESEARCH
One of the key areas identified as a gap by respondents pertains to comprehensive
and national information on MSM. Respondents report that data on MSM, including
data on HIV prevalence and incidence, is sketchy and piecemeal, and has not, to
date, been able to provide a comprehensive picture of MSM in South Africa.
In addition to data to inform policy and programming, respondents also indicated that there was a need for this data as a baseline against which to monitor prevalence, incidence and service provision.
A COORDINATED NATIONAL RESPONSE
The second theme emerging in terms of perceptions of gaps, opportunities and
priorities pertains to perceptions of the need to strengthen a coordinated, national
response to MSM and HIV.
Responses suggest that the two core issues pertaining to a coordinated national response pertain to (i) reducing duplication and increasing cooperation and (i ) extending service provision and support services across the country, and beyond the current concentrations in selected urban areas.
CONSIDERING SPECIALISED FACILITIES
Government respondents support a view that widespread specialised MSM clinics in
the public sector are not a feasible option, although data from this assessment
strongly suggests that the support provided in the form of specialised MSM centres
by external organisations is significantly valued. The current focus on training for
"clinical competency" in MSM care across health services is an appropriate
As with the Department of Health's responses to gaps and priorities, several
respondents indicated that a significant area of priority was reducing stigma, both
at the level of communities at large, as wel as among health care providers.
As with government respondents, several non-government respondents indicated
that prevention (and notably combination prevention) was a gap in many areas
and that there was a critical need for prevention initiatives to be expanded.
Specifical y, several respondents suggested the need for packages of condoms and lubricants that were branded for MSM. Others suggested the need for increased emphasis on considering behaviour change as a component of combination prevention, including issues pertaining to alcohol and substance abuse.
Final y, some respondents spoke to opportunities in terms of PrEP. There is also a definite need to look at optimizing the role of treatment as prevention.
SPECIFIC MSM GROUPINGS
Final y, some respondents made specific reference to sub-groups of MSM that
require attention. These include both older and young MSM, male sex workers and
The needs of MSM accessing private health care, both in ensuring appropriate care and in accessing health information should also be considered.
MSM PROGRAMMING IN SOUTH AFRICA PRIORITY ACTIONS
SUMMARY PRIORITY RECOMMENDATIONS
There have been significant advances in policy development and implementation
for MSM and other key populations in South Africa. Fol owing on from the current
National Strategic Plan (NSP), which acknowledges MSM as a key population,
several current initiatives are advancing MSM work.
• Although not yet ful y released, there is widespread support for the Key
Populations Operational Guidelines for the health sector. Once final y signed off and published, the next chal enge wil be to disseminate and promote the final guidlines to the provinces.
• Few provinces have yet developed their own guidelines or polices for MSM.
Although national guidelines are set, provinces have a great deal of autonomy in implementing health services, and in developing provincial policies. Support for this process fits wel in the mandate of SANAC, working with provincial AIDS Councils, and with the SANAC LGBTI sector. The gaps in provincial policies provide an opportunity to support and work with SANAC and others to ensure provincial policy development and implementation. Additional support to the existing technical partners and the sector organisations could help accelerate the provincial policy processes, and contribute the necessary technical expertise.
• The draft Department of Health HIV prevention policy is a wider scope
document, but it wil also provide a framework to extend MSM prevention activities within the health sector. Similar issues in dissemination and provincial implementation apply.
• New thinking and consultation on the government's Condom Policy could
provide an opportunity to reconsider branding and distribution of condoms and lubricant targeted at MSM communities.
• The SANAC LGBTI sector has put forward priorities for action that are well
aligned to the stakeholder suggestions and recommendations of this report. The coordination role of the LGBTI sector has some funding and support from SANAC, and can be further extended and harnessed in future. Although it is
not a legal entity or an implementing organisation, the LGBTI Sector can be influential in fostering col aborative work.
• There is an urgent need to obtain better estimates of MSM population size
and mapping of communities, MSM resources and outreach target areas, is needed in order to optimize interventions. The recent sex worker population size estimate exercise has more clearly defined the scale of need and enabled decisions on where to target services. In order to move from policy guidance to implementation, a similar level of knowledge is required for MSM. The current government identified High Transmission Areas, in which other key populations are targeted, may or may not be the highest areas of need for MSM. There is some research work planned for 2014 on population size estimation, and provision for mapping of MSM communities in four provinces in the anticipated Global Fund MSM support. Additional resources for more community mapping activities in both rural and urban areas in al provinces in the next year could greatly assist in this process, and in linking to the care and treatment services that are being established.
CARE & TREATMENT
Important advances have been made in extending competency in MSM care
within the government health services, although the need for further extension is
great. Health service stigma remains a major barrier to access to clinical services for
both prevention and care and treatment for MSM. The balance between integrated
services for MSM and other key populations at facility level and the continued need
for MSM-appropriate and targeted information and outreach services needs to be
acknowledged and implemented.
Development of health service capacity must be accompanied by targeted
information and outreach activities to increase the number of MSM who know their
HIV status, have access to prevention technologies and access treatment and care
at an appropriate time.
• There is consensus that Primary Heath Care facilities should be able to provide
sensitive and competent services to MSM across the country. The Key Populations guidance recognises that staff in these facilities need to understand issues and be able to deliver service for multiple groups, and that training can be designed to improve skil s for several key populations.
• Current PEPFAR support, through the USAID-supported Anova Health4Men
programme, and the CDC-supported ICAP mosaic programme has enabled
excellent progress in extending MSM competency training to facility level. Together with the work in the anticipated Global Fund award, and the pilot phase of the integrated Key Populations training, these programmes should reach over 200 facilities by the end of 2014. Although this is a limited scale in national terms, it appears to be the maximum extension rate with available funding. More information on population mapping could help to determine the optimal choice of facilities, and assist in measuring access. Additional resources would be best used to extend current approaches, in collaboration with provincial health departments.
• While dedicated MSM services wil not be required in al facilities or towns,
there is a need to foster expertise in MSM care and investigate innovative models of care and delivery of biomedical prevention modalities. These experienced staff wil also be the core trainers and mentors to ensure wider rol out of MSM competency to primary care level, and to build long term sustainability. Consideration should be given to expanding Anova's current Centres of Excellence approach, which is established in Cape Town and Johannesburg, to other major provincial centres.
• There is also a need to consider and develop pre-service training approaches
for health workers (both doctors and nurses). Activities to date have been limited to some academic centres, but could be expanded through further discussion with training institutions and dissemination of resource materials.
• MSM who access care in the private health sector remain a hard to reach
and underserved group, but may constitute a relatively large number of men, who also experience stigma, discrimination and lack of services. South Africa has a dual health system with a large private health sector, funded by individual and medical insurance schemes and a state funded health sector. While 70% of South Africans rely on state services for al health care, around 30% use private medical practitioners and services. Plans for a National Health Insurance scheme may increase the proportion using private sector providers in the future, but also more closely link these to the state sector facilities. More than 60% of doctors in South Africa work in the private sector. While efforts are being made within the state sector, there has been no parallel process to serve the needs of many MSM who do not use State facilities, especial y employed MSM or those covered by health insurance who utilise general practitioners or private sector facilities. There is a need to educate providers and to reach these men. Support for formative work in this regard is under consideration by a private foundation donor, but additional support wil be required to implement such programming at scale.
• There has been a lack of mainstream and explicit HIV prevention campaigns
targeting MSM risk behaviours and of MSM targeted awareness campaigns
about HIV testing, STI treatment and HIV treatment for middle and higher-level socio economic groups. Several respondents in this assessment identified the lack of campaigns targeted outside of state facilities and township clinics, and the dearth of education and awareness in providers of healthcare outside of the state health systems, which results in sub-standard care for MSM within the private sector.
• Alternative treatment delivery strategies for the MSM community should be
considered in areas of high MSM populations. Approaches for community delivery of ART are gaining support in many areas, and "shop front" or community centre located services could provide prevention, testing and treatment while taking some of the chronic HIV case load out of busy health centres.
There is little information on the proportion of South African MSM who are receiving
antiretroviral treatment, or on the "cascade" of care.
• More work is needed to evaluate and optimize treatment approaches and
strategies. This includes antiretroviral treatment, sexual y transmitted infections in MSM and mental health assessment and care.
• MSM-targeted treatment information and retention and adherence support
strategies, which take into account the situations of diverse MSM, have not been implemented in South Africa. Support to develop these, including linking to and adapting international web based and mobile phone approaches (similar to those developed by the Terence Higgins Trust) could be a very important area of support.
MSM is a broad behavioural category, including men who identify as heterosexual,
homosexual, and bisexual as wel as biological y male transgender or gender queer
individuals. Additionally, MSM may be at additional risk for HIV through sex work or
drug use, and these sub groups may require additional service support.
• Services for transgender people may need additional skil s and more intensive
sensitisation of health workers. GenderDynamix has led the way in producing some guidance on this, which has now also been reprinted for wider distribution by Anova. There needs to be more discussion and planning on
how and where more specialised transgender expertise can be developed and appropriate services provided.
• MSM sex workers may require additional care, STI screening and treatment.
Integrated key populations training can help to build competency for this, but additional service and targeted outreach may be important for this group. The National Sex Worker Programme in development is currently more focused on female sex workers, although it includes male sex work in its scope. Additional targeted MSM sex worker support could contribute to this community.
MSM in South Africa are an under-served group in terms of HIV prevention. In
addition to comprising multiple gender identities and sexual orientations, MSM in
South Africa are also differentiated along racial, age, and socio-economic lines.
There has been a lack of MSM targeted prevention or treatment information
campaigns across al of these groups. Mainstream prevention messaging does not
explicitly address high-risk activities for MSM, in particular the risks of unprotected
Respondents to this assessment acknowledged the considerably increased levels of funding and support which have enabled MSM treatment service delivery to be extended, but rank additional support for HIV prevention for MSM as a major priority need.
Strategic investment in MSM targeted prevention and treatment information would complement the existing support for treatment efforts and could be the most important new contribution to the field.
Government funded activities, both by the South African government structures and international donors, are often subject to more political constraints in terms of MSM-themed and, in particular, explicit messaging which directly addresses the drivers of MSM risk. Foundation funding may al ow more effective innovative approaches.
PREVENTION MESSAGING AND COMMUNICATION
• There is a need for expanded HIV prevention messaging for MSM, which can
be widely distributed and accessed by MSM across the country. A coordinated messaging campaign should also address nuanced messaging for diverse groups of men, potential y under an overarching brand umbrel a that can maximise reach.
• The use of social media and electronic communication, in particular mobile
phone communication, allows for both information dissemination and interactive content in private. Existing project mobile phone projects wil be further extended by activities in the new Global Fund supported grant, and the extensive programme infrastructure which be established wil also al ow for addition of linked sites with potential to reach local groups or targeted age group or sexual practice groupings.
• There is a need for exploration of communication strategies targeted at
young MSM, which can combine information and prevention access with approaches to address structural issues, "coming out" and build self-esteem. While similar approaches are being implemented targeting young women, using social y aspirational content to encourage access and direction to HIV material (such as HIVSA's Hi4LIFE and Choma projects), this has not been attempted for young MSM.
• There is a need to consider some scale of explicit messaging for high risk
sexual activity groups, including MSM who use drugs and those involved in "hard core" sexual practices, who may be hard to reach with more mainline messaging. Recognising the potential high transmission impact of these groups, International examples of these programmes have used sign-up or membership approaches to control access to the preventions strategies.
CONDOMS AND LUBRICANT
• While supply of standard Government issue condoms has been increased in
recent years, there has been very little supply of lubricant for MSM other than through NGO's. There are also widespread negative perceptions about the "Choice" brand of condoms supplied by the Department of Health. There is an opportunity to focus an MSM-targeted brand of condom and lubricant to be supplied for MSM, and consideration should be given to building on one of the successful NGO brands to include this in government or PEPFAR funded supply, for use in MSM programming to increase condom use.
• With an increased focus in "Treatment as Prevention" more intensive efforts
must be made to seek, find and retain MSM in care and treatment. Outreach testing needs to be increased, and capacity building and support of MSM civil society organizations, in addition to building facility capacity, could
achieve this. More discussion is needed on suggestions to allow treatment at an earlier stage for MSM (higher CD4 count or approaching a test and treat strategy), acknowledging the higher risks of transmission in this group.
• More implementation is needed for "Combination Prevention" approaches,
including understanding and delivering multiple prevention strategies or providing a menu of prevention options that are easily accessible for MSM. With treatment being the major focus in overburdened health services, there should be urgent consideration of ways to pilot combination prevention provision outside of health services, while linking closely to care.
• The NSP envisages pilot projects of PrEP and other new biomedical
approaches as these become proven and available. Although PrEP guidelines have been issued by the SA HIV Clinician's Society, there has been minimal progress in implementing the strategy. Consideration should be given to PrEP demonstration sites in the next year to understand whether this could be a feasible, acceptable and effective prevention strategy.
CIVIL SOCIETY AND STRUCTURAL INTERVENTIONS
There is recognition of the need to reach diverse groups of MSM in communities and
to provide support on multiple levels. Structural interventions to raise the social
capital of MSM and address stigma remain crucial to the success of HIV prevention
or treatment programming.
• The network of MSM civil society organisations remains thinly dispersed across
the country and these are not large or wel organised enough in many areas to make a major impact. The work of the SANAC LGBTI sector in bringing together these groups and encouraging new groups is crucial to expanding civil society support, and should be extended. Consideration must be given to how these groups can also focus on HIV prevention and care access issues without losing the essential human rights advocacy work. Capacity building of civil society organisations to enable good governance, compliance with grant awards and successful administration wil be crucial to any expansion. Linking smal er civil society groups to larger scale prevention programmes for supply of information materials, condoms and lubricant and communication systems would help to build capacity and avoid the need for duplication.
Limited examples of structural community base programmes are showing promising results (for example, Anova's Ukwazana and UCSF'sProject Boithato). Funding for extension of such approaches may be is difficult through the existing funding channels but new options should be explored.
MOVING FORWARD WITH PRIORITY ACTIONS
The results of this assessment provide encouraging evidence of an up scaling of both
interest and activity in HIV programming for MSM. A supportive policy environment,
unique in Africa, exists with commitment by SANAC and the South African
government. An unprecedented level of international donor support, led by PEPFAR
and the Global Fund is increasing access to HIV testing care and treatment, and
current and planned projects are starting to extend this outside of the main urban
centres and into more rural parts of all provinces.
There is widespread support for an approach that integrates MSM competent services into primary health care, with the caveat that there is little hard evidence or experience yet that this wil be ful y successful in addressing the barriers to health care for MSM. While further support for care and treatment could increase the pace of capacity development and further expand access, this would require additional resources, staffing and technical assistance, which may best be provided through existing donors and local agencies than by establishing new approaches.
There is however a need to address gaps in the care and treatment programming,
and some possible innovations. Three areas of need are priorities: addressing MSM
competency for health workers in the private sector; addressing clinical care skil s for
transgender people and investigating alternative community based delivery
approaches for chronic HIV treatment for MSM in areas of high MSM prevalence, to
relieve some of the burden on health facilities whilst ensuring prevention and MSM
HIV prevention is identified as a priority for further support. There are chal enges in
aligning and ensuring a dual strategy for prevention and care, promoting an
integrated care system, whilst acknowledging and addressing al of the multiple
issues which make MSM a key population at high risk for HIV. Prevention
interventions, across the spectrum from information and behaviour change
interventions to the provision of biomedical strategies, must target diverse groups of
men in ways that are appropriate for them.
Whilst government and bilateral donor funds can support health system interventions very effectively, prevention interventions sometimes need to be more explicit and more innovative than is possible with state funding. Private foundation support is well suited to be able to target hard to reach populations and to move rapidly and effectively to innovate in this field, for example with targeted media campaigns.
Support to civil society organisations and structural interventions are important in reaching MSM and linking them to HIV prevention and care. Additional support for these approaches wil be needed to optimize the reach of MSM programming.
The progress to date in building MSM services in South Africa provides a unique foundation to redouble efforts now, to ensure that the progress to an AIDS-free generation includes MSM.
Aguinaldo, J. P., T. Myers, et al. (2009). "Accounts of HIV Seroconversion Among
Substance-Using Gay and Bisexual Men." Qualitative Health Research 19(10):
Alvy, L. M., D. J. McKirnan, et al. (2010). "Depression is Associated with Sexual Risk
Among Men Who Have Sex with Men, but is Mediated by Cognitive Escape
and Self-Efficacy." AIDS and Behavior 15(6): 1171-1179.
Anova Health Institute (2012). Health4Men online survey of sexual preferences and
practices, HIV risk, and medical care for MSM in South Africa. Cape Town,
Anova Health Institute.
Arnold, M. P., H. Struthers, et al. (2013). "Contextual correlates of per partner
unprotected anal intercourse rates among MSM in Soweto, South Africa."
AIDS and Behavior 17 Suppl 1: S4-11.
Arnott, J. and A. L. Crago (2009). Rights not rescue: a report on female, male, and
trans sex workers' human rights in Botswana, Namibia, South Africa.
Johannesburg, Open Society Institute.
Baggaley, R., R. White, et al. (2010). "HIV transmission risk through anal intercourse,
systematic review, meta-analysis and implications for HIV prevention."
International Journal of Epidemiology 39(4): 1048-1063.
Balaji, A. B., K. E. Bowles, et al. (2013). "High HIV incidence and prevalence and
associated factors among young MSM, 2008." AIDS 27(2): 269-278.
Baral, S., E. Burrel , et al. (2011). "HIV Risk and Associations of HIV Infection among
men who have sex with men in Peri-Urban Cape Town, South Africa." BMC
Public Health 11(1): 766.
Baral, S., D. Kizub, et al. (2010). "Male sex workers in Moscow, Russia: a pilot study of
demographics, substance use patterns, and prevalence of HIV-1 and sexual y
transmitted infections." AIDS Care 22(1): 112-118.
Baral, S., G. Trapence, et al. (2009). "HIV prevalence, risks for HIV infection, and
human rights among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Malawi, Namibia,
and Botswana." PLoS ONE 4(3): e4997.
Beck, J., G. M. Santos, et al. (2012). Young men who have sex with men: health,
access, and HIV, MSM Global Forum.
Bekker, L. G., K. Rebe, et al. (2012). "Southern African guidelines for the safe use of
pre-exposure prophylaxis in men who have sex with men who are at risk for
HIV infection." South African Journal of HIV Medicine 13(2): 40-55.
Benotsch, E. G., S. Kalichman, et al. (1999). "Sexual compulsivity and substance use in
HIV-seropositive men who have sex with men: prevalence and predictors of
high-risk behaviours." Addictive Behaviours 24(6): 857-868.
Bernstein, K. T., J. L. Marcus, et al. (2010). "Rectal gonorrhea and Chlamydia
reinfection is associated with increased risk of HIV seroconversion." Journal of
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 53: 537 - 543.
Boyce, P., M. Huang Soo Lee, et al. (2007). "Putting sexuality (back) into HIV/AIDS:
issues, theory and practice." Global Public Health 2(1): 1-34.
Boyce, P. and G. Isaacs (2012). An exploratory study of the social contexts, practices
and risks of men who sel sex in southern and eastern Africa. Cape Town,
African Sex Worker Alliance.
Brink, J. G. (2012). An investigation of risky sexual behaviours, basic HIV knowledge
and intention to use condoms among a sample of men who have sex with
men in a student community MA, University of Stel enbosch.
Buchacz, K., P. Patel, et al. (2004). "Syphilis increases HIV viral load and decreases
CD4 cel counts in HIV-infected patients with new syphilis infections." AIDS 18:
Carey, J. W., R. Mejia, et al. (2009). "Drug use, high-risk sex behaviors, and increased
risk for recent HIV infection among men who have sex with men in Chicago
and Los Angeles." AIDS and Behavior 13(6): 1084-1096.
Centers for Disease Control (2007). HIV/AIDS Surveil ance Report. Atlanta, US
Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and
Choi, K. H., D. Operario, et al. (2005). "Substance use, substance choice, and
unprotected anal intercourse among young Asian American and Pacific
Islander men who have sex with men." AIDS Education and Prevention 17(5):
Cloete, A., L. C. Simbayi, et al. (2008). "Stigma and discrimination experiences of HIV-
positive men who have sex with men in Cape Town, South Africa." AIDS Care
Coates, T. J., L. Richter, et al. (2008). "Behavioural strategies to reduce HIV
transmission: How to make them work better." The Lancet 372(9639): 36-51.
Cohen, M. S., Y. Q. Chen, et al. (2011). "Prevention of HIV-1 Infection with Early
Antiretroviral Therapy." New England Journal of Medicine 365(6): 493-505.
Cowan, S. A., J. Gerstoft, et al. (2012). "Stable incidence of HIV diagnoses among
Danish MSM despite increased engagement in unsafe sex." J Acquir Immune
Defic Syndr 61(1): 106-111.
Das, M., P. L. Chu, et al. (2010). "Decreases in community viral load are
accompanied by reductions in new HIV infections in San Francisco." PloS One
Department Of Correctional Services. (2011). Gender Incarceration Levels [Online].
Pretoria. [Accessed 12 November 2013].
De Swardt, G. and K. Rebe (2010). From top to bottom: a sex-positive approach for
men who have sex with men - a manual for healthcare providers.
Johannesburg, ANOVA Health Institute.
De Swardt, G. and K. Rebe (2010). MSM In Your Pocket. A. H. Institute. Johannesburg,
Anova Health Institute.
Dunkle, K. L., R. K. Jewkes, et al. (2013). "Prevalence of consensual male-male sex
and sexual violence, and associations with HIV in South Africa: a population-
based cross-sectional study." PloS Medicine 10(6): e1001472.
Dunkle, K. L., R. Stephenson, et al. (2008). "New heterosexually transmitted HIV
infections in married or cohabiting couples in urban Zambia and Rwanda: an
analysis of survey and clinical data." The Lancet 371(9631): 2183-2191.
Freeman, E. E., H. A. Weiss, et al. (2006). "Herpes simplex virus 2 infection increases HIV
acquisition in men and women: systematic review and meta-analysis of
longitudinal studies." AIDS 20: 73.
Gear, S. (2005). Rules of engagement: Structuring sex and damage in men's prisons
and beyond. Culture , Health & Sexuality, 7, 195-208.
Geibel, S., S. Luchters, et al. (2008). "Factors Associated With Self-Reported
Unprotected Anal Sex Among Male Sex Workers in Mombasa, Kenya."
Sexual y Transmitted Diseases 35(8): 746-752.
Geng, E. H., D. Nash, et al. (2010). "Retention in care among HIV-infected patients in
resource-limited settings: emerging insights and new directions." Current
HIV/AIDS Reports 7(4): 234-244.
Goyer, K. C. (2003). Monograph 79: HIV/AIDS in prisons, problems, policies, and
potential [Online]. Cape Town: Institute for Security Studies. [Accessed 12
Grant, R., J. R. Lama, et al. (2010). "Preexposure Chemoprophylaxis for HIV Prevention
in Men Who Have Sex With Men." New England Journal of Medicine 363(27):
Hallett, L. W. (2003). The experience of the male sex-worker: a phenomenological
investigation. MA Counsel ing Psychology, University of Zululand.
Hazra, H. (2006). "Enhancing sensuality for safer sex among men in India." IDS Bulletin
5(October 2006): 98 - 104.
Health4Men (2012). Tikking the boxes: drug use and sexual behaviour among MSM in
Cape Town. Cape Town, Health4Men.
Heath, J., A. Lanoye, et al. (2012). "The role of alcohol and substance use in risky
sexual behavior among older men who have sex with men: a review and
critique of the current literature." AIDS and Behavior 16(3): 578-589.
Henderson, N. and T. Shefer (2008). "Practices of power and abuse in gay male
relationships: An exploratory case study of a young, isiXhosa speaking man in
the Western Cape, South Africa." South African Journal of Psychology 38(1): 1-
Hinkin, C. H., H. D. J., et al. (2004). "Medication adherence in HIV-infected adults:
effect of patient age, cognitive status, and substance abuse." AIDS 18(Suppl
ICF International (2012). Quality assurance standards for peer education and
outreach programmes for high-risk vulnerable populations in South Africa (draft). Atlanta, ICF International.
Imrie, J., G. Hoddinott, et al. (2013). "Why MSM in rural South African communities
should be an HIV prevention research priority." AIDS and Behavior 17 Suppl 1:
Jali, T. (2006). Commission of inquiry into al eged incidents of corruption,
maladministration, violence or intimidation into the Department of Correctional Services appointed by order of the President of the Republic of South Africa in terms of Proclamation No. 135 of 2001, as amended. In: PRESIDENCY, D. O. T. (ed.). Pretoria: Jali Commission.
Jobson, G. (2012). MSM and recreational drug use. AIDS Priorities. Cape Town.
Jobson, G. (2013). Naked truths: Health4Men's 2012 online survey of MSM sexual
behaviour, HIV risk, and prevention. South African AIDS Conference. Durban
Jobson, G., G. De Swardt, et al. (2011). Client dynamics in a sexual health clinic for
men who have sex with men. South African AIDS Conference. Durban.
Jobson, G., G. de Swardt, et al. (2013). "HIV Risk and Prevention Among Men Who
Have Sex with Men (MSM) in Peri-Urban Townships in Cape Town, South
Africa." AIDS and Behavior 17(1): 12-22.
Jong, E., J. W. Mulder, et al. (2011). "Screening for Anal Dysplasia in HIV-Infected Men
Who Have Sex with Men by Anal Cytology, Human Papil omavirus Testing and
Anoscopy." World Journal of AIDS 1: 37-42.
Knox, J., H. Yi, et al. (2010). "The fal acy of intimacy: sexual risk behaviour and beliefs
about trust and condom use among men who have sex with men in South
Africa." Psychology, health & medicine 15(6): 660-671.
Koblin, B. A., L. Torian, et al. (2006). "Violence and HIV-related risk among young men
who have sex with men." AIDS Care 18(8): 961-967.
Lambert, H. and K. Wood (2005). "A comparative analysis of communication about
sex, health and sexual health in India and South Africa: Implications for HIV
prevention." Culture, Health & Sexuality 7(6): 527-541.
Lane, T. (2013). The Mpumalanga men's study. South African AIDS Conference.
Lane, T., T. Mogale, et al. (2008). ""They see you as a different thing": the experiences
of men who have sex with men with healthcare workers in South African
township communities." Sexual y Transmitted Infections 84: 430-433.
Lane, T., H. F. Raymond, et al. (2009). Lower risk of HIV infection among circumcised
MSM: Results from the Soweto Men's Study. 5th International Aids Society
Conference on HIV Pathogenesis, Treatment and Prevention, Cape Town.
Lane, T., H. F. Raymond, et al. (2011). "High HIV Prevalence Among Men Who have
Sex with Men in Soweto, South Africa: Results from the Soweto Men's Study."
AIDS and Behavior 15(3): 626-634.
Lane, T., S. B. Shade, et al. (2008). "Alcohol and Sexual Risk Behavior Among Men
Who Have Sex with Men in South African Township Communities." AIDS and
Behavior 12(S1): 78-85.
Leaver, C. A., G. Bargh, et al. (2007). "The effects of housing status on health-related
outcomes in people living with HIV: a systematic review of the literature." AIDS
and Behavior 11(6 Suppl): 85-100.
Lewis, D. A., C. Sriruttan, et al. (2013). "Phenotypic and genetic characterization of
the first two cases of extended-spectrum-cephalosporin-resistant Neisseria gonorrhoeae infection in South Africa and association with cefixime
treatment failure." Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy
Lyons, A., M. Pitts, et al. (2010). "Ageing with HIV: health and psychosocial wel -being
of older gay men." AIDS Care 22(10): 1236-1244.
Mimiaga, M. J., S. L. Reisner, et al. (2009). "Street workers and internet escorts:
contextual and psychosocial factors surrounding HIV risk behavior among men who engage in sex work with other men." Journal of urban health :
bul etin of the New York Academy of Medicine 86(1): 54-66.
Mitchel , S. (2013). MSM and substance use: implications for sexual health. AIDS
Priorities. Nelspruit, Anova Health Institute.
Mul er, A. (2013). Sexual and Reproductive Health for Transgender and Gender Non-
Conforming People: Guidelines for Health Care Workers in Primary Care.
Cape Town, Gender Dynamix.
Muraguri, N., M. Temmerman, et al. (2012). "A decade of research involving men
who have sex with men in sub-Saharan Africa: current knowledge and future
directions." SAHARA 9(3): 137-147.
Murray, J. and B. Adam (2001). "Aging, sexuality, and HIV issues among older gay
men." Canadian Journal of Human Sexuality 10(3/4): 75 - 90.
Mustanski, B., M. E. Newcomb, et al. (2011). "Relationship characteristics and sexual
risk-taking in young men who have sex with men." Health Psychology 30(5):
Myers, T., J. P. Aguinaldo, et al. (2004). "How Drug using men who have sex with men
account for substance use during Sexual Behaviours: Questioning assumptions
of Hiv Prevention and Research." Addiction Research & Theory 12(3): 213-229.
National Department of Health (2012). Operational guidelines for HIV, STIs and TB
programmes for key populations in South Africa. Final Draft. N. D. o. Health.
National Department of Health (2013). HIV prevention strategy for the health sector
(draft). N. D. o. Health. Pretoria.
Needle, R., K. Kroeger, et al. (2008). "Sex, drugs, and HIV: Rapid assessment of HIV risk
behaviors among street-based drug using sex workers in Durban, South
Africa." Social Science & Medicine 67(9): 1447-1455.
Nel, J. A., H. Yi, et al. (2013). "HIV-untested men who have sex with men in South
Africa: the perception of not being at risk and fear of being tested." AIDS and
Behavior 17 Suppl 1: S51-59.
Newcomb, M. E. (2013). "Moderating effect of age on the association between
alcohol use and sexual risk in MSM: evidence for elevated risk among younger
MSM." AIDS and Behavior 17(5): 1746-1754.
Office of the Premier: Province of KwaZulu-Natal (2011). Strategy for HIV and AIDS,
STIs, and TB for the Province of KwaZulu-Natal 2012 - 2016. O. o. t. Premier.
Pietermaritzburg, Office of the Premier.
Parker, R., Khan, R. & Aggleton, P. (2000). Conspicuous by their absence? Men who
have sex with men (MSM) in developing countries: implications for HIV
prevention. Critical Public Health, 8, 329-346
Parry, C., P. Petersen, et al. (2008). "Rapid assessment of drug-related HIV risk among
men who have sex with men in three South African cities." Drug and Alcohol
Dependence 95: 45-53.
Parsons, A. N., T. Mathole, et al. (2011). The impact of global health initiatives on
access to antiretroviral therapy in South Africa. South African Health Review.
Durban Health Systems Trust. 2010/11.
PEPFAR (2011). Technical guidance on combination HIV prevention Washington DC,
Philpott, A., W. Knerr, et al. (2006). "Pleasure and Prevention: When Good Sex Is Safer
Sex." Reproductive Health Matters 14(28): 23-31.
Rao-Gupta, G., J. O. Parkhurst, et al. (2008). "Structural approaches to HIV
prevention." The Lancet 372: 764-775.
Rao, D., T. C. Kekwaletswe, et al. (2007). "Stigma and social barriers to medication
adherence with urban youth living with HIV." AIDS Care 19(1): 28-33.
Rebe, K., G. De Swardt, et al. (2013). "Towards 'men who have sex with men
appropriate' health services in South Africa." South African Journal of HIV
Medicine 14(2): 52 - 57.
Rebe, K., H. Struthers, et al. (2011). "HIV prevention and treatment for South African
men who have sex with men." South African Medical Journal 101(10): 708 -
Rebe, K. B., G. De Swardt, et al. (2010). An African Clinic Providing Targeted
Healthcare to Men-who-have-sex-with-men. 18th International Aids
Conference, Vienna, International AIDS Society.
Rebe, K. B., G. De Swardt, et al. (2013). "Towards "men who have se with men-
appropriate" health services in South Africa." SA HIV Med 14(2): 52-57.
Rebe, K. B., P. Semugoma, et al. (2012). "New HIV Prevention Technologies and Their
Relevance to MARPS in African Epidemics." SAHARA In Press.
Rebe, K. B., H. Struthers, et al. (2011). "HIV Prevention and Treatment for South African
Men Who Have Sex With Men." South African Medical Journal 101(10): 708-
Richter, M. L., M. Chersich, et al. (2013). "Characteristics, sexual behaviour and risk
factors of female, male and transgender sex workers in South Africa." South
African medical journal = Suid-Afrikaanse tydskrif vir geneeskunde 103(4): 246-
Rispel, L. and C. Metcalf (2009). "Breaking the silence: South African HIV policies and
the needs of men who have sex with men." Reproductive Health Matters
Rispel, L., C. Metcalf, et al. (2011). "You become afraid to tel them that you are gay:
health service utilisation by men who have sex with men in South African
cities." Journal of Public Health Policy 32(S1): S137-S151.
SA HIV Clinicians Society (2008). "Post-Exposure Prophylaxis." SA HIV Med June 36-45.
Sahay, S., K. S. Reddy, et al. (2011). "Optimizing adherence to antiretroviral therapy."
The Indian journal of medical research 134(6): 835-849.
Salomon, E. A., M. J. Mimiaga, et al. (2009). "Depressive symptoms, utilization of
mental health care, substance use and sexual risk among young men who have sex with men in EXPLORE: implications for age-specific interventions."
AIDS and Behavior 13(4): 811-821.
Samet, J. H., D. M. Cheng, et al. (2007). "Alcohol consumption and HIV disease
progression." Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 46(2): 194 -
SANAC (2012). National Strategic Plan on HIV, STIs and TB: 2012 - 2016. SANAC.
Sankar, A., A. Nevedal, et al. (2011). "What do we know about older adults and HIV?
A review of social and behavioral literature." AIDS Care 23(10): 1187-1207.
Scheibe, A., B. Brown, et al. (2011). Key populations, key responses: a gap analysis for
key populations and HIV in South Africa, and recommendations for the National Strategic Plan for HIV/AIDS, STIs and TB (2012 - 2016). Cape Town, Desmond Tutu HIV Foundation.
Scheibe, A., R. Orleyn, et al. (2013). The social determinants of HIV among men who
have sex with men in Cape Town. International HIV Social Sciences and
Humanities Conference. Paris.
Shisana, O. (2013). HIV/AIDS in South Africa: at last the glass is half ful . South African
AIDS Conference, Durban.
Shisana, O., T. Rehle, et al. (2009). South African national HIV prevalence, incidence,
behaviour and communication survey 2008: A turning tide among teenagers?
Cape Town, HSRC.
South African Department of Health (2003). First Line Comprehensive Management
and Control of Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs). Protocol for the
managemtn of a person with a sexual y transmitted infection according to
the essential drug list. S. A. D. o. Health, Department of Health: 1-20.
Southern African HIV Clinicians Society (2012). "Southern African guidelines for the
safe use of pre-exposure prophylaxis in men who have sex with men who are at risk for HIV infection. Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine
2012;13(2):40-55." Southern African Journal of HIV Medicine 13(2): 40-55.
Stephenson, R., C. Rentsch, et al. (2012). "Attitudes Toward Couples-Based HIV
Counseling and Testing Among MSM in Cape Town, South Africa." AIDS and
Stoloff, K., J. A. Joska, et al. (2013). "A description of common mental disorders in
men who have sex with men (MSM) referred for assessment and intervention
at an MSM clinic in Cape Town, South Africa." AIDS and Behavior 17 Suppl 1:
Sul ivan, P. S., L. Salazar, et al. (2009). "Estimating the proportion of HIV transmissions
from main sex partners among men who have sex with men in five US cities."
AIDS 23(9): 1153-1162.
Swarr, A. L. (2004). "Moffies, Artists, and Queens: Race and the Production of South
African Gay Male Drag." The Journal of Homosexuality 46(3/4): 73-89.
The Global Fund (2009). The Global Fund strategy in relation to sexual orientation
and gender identities. Geneva, The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tubercolosis,
Tucker, A. (2009). Queer Visibilities: Space, Identity and Interaction in Cape Town.
Chichester, Wiley-Blackwel .
Tucker, A., G. De Swardt, et al. (2012). "Understanding the Needs of Township Men
Who Have Sex With Men (MSM) Health Outreach Workers: Exploring the Interplay Between Volunteer Training, Social Capital and Critical
Coinsciousness." Aids Behavior.
Tucker, A., J. Liht, et al. (2013). "An exploration into the role of depression and self-
efficacy on township men who have sex with men's ability to engage in safer
sexual practices." AIDS Care.
Tun, W., M. de Mel o, et al. (2008). "Sexual risk behaviours and HIV seroprevalence
among male sex workers who have sex with men and non-sex workers in
Campinas, Brazil." Sexual y Transmitted Infections 84(6): 455-457.
Tun, W., S. Kel erman, et al. (2012). "HIV-related conspiracy beliefs and its relationships
with HIV testing and unprotected sex among men who have sex with men in
Tshwane (Pretoria), South Africa." AIDS Care 24(4): 459-467.
UNAIDS (2009). UNAIDS Action Framework: universal access for men who have sex
with men and transgender people. Geneva, UNAIDS.
UNAIDS (2013). Operational guidelines for monitoring and evaluation of HIV
programmes for sex workers, men who have sex with men, and transgender
people. Volume I: National and Sub-National Levels. Geneva, UNAIDS.
United Nations (2011). United Nations Political Declaration on HIV and AIDS:
intensifying our efforts to eliminate HIV and AIDS. New York City, United Nations.
United Nations Office On Drugs And Crime (2007). HIV and Prisons in Sub-Saharan
Africa: Opportunities for Action. Geneva,: UNODC.
Valleroy, L. A., D. A. MacKel ar, et al. (2000). "HIV prevalence and associated risks in
young men who have sex with men." Journal of the American Medical
Association 284(2): 198 - 204.
Visser, G. (2003). "Gay men, leisure space and South African cities: the case of Cape
Town." Geoforum 34: 123-137.
Vu, L., W. Tun, et al. (2011). "Levels and Correlates of Internalized Homophobia
Among Men Who Have Sex with Men in Pretoria, South Africa." AIDS and
Wariki, O. E., M. R. Mori, et al. (2011). "Behavioral interventions to reduce the
transmission of HIV infection among sex workers and their clients in high-income countries (review)." The Cochrane Col aboration(12).
Wechsberg, W. M., W. K. Luseno, et al. (2005). "Violence against substance-abusing
South African sex workers: intersection with culture and HIV risk." AIDS Care
Western Cape Department of Health (2012). Provincial Strategic Plan on HIV/AIDS,
STIs and TB 2012 - 2016. W. C. Government. Cape Town.
World Health Organisation (2007). "Post-exposure prophylaxis to prevent HIV
infection: Joint WHO/ILO guidelines on post-exposure prophylaxis to prevent
HIV infection." WHO Library Cataloguing Retrieved 21 May 2012, 2012.
World Health Organisation (2011). Guidelines: prevention and treatment of HIV and
other sexual y transmitted infections among men who have sex with men and transgender people: recommendations for a public health approach. Geneva, World Health Organisation.
World Health Organisation (2012). Prevention and treatment of HIV and other
sexual y transmitted infections for sex workers in low and middle income
countries. Geneva, World Health Organisation.
GENUINE STRESS INCONTINENCE PROTOCOL. GENUINE STRESS URGE INCONTINENCE PROTOCOL Using the NeuroTrac ETSTM in combination of electrostimulation and EMG Biofeedback in the treatment of female urinary incontinence. Anna Pawlaczyk Specialist in Gynecology Background InformationElectrical stimulation has been shown clinically to be effective in the treatment of patients with genuine stress incontinence and detrusor instability. (see figure 3)
Numéro 1 - Juillet 2013 AU SOMMAIRE Le recours à des méthodes alternatives en expérimentation FRANCOPA en bref animale est aujourd'hui une nécessité, eu égard notamment Infocentre aux exigences du règlement REACh qui requiert des résultats Point sur les méthodes alternatives rapides et fiables sur les propriétés toxiques et écotoxiques Quelques partenaires de FRANCOPA